Project
Gutenberg Consortia
Center's
World Public
Library Collection
Project Gutenberg Consortia Center Collection, a member of the World
Public Library,http://WorldLibrary.net,
bringing the world's eBook collections together.
Conditions
of Use:
This
eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with almost
no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use
it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with
this eBook or full complete details are online at: http://gutenberg.net/license.
Here are 3 of the more major items to consider:
The eBooks
on the PG sites are not 100% public domain, some of them are copyrighted
and used by permission and thus you may charge for redistribution
only via direct permission from the copyright holders.
Project
Gutenberg is a registered trademark [TM]. For any other purpose
than to redistribute eBooks containing the entire Project Gutenberg
file free of charge and with the headers intact, permission is
required.
The public
domain status is per U.S. copyright law. This eBook is from the
Project Gutenberg Consortia Center of the United States.
The mission of the Project Gutenberg Consortia Center is to provide
a similar framework for the collection of eBook collections as does
Project Gutenberg for single eBooks, operating under the practices,
and general guidelines of Project Gutenberg. The major additional
function of Project Gutenberg Consortia Center is to manage the addition
of large collections of eBooks from other eBook creation and collection
centers around the world.
For more great classic literature visit:
The
World Public Library and Project Gutenberg Consortia Center, bringing
the world's eBook collections together http://www.Gutenberg.us
"Man proposes and God disposes." There are but few important
events in the affairs of men brought about by their own choice.
Although frequently urged by friends to write my memoirs I had
determined never to do so, nor to write anything for publication. At
the age of nearly sixty-two I received an injury from a fall, which
confined me closely to the house while it did not apparently affect my
general health. This made study a pleasant pastime. Shortly after,
the rascality of a business partner developed itself by the
announcement of a failure. This was followed soon after by universal
depression of all securities, which seemed to threaten the extinction
of a good part of the income still retained, and for which I am
indebted to the kindly act of friends. At this juncture the editor of
the Century Magazine asked me to write a few articles for him. I
consented for the money it gave me; for at that moment I was living
upon borrowed money. The work I found congenial, and I determined to
continue it. The event is an important one for me, for good or evil;
I hope for the former.
In preparing these volumes for the public, I have entered upon the
task with the sincere desire to avoid doing injustice to any one,
whether on the National or Confederate side, other than the
unavoidable injustice of not making mention often where special
mention is due. There must be many errors of omission in this work,
because the subject is too large to be treated of in two volumes in
such way as to do justice to all the officers and men engaged. There
were thousands of instances, during the rebellion, of individual,
company, regimental and brigade deeds of heroism which deserve special
mention and are not here alluded to. The troops engaged in them will
have to look to the detailed reports of their individual commanders
for the full history of those deeds.
The first volume, as well as a portion of the second, was written
before I had reason to suppose I was in a critical condition of
health. Later I was reduced almost to the point of death, and it
became impossible for me to attend to anything for weeks. I have,
however, somewhat regained my strength, and am able, often, to devote
as many hours a day as a person should devote to such work. I would
have more hope of satisfying the expectation of the public if I could
have allowed myself more time. I have used my best efforts, with the
aid of my eldest son, F. D. Grant, assisted by his brothers, to verify
from the records every statement of fact given. The comments are my
own, and show how I saw the matters treated of whether others saw them
in the same light or not.
With these remarks I present these volumes to the public, asking
no favor but hoping they will meet the approval of the reader.
My family is American, and has been for generations, in all its
branches, direct and collateral.
Mathew Grant, the founder of the branch in America, of which I am
a descendant, reached Dorchester, Massachusetts, in May, 1630. In
1635 he moved to what is now Windsor, Connecticut, and was the
surveyor for that colony for more than forty years. He was also, for
many years of the time, town clerk. He was a married man when he
arrived at Dorchester, but his children were all born in this country.
His eldest son, Samuel, took lands on the east side of the
Connecticut River, opposite Windsor, which have been held and occupied
by descendants of his to this day.
I am of the eighth generation from Mathew Grant, and seventh from
Samuel. Mathew Grant's first wife died a few years after their
settlement in Windsor, and he soon after married the widow Rockwell,
who, with her first husband, had been fellow- passengers with him and
his first wife, on the ship Mary and John, from Dorchester, England,
in 1630. Mrs. Rockwell had several children by her first marriage,
and others by her second. By intermarriage, two or three generations
later, I am descended from both the wives of Mathew Grant.
In the fifth descending generation my great grandfather, Noah
Grant, and his younger brother, Solomon, held commissions in the
English army, in 1756, in the war against the French and Indians.
Both were killed that year.
My grandfather, also named Noah, was then but nine years old. At
the breaking out of the war of the Revolution, after the battles of
Concord and Lexington, he went with a Connecticut company to join the
Continental army, and was present at the battle of Bunker Hill. He
served until the fall of Yorktown, or through the entire Revolutionary
war. He must, however, have been on furlough part of the time--as I
believe most of the soldiers of that period were--for he married in
Connecticut during the war, had two children, and was a widower at the
close. Soon after this he emigrated to Westmoreland County,
Pennsylvania, and settled near the town of Greensburg in that county.
He took with him the younger of his two children, Peter Grant. The
elder, Solomon, remained with his relatives in Connecticut until old
enough to do for himself, when he emigrated to the British West
Indies.
Not long after his settlement in Pennsylvania, my grandfather,
Captain Noah Grant, married a Miss Kelly, and in 1799 he emigrated
again, this time to Ohio, and settled where the town of Deerfield now
stands. He had now five children, including Peter, a son by his first
marriage. My father, Jesse R. Grant, was the second child--oldest
son, by the second marriage.
Peter Grant went early to Maysville, Kentucky, where he was very
prosperous, married, had a family of nine children, and was drowned
at the mouth of the Kanawha River, Virginia, in 1825, being at the
time one of the wealthy men of the West.
My grandmother Grant died in 1805, leaving seven children. This
broke up the family. Captain Noah Grant was not thrifty in the way
of "laying up stores on earth," and, after the death of his second
wife, he went, with the two youngest children, to live with his son
Peter, in Maysville. The rest of the family found homes in the
neighborhood of Deerfield, my father in the family of judge Tod, the
father of the late Governor Tod, of Ohio. His industry and
independence of character were such, that I imagine his labor
compensated fully for the expense of his maintenance.
There must have been a cordiality in his welcome into the Tod
family, for to the day of his death he looked upon judge Tod and his
wife, with all the reverence he could have felt if they had been
parents instead of benefactors. I have often heard him speak of Mrs.
Tod as the most admirable woman he had ever known. He remained with
the Tod family only a few years, until old enough to learn a trade.
He went first, I believe, with his half-brother, Peter Grant, who,
though not a tanner himself, owned a tannery in Maysville, Kentucky.
Here he learned his trade, and in a few years returned to Deerfield
and worked for, and lived in the family of a Mr. Brown, the father of
John Brown--"whose body lies mouldering in the grave, while his soul
goes marching on." I have often heard my father speak of John Brown,
particularly since the events at Harper's Ferry. Brown was a boy when
they lived in the same house, but he knew him afterwards, and regarded
him as a man of great purity of character, of high moral and physical
courage, but a fanatic and extremist in whatever he advocated. It was
certainly the act of an insane man to attempt the invasion of the
South, and the overthrow of slavery, with less than twenty men.
My father set up for himself in business, establishing a tannery
at Ravenna, the county seat of Portage County. In a few years he
removed from Ravenna, and set up the same business at Point Pleasant,
Clermont County, Ohio.
During the minority of my father, the West afforded but poor
facilities for the most opulent of the youth to acquire an education,
and the majority were dependent, almost exclusively, upon their own
exertions for whatever learning they obtained. I have often heard him
say that his time at school was limited to six months, when he was
very young, too young, indeed, to learn much, or to appreciate the
advantages of an education, and to a "quarter's schooling" afterwards,
probably while living with judge Tod. But his thirst for education
was intense. He learned rapidly, and was a constant reader up to the
day of his death in his eightieth year. Books were scarce in the
Western Reserve during his youth, but he read every book he could
borrow in the neighborhood where he lived. This scarcity gave him the
early habit of studying everything he read, so that when he got
through with a book, he knew everything in it. The habit continued
through life. Even after reading the daily papers--which he never
neglected--he could give all the important information they contained.
He made himself an excellent English scholar, and before he was
twenty years of age was a constant contributor to Western newspapers,
and was also, from that time until he was fifty years old, an able
debater in the societies for this purpose, which were common in the
West at that time. He always took an active part in politics, but was
never a candidate for office, except, I believe, that he was the
first Mayor of Georgetown. He supported Jackson for the Presidency;
but he was a Whig, a great admirer of Henry Clay, and never voted for
any other democrat for high office after Jackson.
My mother's family lived in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, for
several generations. I have little information about her ancestors.
Her family took no interest in genealogy, so that my grandfather, who
died when I was sixteen years old, knew only back to his grandfather.
On the other side, my father took a great interest in the subject,
and in his researches, he found that there was an entailed estate in
Windsor, Connecticut, belonging to the family, to which his nephew,
Lawson Grant--still living--was the heir. He was so much interested
in the subject that he got his nephew to empower him to act in the
matter, and in 1832 or 1833, when I was a boy ten or eleven years
old, lie went to Windsor, proved the title beyond dispute, and
perfected the claim of the owners for a consideration--three thousand
dollars, I think. I remember the circumstance well, and remember,
too, hearing him say on his return that he found some widows living on
the property, who had little or nothing beyond their homes. From
these he refused to receive any recompense.
My mother's father, John Simpson, moved from Montgomery County,
Pennsylvania, to Clermont County, Ohio, about the year 1819, taking
with him his four children, three daughters and one son. My mother,
Hannah Simpson, was the third of these children, and was then over
twenty years of age. Her oldest sister was at that time married, and
had several children. She still lives in Clermont County at this
writing, October 5th, 1884, and is over ninety ears of age. Until her
memory failed her, a few years ago, she thought the country ruined
beyond recovery when the Democratic party lost control in 1860. Her
family, which was large, inherited her views, with the exception of
one son who settled in Kentucky before the war. He was the only one
of the children who entered the volunteer service to suppress the
rebellion.
Her brother, next of age and now past eighty-eight, is also still
living in Clermont County, within a few miles of the old homestead,
and is as active in mind as ever. He was a supporter of the
Government during the war, and remains a firm believer, that national
success by the Democratic party means irretrievable ruin.
In June, 1821, my father, Jesse R. Grant, married Hannah Simpson.
I was born on the 27th of April, 1822, at Point Pleasant, Clermont
County, Ohio. In the fall of 1823 we moved to Georgetown, the county
seat of Brown, the adjoining county cast. This place remained my
home, until at the age of seventeen, in 1839, I went to West Point.
The schools, at the time of which I write, were very indifferent.
There were no free schools, and none in which the scholars were
classified. They were all supported by subscription, and a single
teacher--who was often a man or a woman incapable of teaching much,
even if they imparted all they knew--would have thirty or forty
scholars, male and female, from the infant learning the A B C's up to
the young lady of eighteen and the boy of twenty, studying the highest
branches taught--the three R's, "Reading, 'Riting, 'Rithmetic." I
never saw an algebra, or other mathematical work higher than the
arithmetic, in Georgetown, until after I was appointed to West Point.
I then bought a work on algebra in Cincinnati; but having no teacher
it was Greek to me.
My life in Georgetown was uneventful. From the age of five or six
until seventeen, I attended the subscription schools of the village,
except during the winters of 1836-7 and 1838-9. The former period was
spent in Maysville, Kentucky, attending the school of Richardson and
Rand; the latter in Ripley, Ohio, at a private school. I was not
studious in habit, and probably did not make progress enough to
compensate for the outlay for board and tuition. At all events both
winters were spent in going over the same old arithmetic which I knew
every word of before, and repeating: "A noun is the name of a thing,"
which I had also heard my Georgetown teachers repeat, until I had come
to believe it--but I cast no reflections upon my old teacher,
Richardson. He turned out bright scholars from his school, many of
whom have filled conspicuous places in the service of their States.
Two of my contemporaries there--who, I believe, never attended any
other institution of learning--have held seats in Congress, and one,
if not both, other high offices; these are Wadsworth and Brewster.
My father was, from my earliest recollection, in comfortable
circumstances, considering the times, his place of residence, and the
community in which he lived. Mindful of his own lack of facilities
for acquiring an education, his greatest desire in maturer years was
for the education of his children. Consequently, as stated before, I
never missed a quarter from school from the time I was old enough to
attend till the time of leaving home. This did not exempt me from
labor. In my early days, every one labored more or less, in the
region where my youth was spent, and more in proportion to their
private means. It was only the very poor who were exempt. While my
father carried on the manufacture of leather and worked at the trade
himself, he owned and tilled considerable land. I detested the trade,
preferring almost any other labor; but I was fond of agriculture, and
of all employment in which horses were used. We had, among other
lands, fifty acres of forest within a mile of the village. In the
fall of the year choppers were employed to cut enough wood to last a
twelve-month. When I was seven or eight years of age, I began hauling
all the wood used in the house and shops. I could not load it on the
wagons, of course, at that time, but I could drive, and the choppers
would load, and some one at the house unload. When about eleven years
old, I was strong enough to hold a plough. From that age until
seventeen I did all the work done with horses, such as breaking up
the land, furrowing, ploughing corn and potatoes, bringing in the
crops when harvested, hauling all the wood, besides tending two or
three horses, a cow or two, and sawing wood for stoves, etc., while
still attending school. For this I was compensated by the fact that
there was never any scolding or punishing by my parents; no objection
to rational enjoyments, such as fishing, going to the creek a mile
away to swim in summer, taking a horse and visiting my grandparents in
the adjoining county, fifteen miles off, skating on the ice in winter,
or taking a horse and sleigh when there was snow on the ground.
While still quite young I had visited Cincinnati, forty-five miles
away, several times, alone; also Maysville, Kentucky, often, and once
Louisville. The journey to Louisville was a big one for a boy of that
day. I had also gone once with a two-horse carriage to Chilicothe,
about seventy miles, with a neighbor's family, who were removing to
Toledo, Ohio, and returned alone; and had gone once, in like manner,
to Flat Rock, Kentucky, about seventy miles away. On this latter
occasion I was fifteen years of age. While at Flat Rock, at the house
of a Mr. Payne, whom I was visiting with his brother, a neighbor of
ours in Georgetown, I saw a very fine saddle horse, which I rather
coveted, and proposed to Mr. Payne, the owner, to trade him for one of
the two I was driving. Payne hesitated to trade with a boy, but
asking his brother about it, the latter told him that it would be all
right, that I was allowed to do as I pleased with the horses. I was
seventy miles from home, with a carriage to take back, and Mr. Payne
said he did not know that his horse had ever had a collar on. I asked
to have him hitched to a farm wagon and we would soon see whether he
would work. It was soon evident that the horse had never worn harness
before; but he showed no viciousness, and I expressed a confidence
that I could manage him. A trade was at once struck, I receiving ten
dollars difference.
The next day Mr. Payne, of Georgetown, and I started on our
return. We got along very well for a few miles, when we encountered
a ferocious dog that frightened the horses and made them run. The new
animal kicked at every jump he made. I got the horses stopped,
however, before any damage was done, and without running into
anything. After giving them a little rest, to quiet their fears, we
started again. That instant the new horse kicked, and started to run
once more. The road we were on, struck the turnpike within half a
mile of the point where the second runaway commenced, and there there
was an embankment twenty or more feet deep on the opposite side of the
pike. I got the horses stopped on the very brink of the precipice.
My new horse was terribly frightened and trembled like an aspen; but
he was not half so badly frightened as my companion, Mr. Payne, who
deserted me after this last experience, and took passage on a freight
wagon for Maysville. Every time I attempted to start, my new horse
would commence to kick. I was in quite a dilemma for a time. Once in
Maysville I could borrow a horse from an uncle who lived there; but I
was more than a day's travel from that point. Finally I took out my
bandanna--the style of handkerchief in universal use then--and with
this blindfolded my horse. In this way I reached Maysville safely the
next day, no doubt much to the surprise of my friend. Here I borrowed
a horse from my uncle, and the following day we proceeded on our
journey.
About half my school-days in Georgetown were spent at the school
of John D. White, a North Carolinian, and the father of Chilton White
who represented the district in Congress for one term during the
rebellion. Mr. White was always a Democrat in politics, and Chilton
followed his father. He had two older brothers--all three being
school-mates of mine at their father's school--who did not go the same
way. The second brother died before the rebellion began; he was a
Whig, and afterwards a Republican. His oldest brother was a
Republican and brave soldier during the rebellion. Chilton is
reported as having told of an earlier horse-trade of mine. As he told
the story, there was a Mr. Ralston living within a few miles of the
village, who owned a colt which I very much wanted. My father had
offered twenty dollars for it, but Ralston wanted twenty-five. I was
so anxious to have the colt, that after the owner left, I begged to be
allowed to take him at the price demanded. My father yielded, but
said twenty dollars was all the horse was worth, and told me to offer
that price; if it was not accepted I was to offer twenty-two and a
half, and if that would not get him, to give the twenty-five. I at
once mounted a horse and went for the colt. When I got to Mr.
Ralston's house, I said to him: " Papa says I may offer you twenty
dollars for the colt, but if you won't take that, I am to offer
twenty-two and a half, and if you won't take that, to give you
twenty-five." It would not require a Connecticut man to guess the
price finally agreed upon. This story is nearly true. I certainly
showed very plainly that I had come for the colt and meant to have
him. I could not have been over eight years old at the time. This
transaction caused me great heart-burning. The story got out among the
boys of the village, and it was a long time before I heard the last of
it. Boys enjoy the misery of their companions, at least village boys
in that day did, and in later life I have found that all adults are
not free from the peculiarity. I kept the horse until he was four
years old, when he went blind, and I sold him for twenty dollars.
When I went to Maysville to school, in 1836, at the age of fourteen,
I recognized my colt as one of the blind horses working on the
tread-wheel of the ferry-boat.
I have describes enough of my early life to give an impression of
the whole. I did not like to work; but I did as much of it, while
young, as grown men can be hired to do in these days, and attended
school at the same time. I had as many privileges as any boy in the
village, and probably more than most of them. I have no recollection
of ever having been punished at home, either by scolding or by the
rod. But at school the case was different. The rod was freely used
there, and I was not exempt from its influence. I can see John D.
White--the school teacher--now, with his long beech switch always in
his hand. It was not always the same one, either. Switches were
brought in bundles, from a beech wood near the school house, by the
boys for whose benefit they were intended. Often a whole bundle
would be used up in a single day. I never had any hard feelings
against my teacher, either while attending the school, or in later
years when reflecting upon my experience. Mr. White was a kindhearted
man, and was much respected by the community in which he lived. He
only followed the universal custom of the period, and that under which
he had received his own education.
In the winter of 1838-9 I was attending school at Ripley, only ten
miles distant from Georgetown, but spent the Christmas holidays at
home. During this vacation my father received a letter from the
Honorable Thomas Morris, then United States Senator from Ohio. When
he read it he said to me, Ulysses, I believe you are going to receive
the appointment." "What appointment?" I inquired. To West Point; I
have applied for it." "But I won't go," I said. He said he thought I
would, AND I THOUGHT SO TOO, IF HE DID. I really had no objection to
going to West Point, except that I had a very exalted idea of the
acquirements necessary to get through. I did not believe I possessed
them, and could not bear the idea of failing. There had been four
boys from our village, or its immediate neighborhood, who had been
graduated from West Point, and never a failure of any one appointed
from Georgetown, except in the case of the one whose place I was to
take. He was the son of Dr. Bailey, our nearest and most intimate
neighbor. Young Bailey had been appointed in 1837. Finding before
the January examination following, that he could not pass, he resigned
and went to a private school, and remained there until the following
year, when he was reappointed. Before the next examination he was
dismissed. Dr. Bailey was a proud and sensitive man, and felt the
failure of his son so keenly that he forbade his return home. There
were no telegraphs in those days to disseminate news rapidly, no
railroads west of the Alleghanies, and but few east; and above ail,
there were no reporters prying into other people's private affairs.
Consequently it did not become generally known that there was a
vacancy at West Point from our district until I was appointed. I
presume Mrs. Bailey confided to my mother the fact that Bartlett had
been dismissed, and that the doctor had forbidden his son's return
home.
The Honorable Thomas L. Hamer, one of the ablest men Ohio ever
produced, was our member of Congress at the time, and had the right
of nomination. He and my father had been members of the same debating
society (where they were generally pitted on opposite sides), and
intimate personal friends from their early manhood up to a few years
before. In politics they differed. Hamer was a life-long Democrat,
while my father was a Whig. They had a warm discussion, which finally
became angry--over some act of President Jackson, the removal of the
deposit of public moneys, I think--after which they never spoke until
after my appointment. I know both of them felt badly over this
estrangement, and would have been glad at any time to come to a
reconciliation; but neither would make the advance. Under these
circumstances my father would not write to Hamer for the appointment,
but he wrote to Thomas Morris, United States Senator from Ohio,
informing him that there was a vacancy at West Point from our
district, and that he would be glad if I could be appointed to fill
it. This letter, I presume, was turned over to Mr. Hamer, and, as
there was no other applicant, he cheerfully appointed me. This healed
the breach between the two, never after reopened.
Besides the argument used by my father in favor of my going to
West Point--that "he thought I would go"--there was another very
strong inducement. I had always a great desire to travel. I was
already the best travelled boy in Georgetown, except the sons of one
man, John Walker, who had emigrated to Texas with his family, and
immigrated back as soon as he could get the means to do so. In his
short stay in Texas he acquired a very different opinion of the
country from what one would form going there now.
I had been east to Wheeling, Virginia, and north to the Western
Reserve, in Ohio, west to Louisville, and south to Bourbon County,
Kentucky, besides having driven or ridden pretty much over the whole
country within fifty miles of home. Going to West Point would give me
the opportunity of visiting the two great cities of the continent,
Philadelphia and New York. This was enough. When these places were
visited I would have been glad to have had a steamboat or railroad
collision, or any other accident happen, by which I might have
received a temporary injury sufficient to make me ineligible, for a
time, to enter the Academy. Nothing of the kind occurred, and I had
to face the music.
Georgetown has a remarkable record for a western village. It is,
and has been from its earliest existence, a democratic town. There
was probably no time during the rebellion when, if the opportunity
could have been afforded, it would not have voted for Jefferson Davis
for President of the United States, over Mr. Lincoln, or any other
representative of his party; unless it was immediately after some of
John Morgan's men, in his celebrated raid through Ohio, spent a few
hours in the village. The rebels helped themselves to whatever they
could find, horses, boots and shoes, especially horses, and many
ordered meals to be prepared for them by the families. This was no
doubt a far pleasanter duty for some families than it would have been
to render a like service for Union soldiers. The line between the
Rebel and Union element in Georgetown was so marked that it led to
divisions even in the churches. There were churches in that part of
Ohio where treason was preached regularly, and where, to secure
membership, hostility to the government, to the war and to the
liberation of the slaves, was far more essential than a belief in the
authenticity or credibility of the Bible. There were men in
Georgetown who filled all the requirements for membership in these
churches.
Yet this far-off western village, with a population, including old
and young, male and female, of about one thousand--about enough for
the organization of a single regiment if all had been men capable of
bearing arms--furnished the Union army four general officers and one
colonel, West Point graduates, and nine generals and field officers of
Volunteers, that I can think of. Of the graduates from West Point, all
had citizenship elsewhere at the breaking out of the rebellion, except
possibly General A. V. Kautz, who had remained in the army from his
graduation. Two of the colonels also entered the service from other
localities. The other seven, General McGroierty, Colonels White,
Fyffe, Loudon and Marshall, Majors King and Bailey, were all residents
of Georgetown when the war broke out, and all of them, who were alive
at the close, returned there. Major Bailey was the cadet who had
preceded me at West Point. He was killed in West Virginia, in his
first engagement. As far as I know, every boy who has entered West
Point from that village since my time has been graduated.
I took passage on a steamer at Ripley, Ohio, for Pittsburg, about
the middle of May, 1839. Western boats at that day did not make
regular trips at stated times, but would stop anywhere, and for any
length of time, for passengers or freight. I have myself been
detained two or three days at a place after steam was up, the gang
planks, all but one, drawn in, and after the time advertised for
starting had expired. On this occasion we had no vexatious delays,
and in about three days Pittsburg was reached. From Pittsburg I chose
passage by the canal to Harrisburg, rather than by the more
expeditious stage. This gave a better opportunity of enjoying the
fine scenery of Western Pennsylvania, and I had rather a dread of
reaching my destination at all. At that time the canal was much
patronized by travellers, and, with the comfortable packets of the
period, no mode of conveyance could be more pleasant, when time was
not an object. From Harrisburg to Philadelphia there was a railroad,
the first I had ever seen, except the one on which I had just crossed
the summit of the Alleghany Mountains, and over which canal boats were
transported. In travelling by the road from Harrisburg, I thought the
perfection of rapid transit had been reached. We travelled at least
eighteen miles an hour, when at full speed, and made the whole
distance averaging probably as much as twelve miles an hour. This
seemed like annihilating space. I stopped five days in Philadelphia,
saw about every street in the city, attended the theatre, visited
Girard College (which was then in course of construction), and got
reprimanded from home afterwards, for dallying by the way so long. My
sojourn in New York was shorter, but long enough to enable me to see
the city very well. I reported at West Point on the 30th or 31st of
May, and about two weeks later passed my examination for admission,
without difficulty, very much to my surprise.
A military life had no charms for me, and I had not the faintest
idea of staying in the army even if I should be graduated, which I
did not expect. The encampment which preceded the commence- ment of
academic studies was very wearisome and uninter- esting. When the
28th of August came--the date for breaking up camp and going into
barracks--I felt as though I had been at West Point always, and that
if I staid to graduation, I would have to remain always. I did not
take hold of my studies with avidity, in fact I rarely ever read over
a lesson the second time during my entire cadetship. I could not sit
in my room doing nothing. There is a fine library connected with the
Academy from which cadets can get books to read in their quarters. I
devoted more time to these, than to books relating to the course of
studies. Much of the time, I am sorry to say, was devoted to novels,
but not those of a trashy sort. I read all of Bulwer's then
published, Cooper's, Marryat's, Scott's, Washington Irving's works,
Lever's, and many others that I do not now remember. Mathematics was
very easy to me, so that when January came, I passed the examination,
taking a good standing in that branch. In French, the only other
study at that time in the first year's course, my standing was very
low. In fact, if the class had been turned the other end foremost I
should have been near head. I never succeeded in getting squarely at
either end of my class, in any one study, during the four years. I
came near it in French, artillery, infantry and cavalry tactics, and
conduct.
Early in the session of the Congress which met in December, 1839,
a bill was discussed abolishing the Military Academy. I saw in this
an honorable way to obtain a discharge, and read the debates with much
interest, but with impatience at the delay in taking action, for I was
selfish enough to favor the bill. It never passed, and a year later,
although the time hung drearily with me, I would have been sorry to
have seen it succeed. My idea then was to get through the course,
secure a detail for a few years as assistant professor of mathematics
at the Academy, and afterwards obtain a permanent position as
professor in some respectable college; but circumstances always did
shape my course different from my plans.
At the end of two years the class received the usual furlough,
extending from the close of the June examination to the 28th of
August. This I enjoyed beyond any other period of my life. My
father had sold out his business in Georgetown--where my youth had
been spent, and to which my day-dreams carried me back as my future
home, if I should ever be able to retire on a competency. He had
moved to Bethel, only twelve miles away, in the adjoining county of
Clermont, and had bought a young horse that had never been in harness,
for my special use under the saddle during my furlough. Most of my
time was spent among my old school-mates--these ten weeks were shorter
than one week at West Point.
Persons acquainted with the Academy know that the corps of cadets
is divided into four companies for the purpose of military exercises.
These companies are officered from the cadets, the superintendent and
commandant selecting the officers for their military bearing and
qualifications. The adjutant, quartermaster, four captains and twelve
lieutenants are taken from the first, or Senior class; the sergeants
from the second, or junior class; and the corporals from the third, or
Sophomore class. I had not been "called out" as a corporal, but when
I returned from furlough I found myself the last but one--about my
standing in all the tactics--of eighteen sergeants. The promotion
was too much for me. That year my standing in the class--as shown by
the number of demerits of the year--was about the same as it was among
the sergeants, and I was dropped, and served the fourth year as a
private.
During my first year's encampment General Scott visited West
Point, and reviewed the cadets. With his commanding figure, his
quite colossal size and showy uniform, I thought him the finest
specimen of manhood my eyes had ever beheld, and the most to be
envied. I could never resemble him in appearance, but I believe I
did have a presentiment for a moment that some day I should occupy his
place on review--although I had no intention then of remaining in the
army. My experience in a horse-trade ten years before, and the
ridicule it caused me, were too fresh in my mind for me to communicate
this presentiment to even my most intimate chum. The next summer
Martin Van Buren, then President of the United States, visited West
Point and reviewed the cadets; he did not impress me with the awe
which Scott had inspired. In fact I regarded General Scott and
Captain C. F. Smith, the Commandant of Cadets, as the two men most to
be envied in the nation. I retained a high regard for both up to the
day of their death.
The last two years wore away more rapidly than the first two, but
they still seemed about five times as long as Ohio years, to me. At
last all the examinations were passed, and the members of the class
were called upon to record their choice of arms of service and
regiments. I was anxious to enter the cavalry, or dragoons as they
were then called, but there was only one regiment of dragoons in the
Army at that time, and attached to that, besides the full complement
of officers, there were at least four brevet second lieutenants. I
recorded therefore my first choice, dragoons; second, 4th infantry;
and got the latter. Again there was a furlough--or, more properly
speaking, leave of absence for the class were now commissioned
officers--this time to the end of September. Again I went to Ohio to
spend my vacation among my old school-mates; and again I found a fine
saddle horse purchased for my special use, besides a horse and buggy
that I could drive--but I was not in a physical condition to enjoy
myself quite as well as on the former occasion. For six months before
graduation I had had a desperate cough ("Tyler's grip" it was called),
and I was very much reduced, weighing but one hundred and seventeen
pounds, just my weight at entrance, though I had grown six inches in
stature in the mean time. There was consumption in my father's
family, two of his brothers having died of that disease, which made
my symptoms more alarming. The brother and sister next younger than
myself died, during the rebellion, of the same disease, and I seemed
the most promising subject for it of the three in 1843.
Having made alternate choice of two different arms of service with
different uniforms, I could not get a uniform suit until notified of
my assignment. I left my measurement with a tailor, with directions
not to make the uniform until I notified him whether it was to be for
infantry or dragoons. Notice did not reach me for several weeks, and
then it took at least a week to get the letter of instructions to the
tailor and two more to make the clothes and have them sent to me.
This was a time of great suspense. I was impatient to get on my
uniform and see how it looked, and probably wanted my old
school-mates, particularly the girls, to see me in it.
The conceit was knocked out of me by two little circumstances that
happened soon after the arrival of the clothes, which gave me a
distaste for military uniform that I never recovered from. Soon after
the arrival of the suit I donned it, and put off for Cincinnati on
horseback. While I was riding along a street of that city, imagining
that every one was looking at me, with a feeling akin to mine when I
first saw General Scott, a little urchin, bareheaded, footed, with
dirty and ragged pants held up by bare a single gallows--that's what
suspenders were called then--and a shirt that had not seen a wash-tub
for weeks, turned to me and cried: "Soldier! will you work? No,
sir--ee; I'll sell my shirt first!!" The horse trade and its dire
consequences were recalled to mind.
The other circumstance occurred at home. Opposite our house in
Bethel stood the old stage tavern where "man and beast" found
accommodation, The stable-man was rather dissipated, but possessed of
some humor. On my return I found him parading the streets, and
attending in the stable, barefooted, but in a pair of sky-blue nankeen
pantaloons--just the color of my uniform trousers--with a strip of
white cotton sheeting sewed down the outside seams in imitation of
mine. The joke was a huge one in the mind of many of the people, and
was much enjoyed by them; but I did not appreciate it so highly.
During the remainder of my leave of absence, my time was spent in
visiting friends in Georgetown and Cincinnati, and occasionally other
towns in that part of the State.
On the 30th of September I reported for duty at Jefferson
Barracks, St. Louis, with the 4th United States infantry. It was the
largest military post in the country at that time, being garrisoned by
sixteen companies of infantry, eight of the 3d regiment, the remainder
of the 4th. Colonel Steven Kearney, one of the ablest officers of the
day, commanded the post, and under him discipline was kept at a high
standard, but without vexatious rules or regulations. Every drill and
roll-call had to be attended, but in the intervals officers were
permitted to enjoy themselves, leaving the garrison, and going where
they pleased, without making written application to state where they
were going for how long, etc., so that they were back for their next
duty. It did seem to me, in my early army days, that too many of the
older officers, when they came to command posts, made it a study to
think what orders they could publish to annoy their subordinates and
render them uncomfortable. I noticed, however, a few years later,
when the Mexican war broke out, that most of this class of officers
discovered they were possessed of disabilities which entirely
incapacitated them for active field service. They had the moral
courage to proclaim it, too. They were right; but they did not always
give their disease the right name.
At West Point I had a class-mate--in the last year of our studies
he was room-mate also--F. T. Dent, whose family resided some five
miles west of Jefferson Barracks. Two of his unmarried brothers were
living at home at that time, and as I had taken with me from Ohio, my
horse, saddle and bridle, I soon found my way out to White Haven, the
name of the Dent estate. As I found the family congenial my visits
became frequent. There were at home, besides the young men, two
daughters, one a school miss of fifteen, the other a girl of eight or
nine. There was still an older daughter of seventeen, who had been
spending several years at boarding-school in St. Louis, but who,
though through school, had not yet returned home. She was spending
the winter in the city with connections, the family of Colonel John
O'Fallon, well known in St. Louis. In February she returned to her
country home. After that I do not know but my visits became more
frequent; they certainly did become more enjoyable. We would often
take walks, or go on horseback to visit the neighbors, until I became
quite well acquainted in that vicinity. Sometimes one of the brothers
would accompany us, sometimes one of the younger sisters. If the 4th
infantry had remained at Jefferson Barracks it is possible, even
probable, that this life might have continued for some years without
my finding out that there was anything serious the matter with me;
but in the following May a circumstance occurred which developed my
sentiment so palpably that there was no mistaking it.
The annexation of Texas was at this time the subject of violent
discussion in Congress, in the press, and by individuals. The
administration of President Tyler, then in power, was making the most
strenuous efforts to effect the annexation, which was, indeed, the
great and absorbing question of the day. During these discussions the
greater part of the single rifle regiment in the army--the 2d
dragoons, which had been dismounted a year or two before, and
designated "Dismounted Rifles"--was stationed at Fort Jessup,
Louisiana, some twenty-five miles east of the Texas line, to observe
the frontier. About the 1st of May the 3d infantry was ordered from
Jefferson Barracks to Louisiana, to go into camp in the neighborhood
of Fort Jessup, and there await further orders. The troops were
embarked on steamers and were on their way down the Mississippi within
a few days after the receipt of this order. About the time they
started I obtained a leave of absence for twenty days to go to Ohio to
visit my parents. I was obliged to go to St. Louis to take a steamer
for Louisville or Cincinnati, or the first steamer going up the Ohio
River to any point. Before I left St. Louis orders were received at
Jefferson Barracks for the 4th infantry to follow the 3d. A messenger
was sent after me to stop my leaving; but before he could reach me I
was off, totally ignorant of these events. A day or two after my
arrival at Bethel I received a letter from a classmate and fellow
lieutenant in the 4th, informing me of the circumstances related
above, and advising me not to open any letter post marked St. Louis or
Jefferson Barracks, until the expiration of my leave, and saying that
he would pack up my things and take them along for me. His advice
was not necessary, for no other letter was sent to me. I now
discovered that I was exceedingly anxious to get back to Jefferson
Barracks, and I understood the reason without explanation from any
one. My leave of absence required me to report for duty, at Jefferson
Barracks, at the end of twenty days. I knew my regiment had gone up
the Red River, but I was not disposed to break the letter of my leave;
besides, if I had proceeded to Louisiana direct, I could not have
reached there until after the expiration of my leave. Accordingly, at
the end of the twenty days, I reported for duty to Lieutenant Ewell,
commanding at Jefferson Barracks, handing him at the same time my
leave of absence. After noticing the phraseology of the order--leaves
of absence were generally worded, "at the end of which time he will
report for duty with his proper command"--he said he would give me an
order to join my regiment in Louisiana. I then asked for a few days'
leave before starting, which he readily granted. This was the same
Ewell who acquired considerable reputation as a Confederate general
during the rebellion. He was a man much esteemed, and deservedly so,
in the old army, and proved himself a gallant and efficient officer
in two wars--both in my estimation unholy.
I immediately procured a horse and started for the country, taking
no baggage with me, of course. There is an insignificant creek--the
Gravois--between Jefferson Barracks and the place to which I was
going, and at that day there was not a bridge over it from its source
to its mouth. There is not water enough in the creek at ordinary
stages to run a coffee mill, and at low water there is none running
whatever. On this occasion it had been raining heavily, and, when the
creek was reached, I found the banks full to overflowing, and the
current rapid. I looked at it a moment to consider what to do. One
of my superstitions had always been when I started to go any where, or
to do anything, not to turn back, or stop until the thing intended was
accomplished. I have frequently started to go to places where I had
never been and to which I did not know the way, depending upon making
inquiries on the road, and if I got past the place without knowing it,
instead of turning back, I would go on until a road was found turning
in the right direction, take that, and come in by the other side. So
I struck into the stream, and in an instant the horse was swimming and
I being carried down by the current. I headed the horse towards the
other bank and soon reached it, wet through and without other clothes
on that side of the stream. I went on, however, to my destination and
borrowed a dry suit from my--future--brother-in-law. We were not of
the same size, but the clothes answered every purpose until I got
more of my own.
Before I returned I mustered up courage to make known, in the most
awkward manner imaginable, the discovery I had made on learning that
the 4th infantry had been ordered away from Jefferson Barracks. The
young lady afterwards admitted that she too, although until then she
had never looked upon me other than as a visitor whose company was
agreeable to her, had experienced a depression of spirits she could
not account for when the regiment left. Before separating it was
definitely understood that at a convenient time we would join our
fortunes, and not let the removal of a regiment trouble us. This was
in May, 1844. It was the 22d of August, 1848, before the fulfilment
of this agreement. My duties kept me on the frontier of Louisiana
with the Army of Observation during the pendency of Annexation; and
afterwards I was absent through the war with Mexico, provoked by the
action of the army, if not by the annexation itself During that time
there was a constant correspondence between Miss Dent and myself, but
we only met once in the period of four years and three months. In
May, 1845, I procured a leave for twenty days, visited St. Louis, and
obtained the consent of the parents for the union, which had not been
asked for before.
As already stated, it was never my intention to remain in the army
long, but to prepare myself for a professorship in some college.
Accordingly, soon after I was settled at Jefferson Barracks, I wrote
a letter to Professor Church--Professor of Mathematics at West
Point--requesting him to ask my designation as his assistant, when
next a detail had to be made. Assistant professors at West Point are
all officers of the army, supposed to be selected for their special
fitness for the particular branch of study they are assigned to teach.
The answer from Professor Church was entirely satisfactory, and no
doubt I should have been detailed a year or two later but for the
Mexican War coming on. Accordingly I laid out for myself a course of
studies to be pursued in garrison, with regularity, if not
persistency. I reviewed my West Point course of mathematics during
the seven months at Jefferson Barracks, and read many valuable
historical works, besides an occasional novel. To help my memory I
kept a book in which I would write up, from time to time, my
recollections of all I had read since last posting it. When the
regiment was ordered away, I being absent at the time, my effects were
packed up by Lieutenant Haslett, of the 4th infantry, and taken along.
I never saw my journal after, nor did I ever keep another, except for
a portion of the time while travelling abroad. Often since a fear has
crossed my mind lest that book might turn up yet, and fall into the
hands of some malicious person who would publish it. I know its
appearance would cause me as much heart-burning as my youthful
horse-trade, or the later rebuke for wearing uniform clothes.
The 3d infantry had selected camping grounds on the reservation at
Fort Jessup, about midway between the Red River and the Sabine. Our
orders required us to go into camp in the same neighborhood, and await
further instructions. Those authorized to do so selected a place in
the pine woods, between the old town of Natchitoches and Grand Ecore,
about three miles from each, and on high ground back from the river.
The place was given the name of Camp Salubrity, and proved entitled
to it. The camp was on a high, sandy, pine ridge, with spring branches
in the valley, in front and rear. The springs furnished an abundance
of cool, pure water, and the ridge was above the flight of mosquitoes,
which abound in that region in great multitudes and of great voracity.
In the valley they swarmed in myriads, but never came to the summit
of the ridge. The regiment occupied this camp six months before the
first death occurred, and that was caused by an accident.
There was no intimation given that the removal of the 3d and 4th
regiments of infantry to the western border of Louisiana was
occasioned in any way by the prospective annexation of Texas, but it
was generally understood that such was the case. Ostensibly we were
intended to prevent filibustering into Texas, but really as a menace
to Mexico in case she appeared to contemplate war. Generally the
officers of the army were indifferent whether the annexation was
consummated or not; but not so all of them. For myself, I was
bitterly opposed to the measure, and to this day regard the war, which
resulted, as one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a
weaker nation. It was an instance of a republic following the bad
example of European monarchies, in not considering justice in their
desire to acquire additional territory. Texas was originally a state
belonging to the republic of Mexico. It extended from the Sabine
River on the east to the Rio Grande on the west, and from the Gulf of
Mexico on the south and east to the territory of the United States and
New Mexico--another Mexican state at that time--on the north and west.
An empire in territory, it had but a very sparse population, until
settled by Americans who had received authority from Mexico to
colonize. These colonists paid very little attention to the supreme
government, and introduced slavery into the state almost from the
start, though the constitution of Mexico did not, nor does it now,
sanction that institution. Soon they set up an independent government
of their own, and war existed, between Texas and Mexico, in name from
that time until 1836, when active hostilities very nearly ceased upon
the capture of Santa Anna, the Mexican President. Before long,
however, the same people--who with permission of Mexico had colonized
Texas, and afterwards set up slavery there, and then seceded as soon
as they felt strong enough to do so--offered themselves and the State
to the United States, and in 1845 their offer was accepted. The
occupation, separation and annexation were, from the inception of the
movement to its final consummation, a conspiracy to acquire territory
out of which slave states might be formed for the American Union.
Even if the annexation itself could be justified, the manner in
which the subsequent war was forced upon Mexico cannot. The fact is,
annexationists wanted more territory than they could possibly lay any
claim to, as part of the new acquisition. Texas, as an independent
State, never had exercised jurisdiction over the territory between the
Nueces River and the Rio Grande. Mexico had never recognized the
independence of Texas, and maintained that, even if independent, the
State had no claim south of the Nueces. I am aware that a treaty,
made by the Texans with Santa Anna while he was under duress, ceded
all the territory between the Nueces and the Rio Grande--, but he was
a prisoner of war when the treaty was made, and his life was in
jeopardy. He knew, too, that he deserved execution at the hands of
the Texans, if they should ever capture him. The Texans, if they had
taken his life, would have only followed the example set by Santa Anna
himself a few years before, when he executed the entire garrison of
the Alamo and the villagers of Goliad.
In taking military possession of Texas after annexation, the army
of occupation, under General Taylor, was directed to occupy the
disputed territory. The army did not stop at the Nueces and offer to
negotiate for a settlement of the boundary question, but went beyond,
apparently in order to force Mexico to initiate war. It is to the
credit of the American nation, however, that after conquering Mexico,
and while practically holding the country in our possession, so that
we could have retained the whole of it, or made any terms we chose, we
paid a round sum for the additional territory taken; more than it was
worth, or was likely to be, to Mexico. To us it was an empire and of
incalculable value; but it might have been obtained by other means.
The Southern rebellion was largely the outgrowth of the Mexican war.
Nations, like individuals, are punished for their transgressions. We
got our punishment in the most sanguinary and expensive war of modern
times.
The 4th infantry went into camp at Salubrity in the month of May,
1844, with instructions, as I have said, to await further orders. At
first, officers and men occupied ordinary tents. As the summer heat
increased these were covered by sheds to break the rays of the sun.
The summer was whiled away in social enjoyments among the officers,
in visiting those stationed at, and near, Fort Jessup, twenty-five
miles away, visiting the planters on the Red River, and the citizens
of Natchitoches and Grand Ecore. There was much pleasant intercourse
between the inhabitants and the officers of the army. I retain very
agreeable recollections of my stay at Camp Salubrity, and of the
acquaintances made there, and no doubt my feeling is shared by the
few officers living who were there at the time. I can call to mind
only two officers of the 4th infantry, besides myself, who were at
Camp Salubrity with the regiment, who are now alive.
With a war in prospect, and belonging to a regiment that had an
unusual number of officers detailed on special duty away from the
regiment, my hopes of being ordered to West Point as instructor
vanished. At the time of which I now write, officers in the
quartermaster's, commissary's and adjutant--general's departments were
appointed from the line of the army, and did not vacate their
regimental commissions until their regimental and staff commissions
were for the same grades. Generally lieutenants were appointed to
captaincies to fill vacancies in the staff corps. If they should
reach a captaincy in the line before they arrived at a majority in the
staff, they would elect which commission they would retain. In the
4th infantry, in 1844, at least six line officers were on duty in the
staff, and therefore permanently detached from the regiment. Under
these circumstances I gave up everything like a special course of
reading, and only read thereafter for my own amusement, and not very
much for that, until the war was over. I kept a horse and rode, and
staid out of doors most of the time by day, and entirely recovered
from the cough which I had carried from West Point, and from all
indications of consumption. I have often thought that my life was
saved, and my health restored, by exercise and exposure, enforced by
an administrative act, and a war, both of which I disapproved.
As summer wore away, and cool days and colder nights came upon us,
the tents We were occupying ceased to afford comfortable quarters; and
"further orders" not reaching us, we began to look about to remedy the
hardship. Men were put to work getting out timber to build huts, and
in a very short time all were comfortably housed--privates as well as
officers. The outlay by the government in accomplishing this was
nothing, or nearly nothing. The winter was spent more agreeably than
the summer had been. There were occasional parties given by the
planters along the "coast"--as the bottom lands on the Red River were
called. The climate was delightful.
Near the close of the short session of Congress of 1844-5, the
bill for the annexation of Texas to the United States was passed. It
reached President Tyler on the 1st of March, 1845, and promptly
received his approval. When the news reached us we began to look
again for "further orders." They did not arrive promptly, and on the
1st of May following I asked and obtained a leave of absence for
twenty days, for the purpose of visiting-- St. Louis. The object of
this visit has been before stated.
Early in July the long expected orders were received, but they
only took the regiment to New Orleans Barracks. We reached there
before the middle of the month, and again waited weeks for still
further orders. The yellow fever was raging in New Orleans during the
time we remained there, and the streets of the city had the appearance
of a continuous well-observed Sunday. I recollect but one occasion
when this observance seemed to be broken by the inhabitants. One
morning about daylight I happened to be awake, and, hearing the
discharge of a rifle not far off, I looked out to ascertain where the
sound came from. I observed a couple of clusters of men near by, and
learned afterwards that "it was nothing; only a couple of gentlemen
deciding a difference of opinion with rifles, at twenty paces. "I do
not remember if either was killed, or even hurt, but no doubt the
question of difference was settled satisfactorily, and "honorably," in
the estimation of the parties engaged. I do not believe I ever would
have the courage to fight a duel. If any man should wrong me to the
extent of my being willing to kill him, I would not be willing to give
him the choice of weapons with which it should be done, and of the
time, place and distance separating us, when I executed him. If I
should do another such a wrong as to justify him in killing me, I
would make any reasonable atonement within my power, if convinced of
the wrong done. I place my opposition to duelling on higher grounds
than here stated. No doubt a majority of the duels fought have been
for want of moral courage on the part of those engaged to decline.
At Camp Salubrity, and when we went to New Orleans Barracks, the
4th infantry was commanded by Colonel Vose, then an old gentleman who
had not commanded on drill for a number of years. He was not a man to
discover infirmity in the presence of danger. It now appeared that
war was imminent, and he felt that it was his duty to brush up his
tactics. Accordingly, when we got settled down at our new post, he
took command of the regiment at a battalion drill. Only two or three
evolutions had been gone through when he dismissed the battalion, and,
turning to go to his own quarters, dropped dead. He had not been
complaining of ill health, but no doubt died of heart disease. He was
a most estimable man, of exemplary habits, and by no means the author
of his own disease.
Early in September the regiment left New Orleans for Corpus
Christi, now in Texas. Ocean steamers were not then common, and the
passage was made in sailing vessels. At that time there was not more
than three feet of water in the channel at the outlet of Corpus
Christi Bay; the debarkation, therefore, had to take place by small
steamers, and at an island in the channel called Shell Is land, the
ships anchoring some miles out from shore. This made the work slow,
and as the army was only supplied with one or two steamers, it took a
number of days to effect the landing of a single regiment with its
stores, camp and garrison equipage, etc. There happened to be
pleasant weather while this was going on, but the land-swell was so
great that when the ship and steamer were on opposite sides of the
same wave they would be at considerable distance apart. The men and
baggage were let down to a point higher than the lower deck of the
steamer, and when ship and steamer got into the trough between the
waves, and were close together, the load would be drawn over the
steamer and rapidly run down until it rested on the deck.
After I had gone ashore, and had been on guard several days at
Shell Island, quite six miles from the ship, I had occasion for some
reason or other to return on board. While on the Suviah--I think that
was the name of our vessel--I heard a tremendous racket at the other
end of the ship, and much and excited sailor language, such as "damn
your eyes," etc. In a moment or two the captain, who was an excitable
little man, dying with consumption, and not weighing much over a
hundred pounds, came running out, carrying a sabre nearly as large and
as heavy as he was, and cry ing, that his men had mutinied. It was
necessary to sustain the captain without question, and in a few
minutes all the sailors charged with mutiny were in irons. I rather
felt for a time a wish that I had not gone aboard just then. As the
men charged with mutiny submitted to being placed in irons without
resistance, I always doubted if they knew that they had mutinied until
they were told.
By the time I was ready to leave the ship again I thought I had
learned enough of the working of the double and single pulley, by
which passengers were let down from the upper deck of the ship to the
steamer below, and determined to let myself down without assistance.
Without saying anything of my intentions to any one, I mounted the
railing, and taking hold of the centre rope, just below the upper
block, I put one foot on the hook below the lower block, and stepped
off just as I did so some one called out "hold on." It was too late.
I tried to "hold on" with all my might, but my heels went up, and my
head went down so rapidly that my hold broke, and I plunged head
foremost into the water, some twenty-five feet below, with such
velocity that it seemed to me I never would stop. When I came to the
surface again, being a fair swimmer, and not having lost my presence
of mind, I swam around until a bucket was let down for me, and I was
drawn up without a scratch or injury. I do not believe there was a man
on board who sympathized with me in the least when they found me
uninjured. I rather enjoyed the joke myself The captain of the Suviah
died of his disease a few months later, and I believe before the
mutineers were tried. I hope they got clear, because, as before
stated, I always thought the mutiny was all in the brain of a very
weak and sick man.
After reaching shore, or Shell Island, the labor of getting to
Corpus Christi was slow and tedious. There was, if my memory serves
me, but one small steamer to transport troops and baggage when the 4th
infantry arrived. Others were procured later. The distance from
Shell Island to Corpus Christi was some sixteen or eighteen miles.
The channel to the bay was so shallow that the steamer, small as it
was, had to be dragged over the bottom when loaded. Not more than one
trip a day could be effected. Later this was remedied, by deepening
the channel and increasing the number of vessels suitable to its
navigation.
Corpus Christi is near the head of the bay of the same name,
formed by the entrance of the Nueces River into tide-water, and is on
the west bank of that bay. At the time of its first occupancy by
United States troops there was a small Mexican hamlet there,
containing probably less than one hundred souls. There was, in
addition, a small American trading post, at which goods were sold to
Mexican smugglers. All goods were put up in compact packages of about
one hundred pounds each, suitable for loading on pack mules. Two of
these packages made a load for an ordinary Mexican mule, and three for
the larger ones. The bulk of the trade was in leaf tobacco, and
domestic cotton-cloths and calicoes. The Mexicans had, before the
arrival of the army, but little to offer in exchange except silver.
The trade in tobacco was enormous, considering the population to be
supplied. Almost every Mexican above the age of ten years, and many
much younger, smoked the cigarette. Nearly every Mexican carried a
pouch of leaf tobacco, powdered by rolling in the hands, and a roll of
corn husks to make wrappers. The cigarettes were made by the smokers
as they used them.
Up to the time of which I write, and for years afterwards--I think
until the administration of President Juarez--the cultivation,
manufacture and sale of tobacco constituted a government monopoly, and
paid the bulk of the revenue collected from internal sources. The
price was enormously high, and made successful smuggling very
profitable. The difficulty of obtaining tobacco is probably the
reason why everybody, male and female, used it at that time. I know
from my own experience that when I was at West Point, the fact that
tobacco, in every form, was prohibited, and the mere possession of the
weed severely punished, made the majority of the cadets, myself
included, try to acquire the habit of using it. I failed utterly at
the time and for many years afterward; but the majority accomplished
the object of their youthful ambition.
Under Spanish rule Mexico was prohibited from producing anything
that the mother-country could supply. This rule excluded the
cultivation of the grape, olive and many other articles to which the
soil and climate were well adapted. The country was governed for
"revenue only;" and tobacco, which cannot be raised in Spain, but is
indigenous to Mexico, offered a fine instrumentality for securing this
prime object of government. The native population had been in the
habit of using "the weed" from a period, back of any recorded history
of this continent. Bad habits--if not restrained by law or public
opinion--spread more rapidly and universally than good ones, and the
Spanish colonists adopted the use of tobacco almost as generally as
the natives. Spain, therefore, in order to secure the largest revenue
from this source, prohibited the cultivation, except in specified
localities--and in these places farmed out the privilege at a very
high price. The tobacco when raised could only be sold to the
government, and the price to the consumer was limited only by the
avarice of the authorities, and the capacity of the people to pay.
All laws for the government of the country were enacted in Spain,
and the officers for their execution were appointed by the Crown, and
sent out to the New El Dorado. The Mexicans had been brought up
ignorant of how to legislate or how to rule. When they gained their
independence, after many years of war, it was the most natural thing
in the world that they should adopt as their own the laws then in
existence. The only change was, that Mexico became her own executor
of the laws and the recipient of the revenues. The tobacco tax,
yielding so large a revenue under the law as it stood, was one of the
last, if not the very last, of the obnoxious imposts to be repealed.
Now, the citizens are allowed to cultivate any crops the soil will
yield. Tobacco is cheap, and every quality can be produced. Its use
is by no means so general as when I first visited the country.
Gradually the "Army of Occupation" assembled at Corpus Christi.
When it was all together it consisted of seven companies of the 2d
regiment of dragoons, four companies of light artillery, five
regiments of infantry--the 3d, 4th, 5th, 7th and 8th--and one regiment
of artillery acting as infantry--not more than three thousand men in
all. General Zachary Taylor commanded the whole. There were troops
enough in one body to establish a drill and discipline sufficient to
fit men and officers for all they were capable of in case of battle.
The rank and file were composed of men who had enlisted in time of
peace, to serve for seven dollars a month, and were necessarily
inferior as material to the average volunteers enlisted later in the
war expressly to fight, and also to the volunteers in the war for the
preservation of the Union. The men engaged in the Mexican war were
brave, and the officers of the regular army, from highest to lowest,
were educated in their profession. A more efficient army for its
number and armament, I do not believe ever fought a battle than the
one commanded by General Taylor in his first two engagements on
Mexican--or Texan soil.
The presence of United States troops on the edge of the disputed
territory furthest from the Mexican settlements, was not sufficient
to provoke hostilities. We were sent to provoke a fight, but it was
essential that Mexico should commence it. It was very doubtful
whether Congress would declare war; but if Mexico should attack our
troops, the Executive could announce, "Whereas, war exists by the acts
of, etc.," and prosecute the contest with vigor. Once initiated there
were but few public men who would have the courage to oppose it.
Experience proves that the man who obstructs a war in which his
nation is engaged, no matter whether right or wrong, occupies no
enviable place in life or history. Better for him, individually, to
advocate "war, pestilence, and famine," than to act as obstructionist
to a war already begun. The history of the defeated rebel will be
honorable hereafter, compared with that of the Northern man who aided
him by conspiring against his government while protected by it. The
most favorable posthumous history the stay-at-home traitor can hope
for is--oblivion.
Mexico showing no willingness to come to the Nueces to drive the
invaders from her soil, it became necessary for the "invaders" to
approach to within a convenient distance to be struck. Accordingly,
preparations were begun for moving the army to the Rio Grande, to a
point near Matamoras. It was desirable to occupy a position near the
largest centre of population possible to reach, without absolutely
invading territory to which we set up no claim whatever.
The distance from Corpus Christi to Matamoras is about one hundred
and fifty miles. The country does not abound in fresh water, and the
length of the marches had to be regulated by the distance between
water supplies. Besides the streams, there were occasional pools,
filled during the rainy season, some probably made by the traders, who
travelled constantly between Corpus Christi and the Rio Grande, and
some by the buffalo. There was not at that time a single habitation,
cultivated field, or herd of do mestic animals, between Corpus Christi
and Matamoras. It was necessary, therefore, to have a wagon train
sufficiently large to transport the camp and garrison equipage,
officers' baggage, rations for the army, and part rations of grain
for the artillery horses and all the animals taken from the north,
where they had been accustomed to having their forage furnished them.
The army was but indifferently supplied with transportation. Wagons
and harness could easily be supplied from the north but mules and
horses could not so readily be brought. The American traders and
Mexican smugglers came to the relief. Contracts were made for mules
at from eight to eleven dollars each. The smugglers furnished the
animals, and took their pay in goods of the description before
mentioned. I doubt whether the Mexicans received in value from the
traders five dollars per head for the animals they furnished, and
still more, whether they paid anything but their own time in procuring
them. Such is trade; such is war. The government paid in hard cash
to the contractor the stipulated price.
Between the Rio Grande and the Nueces there was at that time a
large band of wild horses feeding; as numerous, probably, as the band
of buffalo roaming further north was before its rapid extermination
commenced. The Mexicans used to capture these in large numbers and
bring them into the American settlements and sell them. A picked
animal could be purchased at from eight to twelve dollars, but taken
at wholesale, they could be bought for thirty-six dollars a dozen.
Some of these were purchased for the army, and answered a most useful
purpose. The horses were generally very strong, formed much like the
Norman horse, and with very heavy manes and tails. A number of
officers supplied themselves with these, and they generally rendered
as useful service as the northern animal in fact they were much better
when grazing was the only means of supplying forage.
There was no need for haste, and some months were consumed in the
necessary preparations for a move. In the meantime the army was
engaged in all the duties pertaining to the officer and the soldier.
Twice, that I remember, small trains were sent from Corpus Christi,
with cavalry escorts, to San Antonio and Austin, with paymasters and
funds to pay off small detachments of troops stationed at those
places. General Taylor encouraged officers to accompany these
expeditions. I accompanied one of them in December, 1845. The
distance from Corpus Christi to San Antonio was then computed at one
hundred and fifty miles. Now that roads exist it is probably less.
From San Antonio to Austin we computed the distance at one hundred
and ten miles, and from the latter place back to Corpus Christi at
over two hundred miles. I know the distance now from San Antonio to
Austin is but little over eighty miles, so that our computation was
probably too high.
There was not at the time an individual living between Corpus
Christi and San Antonio until within about thirty miles of the latter
point, where there were a few scattering Mexican settlements along the
San Antonio River. The people in at least one of these hamlets lived
underground for protection against the Indians. The country abounded
in game, such as deer and antelope, with abundance of wild turkeys
along the streams and where there were nut-bearing woods. On the
Nueces, about twenty-five miles up from Corpus Christi, were a few log
cabins, the remains of a town called San Patricio, but the inhabitants
had all been massacred by the Indians, or driven away.
San Antonio was about equally divided in population between
Americans and Mexicans. From there to Austin there was not a single
residence except at New Braunfels, on the Guadalupe River. At that
point was a settlement of Germans who had only that year come into the
State. At all events they were living in small huts, about such as
soldiers would hastily construct for temporary occupation. From
Austin to Corpus Christi there was only a small settlement at Bastrop,
with a few farms along the Colorado River; but after leaving that,
there were no settlements except the home of one man, with one female
slave, at the old town of Goliad. Some of the houses were still
standing. Goliad had been quite a village for the period and region,
but some years before there had been a Mexican massacre, in which
every inhabitant had been killed or driven away. This, with the
massacre of the prisoners in the Alamo, San Antonio, about the same
time, more than three hundred men in all, furnished the strongest
justification the Texans had for carrying on the war with so much
cruelty. In fact, from that time until the Mexican. war, the
hostilities between Texans and Mexicans was so great that neither was
safe in the neighborhood of the other who might be in superior numbers
or possessed of superior arms. The man we found living there seemed
like an old friend; he had come from near Fort Jessup, Louisiana,
where the officers of the 3d and 4th infantry and the 2d dragoons had
known him and his family. He had emigrated in advance of his family
to build up a home for them.
When our party left Corpus Christi it was quite large, including
the cavalry escort, Paymaster, Major Dix, his clerk and the officers
who, like myself, were simply on leave; but all the officers on leave,
except Lieutenant Benjamin--afterwards killed in the valley of
Mexico--Lieutenant, now General, Augur, and myself, concluded to spend
their allotted time at San Antonio and return from there. We were all
to be back at Corpus Christi by the end of the month. The paymaster
was detained in Austin so long that, if we had waited for him, we
would have exceeded our leave. We concluded, therefore, to start back
at once with the animals we had, and having to rely principally on
grass for their food, it was a good six days' journey. We had to
sleep on the prairie every night, except at Goliad, and possibly one
night on the Colorado, without shelter and with only such food as we
carried with us, and prepared ourselves. The journey was hazardous
on account of Indians, and there were white men in Texas whom I would
not have cared to meet in a secluded place. Lieutenant Augur was taken
seriously sick before we reached Goliad and at a distance from any
habitation. To add to the complication, his horse--a mustang that had
probably been captured from the band of wild horses before alluded to,
and of undoubted longevity at his capture--gave out. It was absolutely
necessary to get for ward to Goliad to find a shelter for our sick
companion. By dint of patience and exceedingly slow movements, Goliad
was at last reached, and a shelter and bed secured for our patient.
We remained over a day, hoping that Augur might recover sufficiently
to resume his travels. He did not, however, and knowing that Major
Dix would be along in a few days, with his wagon-train, now empty, and
escort, we arranged with our Louisiana friend to take the best of care
of the sick lieutenant until thus relieved, and went on.
I had never been a sportsman in my life; had scarcely ever gone in
search of game, and rarely seen any when looking for it. On this trip
there was no minute of time while travelling between San Patricio and
the settlements on the San Antonio River, from San Antonio to Austin,
and again from the Colorado River back to San Patricio, when deer or
antelope could not be seen in great numbers. Each officer carried a
shot-gun, and every evening, after going into camp, some would go out
and soon return with venison and wild turkeys enough for the entire
camp. I, however, never went out, and had no occasion to fire my gun;
except, being detained over a day at Goliad, Benjamin and I concluded
to go down to the creek--which was fringed with timber, much of it the
pecan--and bring back a few turkeys. We had scarcely reached the edge
of the timber when I heard the flutter of wings overhead, and in an
instant I saw two or three turkeys flying away. These were soon
followed by more, then more, and more, until a flock of twenty or
thirty had left from just over my head. All this time I stood
watching the turkeys to see where they flew--with my gun on my
shoulder, and never once thought of levelling it at the birds. When I
had time to reflect upon the matter, I came to the conclusion that as
a sportsman I was a failure, and went back to the house. Benjamin
remained out, and got as many turkeys as he wanted to carry back.
After the second night at Goliad, Benjamin and I started to make
the remainder of the journey alone. We reached Corpus Christi just
in time to avoid "absence without leave." We met no one not even an
Indian--during the remainder of our journey, except at San Patricio.
A new settlement had been started there in our absence of three
weeks, induced possibly by the fact that there were houses already
built, while the proximity of troops gave protection against the
Indians. On the evening of the first day out from Goliad we heard the
most unearthly howling of wolves, directly in our front. The prairie
grass was tall and we could not see the beasts, but the sound
indicated that they were near. To my ear it appeared that there must
have been enough of them to devour our party, horses and all, at a
single meal. The part of Ohio that I hailed from was not thickly
settled, but wolves had been driven out long before I left. Benjamin
was from Indiana, still less populated, where the wolf yet roamed
over the prairies. He understood the nature of the animal and the
capacity of a few to make believe there was an unlimited number of
them. He kept on towards the noise, unmoved. I followed in his
trail, lacking moral courage to turn back and join our sick companion.
I have no doubt that if Benjamin had proposed returning to Goliad, I
would not only have "seconded the motion" but have sug gested that it
was very hard-hearted in us to leave Augur sick there in the first
place; but Benjamin did not propose turning back. When he did speak
it was to ask: "Grant, how many wolves do you think there are in that
pack?" Knowing where he was from, and suspecting that he thought I
would over-estimate the number, I determined to show my acquaintance
with the animal by putting the estimate below what possibly could be
correct, and answered: "Oh, about twenty," very indifferently. He
smiled and rode on. In a minute we were close upon them, and before
they saw us. There were just TWO of them. Seated upon their
haunches, with their mouths close together, they had made all the
noise we had been hearing for the past ten minutes. I have often
thought of this incident since when I have heard the noise of a few
disappointed politicians who had deserted their associates. There are
always more of them before they are counted.
A week or two before leaving Corpus Christi on this trip, I had
been promoted from brevet second-lieutenant, 4th infantry, to full
second-lieutenant, 7th infantry. Frank Gardner,(*1) of the 7th, was
promoted to the 4th in the same orders. We immediately made
application to be transferred, so as to get back to our old regiments.
On my return, I found that our application had been approved at
Washington. While in the 7th infantry I was in the company of Captain
Holmes, afterwards a Lieutenant-general in the Confederate army. I
never came in contact with him in the war of the Rebellion, nor did he
render any very conspicuous service in his high rank. My transfer
carried me to the company of Captain McCall, who resigned from the
army after the Mexican war and settled in Philadelphia. He was
prompt, however, to volunteer when the rebellion broke out, and soon
rose to the rank of major-general in the Union army. I was not
fortunate enough to meet him after he resigned. In the old army he
was esteemed very highly as a soldier and gentleman. Our relations
were always most pleasant.
The preparations at Corpus Christi for an advance progressed as
rapidly in the absence of some twenty or more lieutenants as if we
had been there. The principal business consisted in securing mules,
and getting them broken to harness. The process was slow but amusing.
The animals sold to the government were all young and unbroken, even
to the saddle, and were quite as wild as the wild horses of the
prairie. Usually a number would be brought in by a company of
Mexicans, partners in the delivery. The mules were first driven into
a stockade, called a corral, inclosing an acre or more of ground. The
Mexicans,--who were all experienced in throwing the lasso,--would go
into the corral on horseback, with their lassos attached to the
pommels of their saddles. Soldiers detailed as teamsters and black
smiths would also enter the corral, the former with ropes to serve as
halters, the latter with branding irons and a fire to keep the irons
heated. A lasso was then thrown over the neck of a mule, when he
would immediately go to the length of his tether, first one end, then
the other in the air. While he was thus plunging and gyrating,
another lasso would be thrown by another Mexican, catching the animal
by a fore-foot. This would bring the mule to the ground, when he was
seized and held by the teamsters while the blacksmith put upon him,
with hot irons, the initials "U. S." Ropes were then put about the
neck, with a slipnoose which would tighten around the throat if
pulled. With a man on each side holding these ropes, the mule was
released from his other bindings and allowed to rise. With more or
less difficulty he would be conducted to a picket rope outside and
fastened there. The delivery of that mule was then complete. This
process was gone through with every mule and wild horse with the army
of occupation.
The method of breaking them was less cruel and much more amusing.
It is a well-known fact that where domestic animals are used for
specific purposes from generation to generation, the descendants are
easily, as a rule, subdued to the same uses. At that time in Northern
Mexico the mule, or his ancestors, the horse and the ass, was seldom
used except for the saddle or pack. At all events the Corpus Christi
mule resisted the new use to which he was being put. The treatment he
was subjected to in order to overcome his prejudices was summary and
effective.
The soldiers were principally foreigners who had enlisted in our
large cities, and, with the exception of a chance drayman among them,
it is not probable that any of the men who reported themselves as
competent teamsters had ever driven a mule-team in their lives, or
indeed that many had had any previous experience in driving any animal
whatever to harness. Numbers together can accomplish what twice their
number acting individually could not perform. Five mules were
allotted to each wagon. A teamster would select at the picket rope
five animals of nearly the same color and general appearance for his
team. With a full corps of assistants, other teamsters, he would then
proceed to get his mules together. In two's the men would approach
each animal selected, avoiding as far as possible its heels. Two
ropes would be put about the neck of each animal, with a slip noose,
so that he could be choked if too unruly. They were then led out,
harnessed by force and hitched to the wagon in the position they had
to keep ever after. Two men remained on either side of the leader,
with the lassos about its neck, and one man retained the same
restraining influence over each of the others. All being ready, the
hold would be slackened and the team started. The first motion was
generally five mules in the air at one time, backs bowed, hind feet
extended to the rear. After repeating this movement a few times the
leaders would start to run. This would bring the breeching tight
against the mules at the wheels, which these last seemed to regard as
a most unwarrantable attempt at coercion and would resist by taking a
seat, sometimes going so far as to lie down. In time all were broken
in to do their duty submissively if not cheerfully, but there never
was a time during the war when it was safe to let a Mexican mule get
entirely loose. Their drivers were all teamsters by the time they got
through.
I recollect one case of a mule that had worked in a team under the
saddle, not only for some time at Corpus Christi, where he was broken,
but all the way to the point opposite Matamoras, then to Camargo,
where he got loose from his fastenings during the night. He did not
run away at first, but staid in the neighborhood for a day or two,
coming up sometimes to the feed trough even; but on the approach of
the teamster he always got out of the way. At last, growing tired of
the constant effort to catch him, he disappeared altogether. Nothing
short of a Mexican with his lasso could have caught him. Regulations
would not have warranted the expenditure of a dollar in hiring a man
with a lasso to catch that mule; but they did allow the expenditure
"of the mule," on a certificate that he had run away without any fault
of the quartermaster on whose returns he was borne, and also the
purchase of another to take his place. am a competent witness, for I
was regimental quartermaster at the time.
While at Corpus Christi all the officers who had a fancy for
riding kept horses. The animals cost but little in the first
instance, and when picketed they would get their living without any
cost. I had three not long before the army moved, but a sad accident
bereft me of them all at one time. A colored boy who gave them all
the attention they got--besides looking after my tent and that of a
class-mate and fellow-lieutenant and cooking for us, all for about
eight dollars per month, was riding one to water and leading the other
two. The led horses pulled him from his seat and all three ran away.
They never were heard of afterwards. Shortly after that some one
told Captain Bliss, General Taylor's Adjutant-General, of my
misfortune. "Yes; I heard Grant lost five or six dollars' worth of
horses the other day," he replied. That was a slander; they were
broken to the saddle when I got them and cost nearly twenty dollars.
I never suspected the colored boy of malicious intent in letting them
get away, because, if they had not escaped, he could have had one of
them to ride on the long march then in prospect.
At last the preparations were complete and orders were issued for
the advance to begin on the 8th of March. General Taylor had an army
of not more than three thousand men. One battery, the siege guns and
all the convalescent troops were sent on by water to Brazos Santiago,
at the mouth of the Rio Grande. A guard was left back at Corpus
Christi to look after public property and to take care of those who
were too sick to be removed. The remainder of the army, probably not
more than twenty five hundred men, was divided into three brigades,
with the cavalry independent. Colonel Twiggs, with seven companies
of dragoons and a battery of light artillery, moved on the 8th. He
was followed by the three infantry brigades, with a day's interval
between the commands. Thus the rear brigade did not move from Corpus
Christi until the 11th of March. In view of the immense bodies of men
moved on the same day over narrow roads, through dense forests and
across large streams, in our late war, it seems strange now that a
body of less than three thousand men should have been broken into four
columns, separated by a day's march.
General Taylor was opposed to anything like plundering by the
troops, and in this instance, I doubt not, he looked upon the enemy
as the aggrieved party and was not willing to injure them further than
his instructions from Washington demanded. His orders to the troops
enjoined scrupulous regard for the rights of all peaceable persons and
the payment of the highest price for all supplies taken for the use of
the army.
All officers of foot regiments who had horses were permitted to
ride them on the march when it did not interfere with their military
duties. As already related, having lost my "five or six dollars'
worth of horses " but a short time before I determined not to get
another, but to make the journey on foot. My company commander,
Captain McCall, had two good American horses, of considerably more
value in that country, where native horses were cheap, than they were
in the States. He used one himself and wanted the other for his
servant. He was quite anxious to know whether I did not intend to get
me another horse before the march began. I told him No; I belonged to
a foot regiment. I did not understand the object of his solicitude
at the time, but, when we were about to start, he said: "There,
Grant, is a horse for you." I found that he could not bear the idea
of his servant riding on a long march while his lieutenant went
a-foot. He had found a mustang, a three-year old colt only recently
captured, which had been purchased by one of the colored servants with
the regiment for the sum of three dollars. It was probably the only
horse at Corpus Christi that could have been purchased just then for
any reasonable price. Five dollars, sixty-six and two-thirds per
cent. advance, induced the owner to part with the mustang. I was
sorry to take him, because I really felt that, belonging to a foot
regiment, it was my duty to march with the men. But I saw the
Captain's earnestness in the matter, and accepted the horse for the
trip. The day we started was the first time the horse had ever been
under saddle. I had, however, but little difficulty in breaking him,
though for the first day there were frequent disagreements between us
as to which way we should go, and sometimes whether we should go at
all. At no time during the day could I choose exactly the part of the
column I would march with; but after that, I had as tractable a horse
as any with the army, and there was none that stood the trip better.
He never ate a mouthful of food on the journey except the grass he
could pick within the length of his picket rope.
A few days out from Corpus Christi, the immense herd of wild
horses that ranged at that time between the Nueces and the Rio Grande
was seen directly in advance of the head of the column and but a few
miles off. It was the very band from which the horse I was riding had
been captured but a few weeks before. The column was halted for a
rest, and a number of officers, myself among them, rode out two or
three miles to the right to see the extent of the herd. The country
was a rolling prairie, and, from the higher ground, the vision was
obstructed only by the earth's curvature. As far as the eye could
reach to our right, the herd extended. To the left, it extended
equally. There was no estimating the number of animals in it; I have
no idea that they could all have been corralled in the State of Rhode
Island, or Delaware, at one time. If they had been, they would have
been so thick that the pasturage would have given out the first day.
People who saw the Southern herd of buffalo, fifteen or twenty years
ago, can appreciate the size of the Texas band of wild horses in
1846.
At the point where the army struck the Little Colorado River, the
stream was quite wide and of sufficient depth for navigation. The
water was brackish and the banks were fringed with timber. Here the
whole army concentrated before attempting to cross. The army was not
accompanied by a pontoon train, and at that time the troops were not
instructed in bridge building. To add to the embarrassment of the
situation, the army was here, for the first time, threatened with
opposition. Buglers, concealed from our view by the brush on the
opposite side, sounded the "assembly," and other military calls. Like
the wolves before spoken of, they gave the impression that there was
a large number of them and that, if the troops were in proportion to
the noise, they were sufficient to devour General Taylor and his army.
There were probably but few troops, and those engaged principally in
watching the movements of the "invader." A few of our cavalry dashed
in, and forded and swam the stream, and all opposition was soon
dispersed. I do not remember that a single shot was fired.
The troops waded the stream, which was up to their necks in the
deepest part. Teams were crossed by attaching a long rope to the end
of the wagon tongue passing it between the two swing mules and by the
side of the leader, hitching his bridle as well as the bridle of the
mules in rear to it, and carrying the end to men on the opposite
shore. The bank down to the water was steep on both sides. A rope
long enough to cross the river, therefore, was attached to the back
axle of the wagon, and men behind would hold the rope to prevent the
wagon "beating" the mules into the water. This latter rope also
served the purpose of bringing the end of the forward one back, to be
used over again. The water was deep enough for a short distance to
swim the little Mexican mules which the army was then using, but
they, and the wagons, were pulled through so fast by the men at the
end of the rope ahead, that no time was left them to show their
obstinacy. In this manner the artillery and transportation of the
"army of occupation" crossed the Colorado River.
About the middle of the month of March the advance of the army
reached the Rio Grande and went into camp near the banks of the
river, opposite the city of Matamoras and almost under the guns of a
small fort at the lower end of the town. There was not at that time a
single habitation from Corpus Christi until the Rio Grande was
reached.
The work of fortifying was commenced at once. The fort was laid
out by the engineers, but the work was done by the soldiers under the
supervision of their officers, the chief engineer retaining general
directions. The Mexicans now became so incensed at our near approach
that some of their troops crossed the river above us, and made it
unsafe for small bodies of men to go far beyond the limits of camp.
They captured two companies of dragoons, commanded by Captains
Thornton and Hardee. The latter figured as a general in the late war,
on the Confederate side, and was author of the tactics first used by
both armies. Lieutenant Theodric Porter, of the 4th infantry, was
killed while out with a small detachment; and Major Cross, the
assistant quartermaster-general, had also been killed not far from
camp.
There was no base of supplies nearer than Point Isabel, on the
coast, north of the mouth of the Rio Grande and twenty-five miles
away. The enemy, if the Mexicans could be called such at this time
when no war had been declared, hovered about in such numbers that it
was not safe to send a wagon train after supplies with any escort that
could be spared. I have already said that General Taylor's whole
command on the Rio Grande numbered less than three thousand men. He
had, however, a few more troops at Point Isabel or Brazos Santiago.
The supplies brought from Corpus Christi in wagons were running
short. Work was therefore pushed with great vigor on the defences, to
enable the minimum number of troops to hold the fort. All the men who
could be employed, were kept at work from early dawn until darkness
closed the labors of the day. With all this the fort was not
completed until the supplies grew so short that further delay in
obtaining more could not be thought of. By the latter part of April
the work was in a partially defensible condition, and the 7th
infantry, Major Jacob Brown commanding, was marched in to garrison it,
with some few pieces of artillery. All the supplies on hand, with the
exception of enough to carry the rest of the army to Point Isabel,
were left with the garrison, and the march was commenced with the
remainder of the command, every wagon being taken with the army.
Early on the second day after starting the force reached its
destination, without opposition from the Mexicans. There was some
delay in getting supplies ashore from vessels at anchor in the open
roadstead.
While General Taylor was away with the bulk of his army, the
little garrison up the river was besieged. As we lay in our tents
upon the sea-shore, the artillery at the fort on the Rio Grande could
be distinctly heard.
The war had begun.
There were no possible means of obtaining news from the garrison,
and information from outside could not be otherwise than unfavorable.
What General Taylor's feelings were during this suspense I do not
know; but for myself, a young second-lieutenant who had never heard a
hostile gun before, I felt sorry that I had enlisted. A great many
men, when they smell battle afar off, chafe to get into the fray.
When they say so themselves they generally fail to convince their
hearers that they are as anxious as they would like to make believe,
and as they approach danger they become more subdued. This rule is
not universal, for I have known a few men who were always aching for
a fight when there was no enemy near, who were as good as their word
when the battle did come. But the number of such men is small.
On the 7th of May the wagons were all loaded and General Taylor
started on his return, with his army reinforced at Point Isabel, but
still less than three thousand strong, to relieve the garrison on the
Rio Grande. The road from Point Isabel to Matamoras is over an open,
rolling, treeless prairie, until the timber that borders the bank of
the Rio Grande is reached. This river, like the Mississippi, flows
through a rich alluvial valley in the most meandering manner, running
towards all points of the compass at times within a few miles.
Formerly the river ran by Resaca de la Palma, some four or five miles
east of the present channel. The old bed of the river at Resaca had
become filled at places, leaving a succession of little lakes. The
timber that had formerly grown upon both banks, and for a considerable
distance out, was still standing. This timber was struck six or
eight miles out from the besieged garrison, at a point known as Palo
Alto--"Tall trees" or "woods."
Early in the forenoon of the 8th of May as Palo Alto was
approached, an army, certainly outnumbering our little force, was
seen, drawn up in line of battle just in front of the timber. Their
bayonets and spearheads glistened in the sunlight formidably. The
force was composed largely of cavalry armed with lances. Where we
were the grass was tall, reaching nearly to the shoulders of the men,
very stiff, and each stock was pointed at the top, and hard and almost
as sharp as a darning-needle. General Taylor halted his army before
the head of column came in range of the artillery of the Mexicans. He
then formed a line of battle, facing the enemy. His artillery, two
batteries and two eighteen-pounder iron guns, drawn by oxen, were
placed in position at intervals along the line. A battalion was
thrown to the rear, commanded by Lieutenant-Colonel Childs, of the
artillery, as reserves. These preparations completed, orders were
given for a platoon of each company to stack arms and go to a stream
off to the right of the command, to fill their canteens and also those
of the rest of their respective companies. When the men were all back
in their places in line, the command to advance was given. As I
looked down that long line of about three thousand armed men,
advancing towards a larger force also armed, I thought what a fearful
responsibility General Taylor must feel, commanding such a host and so
far away from friends. The Mexicans immediately opened fire upon us,
first with artillery and then with infantry. At first their shots did
not reach us, and the advance was continued. As we got nearer, the
cannon balls commenced going through the ranks. They hurt no one,
however, during this advance, because they would strike the ground
long before they reached our line, and ricochetted through the tall
grass so slowly that the men would see them and open ranks and let
them pass. When we got to a point where the artillery could be used
with effect, a halt was called, and the battle opened on both sides.
The infantry under General Taylor was armed with flint-lock
muskets, and paper cartridges charged with powder, buck-shot and
ball. At the distance of a few hundred yards a man might fire at you
all day without your finding it out. The artillery was generally
six-pounder brass guns throwing only solid shot; but General Taylor
had with him three or four twelve-pounder howitzers throwing shell,
besides his eighteen-pounders before spoken of, that had a long range.
This made a powerful armament. The Mexicans were armed about as we
were so far as their infantry was concerned, but their artillery only
fired solid shot. We had greatly the advantage in this arm.
The artillery was advanced a rod or two in front of the line, and
opened fire. The infantry stood at order arms as spectators, watching
the effect of our shots upon the enemy, and watching his shots so as
to step out of their way. It could be seen that the eighteen-pounders
and the howitzers did a great deal of execution. On our side there
was little or no loss while we occupied this position. During the
battle Major Ringgold, an accomplished and brave artillery officer,
was mortally wounded, and Lieutenant Luther, also of the artillery,
was struck. During the day several advances were made, and just at
dusk it became evident that the Mexicans were falling back. We again
advanced, and occupied at the close of the battle substantially the
ground held by the enemy at the beginning. In this last move there
was a brisk fire upon our troops, and some execution was done. One
cannon-ball passed through our ranks, not far from me. It took off
the head of an enlisted man, and the under jaw of Captain Page of my
regiment, while the splinters from the musket of the killed soldier,
and his brains and bones, knocked down two or three others, including
one officer, Lieutenant Wallen,--hurting them more or less. Our
casualties for the day were nine killed and forty-seven wounded.
At the break of day on the 9th, the army under Taylor was ready to
renew the battle ; but an advance showed that the enemy had entirely
left our front during the night. The chaparral before us was
impenetrable except where there were roads or trails, with
occasionally clear or bare spots of small dimensions. A body of men
penetrating it might easily be ambushed. It was better to have a few
men caught in this way than the whole army, yet it was necessary that
the garrison at the river should be relieved. To get to them the
chaparral had to be passed. Thus I assume General Taylor reasoned.
He halted the army not far in advance of the ground occupied by the
Mexicans the day before, and selected Captain C. F. Smith, of the
artillery, and Captain McCall, of my company, to take one hundred and
fifty picked men each and find where the enemy had gone. This left me
in command of the company, an honor and responsibility I thought very
great.
Smith and McCall found no obstruction in the way of their advance
until they came up to the succession of ponds, before describes, at
Resaca. The Mexicans had passed them and formed their lines on the
opposite bank. This position they had strengthened a little by
throwing up dead trees and brush in their front, and by placing
artillery to cover the approaches and open places. Smith and McCall
deployed on each side of the road as well as they could, and engaged
the enemy at long range. Word was sent back, and the advance of the
whole army was at once commenced. As we came up we were deployed in
like manner. I was with the right wing, and led my company through
the thicket wherever a penetrable place could be found, taking
advantage of any clear spot that would carry me towards the enemy.
At last I got pretty close up without knowing it. The balls
commenced to whistle very thick overhead, cutting the limbs of the
chaparral right and left. We could not see the enemy, so I ordered my
men to lie down, an order that did not have to be enforced. We kept
our position until it became evident that the enemy were not firing at
us, and then withdrew to find better ground to advance upon.
By this time some progress had been made on our left. A section
of artillery had been captured by the cavalry, and some prisoners had
been taken. The Mexicans were giving way all along the line, and many
of them had, no doubt, left early. I at last found a clear space
separating two ponds. There seemed to be a few men in front and I
charged upon them with my company.
There was no resistance, and we captured a Mexican colonel, who
had been wounded, and a few men. Just as I was sending them to the
rear with a guard of two or three men, a private came from the front
bringing back one of our officers, who had been badly wounded in
advance of where I was. The ground had been charged over before. My
exploit was equal to that of the soldier who boasted that he had cut
off the leg of one of the enemy. When asked why he did not cut off
his head, he replied: "Some one had done that before." This left no
doubt in my mind but that the battle of Resaca de la Palma would have
been won, just as it was, if I had not been there. There was no
further resistance. The evening of the 9th the army was encamped on
its old ground near the Fort, and the garrison was relieved. The
siege had lasted a number of days, but the casualties were few in
number. Major Jacob Brown, of the 7th infantry, the commanding
officer, had been killed, and in his honor the fort was named. Since
then a town of considerable importance has sprung up on the ground
occupied by the fort and troops, which has also taken his name.
The battles of Palo Alto and Resaca de la Palma seemed to us
engaged, as pretty important affairs; but we had only a faint
conception of their magnitude until they were fought over in the
North by the Press and the reports came back to us. At the same
time, or about the same time, we learned that war existed between the
United States and Mexico, by the acts of the latter country. On
learning this fact General Taylor transferred our camps to the south
or west bank of the river, and Matamoras was occupied. We then became
the "Army of Invasion."
Up to this time Taylor had none but regular troops in his command;
but now that invasion had already taken place, volunteers for one year
commenced arriving. The army remained at Matamoras until sufficiently
reinforced to warrant a movement into the interior. General Taylor
was not an officer to trouble the administration much with his
demands, but was inclined to do the best he could with the means given
him. He felt his responsibility as going no further. If he had
thought that he was sent to perform an impossibility with the means
given him, he would probably have informed the authorities of his
opinion and left them to determine what should be done. If the
judgment was against him he would have gone on and done the best he
could with the means at hand without parading his grievance before the
public. No soldier could face either danger or responsibility more
calmly than he. These are qualities more rarely found than genius or
physical courage.
General Taylor never made any great show or parade, either of
uniform or retinue. In dress he was possibly too plain, rarely
wearing anything in the field to indicate his rank, or even that he
was an officer; but he was known to every soldier in his army, and was
respected by all. I can call to mind only one instance when I saw him
in uniform, and one other when I heard of his wearing it, On both
occasions he was unfortunate. The first was at Corpus Christi. He
had concluded to review his army before starting on the march and gave
orders accordingly. Colonel Twiggs was then second in rank with the
army, and to him was given the command of the review. Colonel and
Brevet Brigadier-General Worth, a far different soldier from Taylor in
the use of the uniform, was next to Twiggs in rank, and claimed
superiority by virtue of his brevet rank when the accidents of
service threw them where one or the other had to command. Worth
declined to attend the review as subordinate to Twiggs until the
question was settled by the highest authority. This broke up the
review, and the question was referred to Washington for final
decision.
General Taylor was himself only a colonel, in real rank, at that
time, and a brigadier-general by brevet. He was assigned to duty,
however, by the President, with the rank which his brevet gave him.
Worth was not so assigned, but by virtue of commanding a division he
must, under the army regulations of that day, have drawn the pay of
his brevet rank. The question was submitted to Washington, and no
response was received until after the army had reached the Rio Grande.
It was decided against General Worth, who at once tendered his
resignation and left the army, going north, no doubt, by the same
vessel that carried it. This kept him out of the battles of Palo Alto
and Resaca de la Palma. Either the resignation was not accepted, or
General Worth withdrew it before action had been taken. At all
events he returned to the army in time to command his division in the
battle of Monterey, and served with it to the end of the war.
The second occasion on which General Taylor was said to have
donned his uniform, was in order to receive a visit from the Flag
Officer of the naval squadron off the mouth of the Rio Grande. While
the army was on that river the Flag Officer sent word that he would
call on the General to pay his respects on a certain day. General
Taylor, knowing that naval officers habitually wore all the uniform
the "law allowed" on all occasions of ceremony, thought it would be
only civil to receive his guest in the same style. His uniform was
therefore got out, brushed up, and put on, in advance of the visit.
The Flag Officer, knowing General Taylor's aversion to the wearing of
the uniform, and feeling that it would be regarded as a compliment
should he meet him in civilian's dress, left off his uniform for this
occasion. The meeting was said to have been embarrassing to both, and
the conversation was principally apologetic.
The time was whiled away pleasantly enough at Matamoras, while we
were waiting for volunteers. It is probable that all the most
important people of the territory occupied by our army left their
homes before we got there, but with those remaining the best of
relations apparently existed. It was the policy of the Commanding
General to allow no pillaging, no taking of private property for
public or individual use without satisfactory compensation, so that a
better market was afforded than the people had ever known before.
Among the troops that joined us at Matamoras was an Ohio regiment,
of which Thomas L. Hamer, the Member of Congress who had given me my
appointment to West Point, was major. He told me then that he could
have had the colonelcy, but that as he knew he was to be appointed a
brigadier-general, he preferred at first to take the lower grade. I
have said before that Hamer was one of the ablest men Ohio ever
produced. At that time he was in the prime of life, being less than
fifty years of age, and possessed an admirable physique, promising
long life. But he was taken sick before Monterey, and died within a
few days. I have always believed that had his life been spared, he
would have been President of the United States during the term filled
by President Pierce. Had Hamer filled that office his partiality for
me was such, there is but little doubt I should have been appointed to
one of the staff corps of the army--the Pay Department probably--and
would therefore now be preparing to retire. Neither of these
speculations is unreasonable, and they are mentioned to show how
little men control their own destiny.
Reinforcements having arrived, in the month of August the movement
commenced from Matamoras to Camargo, the head of navigation on the Rio
Grande. The line of the Rio Grande was all that was necessary to
hold, unless it was intended to invade Mexico from the North. In that
case the most natural route to take was the one which General Taylor
selected. It entered a pass in the Sierra Madre Mountains, at
Monterey, through which the main road runs to the City of Mexico.
Monterey itself was a good point to hold, even if the line of the Rio
Grande covered all the territory we desired to occupy at that time.
It is built on a plain two thousand feet above tide water, where the
air is bracing and the situation healthy.
On the 19th of August the army started for Monterey, leaving a
small garrison at Matamoras. The troops, with the exception of the
artillery, cavalry, and the brigade to which I belonged, were moved up
the river to Camargo on steamers. As there were but two or three of
these, the boats had to make a number of trips before the last of the
troops were up. Those who marched did so by the south side of the
river. Lieutenant-Colonel Garland, of the 4th infantry, was the
brigade commander, and on this occasion commanded the entire marching
force. One day out convinced him that marching by day in that
latitude, in the month of August, was not a beneficial sanitary
measure, particularly for Northern men. The order of marching was
changed and night marches were substituted with the best results.
When Camargo was reached, we found a city of tents outside the
Mexican hamlet. I was detailed to act as quartermaster and
commissary to the regiment. The teams that had proven abundantly
sufficient to transport all supplies from Corpus Christi to the Rio
Grande over the level prairies of Texas, were entirely inadequate to
the needs of the reinforced army in a mountainous country. To obviate
the deficiency, pack mules were hired, with Mexicans to pack and drive
them. I had charge of the few wagons allotted to the 4th infantry and
of the pack train to supplement them. There were not men enough in
the army to manage that train without the help of Mexicans who had
learned how. As it was the difficulty was great enough. The troops
would take up their march at an early hour each day. After they had
started, the tents and cooking utensils had to be made into packages,
so that they could be lashed to the backs of the mules. Sheet-iron
kettles, tent-poles and mess chests were inconvenient articles to
transport in that way. It took several hours to get ready to start
each morning, and by the time we were ready some of the mules first
loaded would be tired of standing so long with their loads on their
backs. Sometimes one would start to run, bowing his back and kicking
up until he scattered his load; others would lie down and try to
disarrange their loads by attempting to get on the top of them by
rolling on them; others with tent-poles for part of their loads would
manage to run a tent-pole on one side of a sapling while they would
take the other. I am not aware of ever having used a profane
expletive in my life; but I would have the charity to excuse those who
may have done so, if they were in charge of a train of Mexican pack
mules at the time.
The advance from Camargo was commenced on the 5th of September.
The army was divided into four columns, separated from each other by
one day's march. The advance reached Cerralvo in four days and halted
for the remainder of the troops to come up. By the 13th the
rear-guard had arrived, and the same day the advance resumed its
march, followed as before, a day separating the divisions. The
forward division halted again at Marin, twenty-four miles from
Monterey. Both this place and Cerralvo were nearly deserted, and men,
women and children were seen running and scattered over the hills as
we approached; but when the people returned they found all their
abandoned property safe, which must have given them a favorable
opinion of Los Grengos--"the Yankees." From Marin the movement was in
mass. On the 19th General Taylor, with is army, was encamped at Walnut
Springs, within three miles of Monterey.
The town is on a small stream coming out of the mountain-pass, and
is backed by a range of hills of moderate elevation. To the north,
between the city and Walnut Springs, stretches an extensive plain. On
this plain, and entirely outside of the last houses of the city, stood
a strong fort, enclosed on all sides, to which our army gave the name
of "Black Fort." Its guns commanded the approaches to the city to the
full extent of their range. There were two detached spurs of hills or
mountains to the north and northwest of the city, which were also
fortified. On one of these stood the Bishop's Palace. The road to
Saltillo leaves the upper or western end of the city under the fire of
the guns from these heights. The lower or eastern end was defended by
two or three small detached works, armed with artillery and infantry.
To the south was the mountain stream before mentioned, and back of
that the range of foot-hills. The plaza in the centre of the city was
the citadel, properly speaking. All the streets leading from it were
swept by artillery, cannon being intrenched behind temporary parapets.
The house-tops near the plaza were converted into infantry
fortifications by the use of sand-bags for parapets. Such were the
defences of Monterey in September, 1847. General Ampudia, with a
force of certainly ten thousand men, was in command.
General Taylor's force was about six thousand five hundred strong,
in three divisions, under Generals Butler, Twiggs and Worth. The
troops went into camp at Walnut Springs, while the engineer officers,
under Major Mansfield--a General in the late war--commenced their
reconnoissance. Major Mansfield found that it would be practicable to
get troops around, out of range of the Black Fort and the works on the
detached hills to the north-west of the city, to the Saltillo road.
With this road in our possession, the enemy would be cut off from
receiving further supplies, if not from all communication with the
interior. General Worth, with his division somewhat reinforced, was
given the task of gaining possession of the Saltillo road, and of
carrying the detached works outside the city, in that quarter. He
started on his march early in the afternoon of the 20th. The
divisions under Generals Butler and Twiggs were drawn up to threaten
the east and north sides of the city and the works on those fronts, in
support of the movement under General Worth. Worth's was regarded as
the main attack on Monterey, and all other operations were in support
of it. His march this day was uninterrupted; but the enemy was seen
to reinforce heavily about the Bishop's Palace and the other outside
fortifications on their left. General Worth reached a defensible
position just out of range of the enemy's guns on the heights
north-west of the city, and bivouacked for the night. The engineer
officers with him--Captain Sanders and Lieutenant George G. Meade,
afterwards the commander of the victorious National army at the battle
of Gettysburg--made a reconnoissance to the Saltillo road under cover
of night.
During the night of the 20th General Taylor had established a
battery, consisting of two twenty-four-pounder howitzers and a ten
inch mortar, at a point from which they could play upon Black Fort. A
natural depression in the plain, sufficiently deep to protect men
standing in it from the fire from the fort, was selected and the
battery established on the crest nearest the enemy. The 4th infantry,
then consisting of but six reduced companies, was ordered to support
the artillerists while they were intrenching themselves and their
guns. I was regimental quartermaster at the time and was ordered to
remain in charge of camp and the public property at Walnut Springs.
It was supposed that the regiment would return to its camp in the
morning.
The point for establishing the siege battery was reached and the
work performed without attracting the attention of the enemy. At
daylight the next morning fire was opened on both sides and continued
with, what seemed to me at that day, great fury. My curiosity got the
better of my judgment, and I mounted a horse and rode to the front to
see what was going on. I had been there but a short time when an
order to charge was given, and lacking the moral courage to return to
camp--where I had been ordered to stay--I charged with the regiment As
soon as the troops were out of the depression they came under the fire
of Black Fort. As they advanced they got under fire from batteries
guarding the cast, or lower, end of the city, and of musketry. About
one-third of the men engaged in the charge were killed or wounded in
the space of a few minutes. We retreated to get out of fire, not
backward, but eastward and perpendicular to the direct road running
into the city from Walnut Springs. I was, I believe, the only person
in the 4th infantry in the charge who was on horseback. When we got
to a lace of safety the regiment halted and drew itself together--what
was left of it. The adjutant of the regiment, Lieutenant Hoskins, who
was not in robust health, found himself very much fatigued from
running on foot in the charge and retreat, and, seeing me on
horseback, expressed a wish that he could be mounted also. I offered
him my horse and he accepted the offer. A few minutes later I saw a
soldier, a quartermaster's man, mounted, not far away. I ran to him,
took his horse and was back with the regiment in a few minutes. In a
short time we were off again; and the next place of safety from the
shots of the enemy that I recollect of being in, was a field of cane
or corn to the north-east of the lower batteries. The adjutant to
whom I had loaned my horse was killed, and I was designated to act in
his place.
This charge was ill-conceived, or badly executed. We belonged to
the brigade commanded by Lieutenant-Colonel Garland, and he had
received orders to charge the lower batteries of the city, and carry
them if he could without too much loss, for the purpose of creating a
diversion in favor of Worth, who was conducting the movement which it
was intended should be decisive. By a movement by the left flank
Garland could have led his men beyond the range of the fire from Black
Fort and advanced towards the northeast angle of the city, as well
covered from fire as could be expected. There was no undue loss of
life in reaching the lower end of Monterey, except that sustained by
Garland's command.
Meanwhile Quitman's brigade, conducted by an officer of engineers,
had reached the eastern end of the city, and was placed under cover of
the houses without much loss. Colonel Garland's brigade also arrived
at the suburbs, and, by the assistance of some of our troops that had
reached house-tops from which they could fire into a little battery
covering the approaches to the lower end of the city, the battery was
speedily captured and its guns were turned upon another work of the
enemy. An entrance into the cast end of the city was now secured, and
the houses protected our troops so long as they were inactive. On the
west General Worth had reached the Saltillo road after some fighting
but without heavy loss. He turned from his new position and captured
the forts on both heights in that quarter. This gave him possession
of the upper or west end of Monterey. Troops from both Twiggs's and
Butler's divisions were in possession of the east end of the town, but
the Black Fort to the north of the town and the plaza in the centre
were still in the possession of the enemy. Our camps at Walnut
Springs, three miles away, were guarded by a company from each
regiment. A regiment of Kentucky volunteers guarded the mortars and
howitzers engaged against Black Fort. Practically Monterey was
invested.
There was nothing done on the 22d by the United States troops; but
the enemy kept up a harmless fire upon us from Black Fort and the
batteries still in their possession at the east end of the city.
During the night they evacuated these; so that on the morning of the
23d we held undisputed possession of the east end of Monterey.
Twiggs's division was at the lower end of the city, and well
covered from the fire of the enemy. But the streets leading to the
plaza--all Spanish or Spanish-American towns have near their centres a
square called a plaza--were commanded from all directions by
artillery. The houses were flat-roofed and but one or two stories
high, and about the plaza the roofs were manned with infantry, the
troops being protected from our fire by parapets made of sand-bags.
All advances into the city were thus attended with much danger.
While moving along streets which did not lead to the plaza, our men
were protected from the fire, and from the view, of the enemy except
at the crossings; but at these a volley of musketry and a discharge of
grape-shot were invariably encountered. The 3d and 4th regiments of
infantry made an advance nearly to the plaza in this way and with
heavy loss. The loss of the 3d infantry in commissioned officers was
especially severe. There were only five companies of the regiment and
not over twelve officers present, and five of these officers were
killed. When within a square of the plaza this small command, ten
companies in all, was brought to a halt. Placing themselves under
cover from the shots of the enemy, the men would watch to detect a
head above the sand-bags on the neighboring houses. The exposure of a
single head would bring a volley from our soldiers.
We had not occupied this position long when it was discovered that
our ammunition was growing low. I volunteered to go back (*2) to the
point we had started from, report our position to General Twiggs, and
ask for ammunition to be forwarded. We were at this time occupying
ground off from the street, in rear of the houses. My ride back was
an exposed one. Before starting I adjusted myself on the side of my
horse furthest from the enemy, and with only one foot holding to the
cantle of the saddle, and an arm over the neck of the horse exposed, I
started at full run. It was only at street crossings that my horse
was under fire, but these I crossed at such a flying rate that
generally I was past and under cover of the next block of houses
before the enemy fired. I got out safely without a scratch.
At one place on my ride, I saw a sentry walking in front of a
house, and stopped to inquire what he was doing there. Finding that
the house was full of wounded American officers and soldiers, I
dismounted and went in. I found there Captain Williams, of the
Engineer Corps, wounded in the head, probably fatally, and Lieutenant
Territt, also badly wounded his bowels protruding from his wound.
There were quite a number of soldiers also. Promising them to report
their situation, I left, readjusted myself to my horse, recommenced
the run, and was soon with the troops at the east end. Before
ammunition could be collected, the two regiments I had been with were
seen returning, running the same gauntlet in getting out that they
had passed in going in, but with comparatively little loss. The
movement was countermanded and the troops were withdrawn. The poor
wounded officers and men I had found, fell into the hands of the enemy
during the night, and died.
While this was going on at the east, General Worth, with a small
division of troops, was advancing towards the plaza from the opposite
end of the city. He resorted to a better expedient for getting to the
plaza--the citadel--than we did on the east. Instead of moving by the
open streets, he advanced through the houses, cutting passageways from
one to another. Without much loss of life, he got so near the plaza
during the night that before morning, Ampudia, the Mexican commander,
made overtures for the surrender of the city and garrison. This
stopped all further hostilities. The terms of surrender were soon
agreed upon. The prisoners were paroled and permitted to take their
horses and personal property with them.
My pity was aroused by the sight of the Mexican garrison of
Monterey marching out of town as prisoners, and no doubt the same
feeling was experienced by most of our army who witnessed it. Many of
the prisoners were cavalry, armed with lances, and mounted on
miserable little half-starved horses that did not look as if they
could carry their riders out of town. The men looked in but little
better condition. I thought how little interest the men before me had
in the results of the war, and how little knowledge they had of "what
it was all about."
After the surrender of the garrison of Monterey a quiet camp life
was led until midwinter. As had been the case on the Rio Grande, the
people who remained at their homes fraternized with the "Yankees" in
the pleasantest manner. In fact, under the humane policy of our
commander, I question whether the great majority of the Mexican people
did not regret our departure as much as they had regretted our coming.
Property and person were thoroughly protected, and a market was
afforded for all the products of the country such as the people had
never enjoyed before. The educated and wealthy portion of the
population here, as elsewhere, abandoned their homes and remained away
from them as long as they were in the possession of the invaders; but
this class formed a very small percentage of the whole population.
The Mexican war was a political war, and the administration
conducting it desired to make party capital out of it. General Scott
was at the head of the army, and, being a soldier of acknowledged
professional capacity, his claim to the command of the forces in the
field was almost indisputable and does not seem to have been denied by
President Polk, or Marcy, his Secretary of War. Scott was a Whig and
the administration was democratic. General Scott was also known to
have political aspirations, and nothing so popularizes a candidate for
high civil positions as military victories. It would not do
therefore to give him command of the "army of conquest." The plans
submitted by Scott for a campaign in Mexico were disapproved by the
administration, and he replied, in a tone possibly a little
disrespectful, to the effect that, if a soldier's plans were not to be
supported by the administration, success could not be expected. This
was on the 27th of May, 1846. Four days later General Scott was
notified that he need not go to Mexico. General Gaines was next in
rank, but he was too old and feeble to take the field. Colonel
Zachary Taylor--a brigadier-general by brevet--was therefore left in
command. He, too, was a Whig, but was not supposed to entertain any
political ambitions; nor did he; but after the fall of Monterey, his
third battle and third complete victory, the Whig papers at home began
to speak of him as the candidate of their party for the Presidency.
Something had to be done to neutralize his growing popularity. He
could not be relieved from duty in the field where all his battles had
been victories: the design would have been too transparent. It was
finally decided to send General Scott to Mexico in chief command, and
to authorize him to carry out his own original plan: that is, capture
Vera Cruz and march upon the capital of the country. It was no doubt
supposed that Scott's ambition would lead him to slaughter Taylor or
destroy his chances for the Presidency, and yet it was hoped that he
would not make sufficient capital himself to secure the prize.
The administration had indeed a most embarrassing problem to
solve. It was engaged in a war of conquest which must be carried to
a successful issue, or the political object would be unattained. Yet
all the capable officers of the requisite rank belonged to the
opposition, and the man selected for his lack of political ambition
had himself become a prominent candidate for the Presidency. It was
necessary to destroy his chances promptly. The problem was to do this
without the loss of conquest and without permitting another general of
the same political party to acquire like popularity. The fact is, the
administration of Mr. Polk made every preparation to disgrace Scott,
or, to speak more correctly, to drive him to such desperation that he
would disgrace himself.
General Scott had opposed conquest by the way of the Rio Grande,
Matamoras and Saltillo from the first. Now that he was in command of
all the forces in Mexico, he withdrew from Taylor most of his regular
troops and left him only enough volunteers, as he thought, to hold the
line then in possession of the invading army. Indeed Scott did not
deem it important to hold anything beyond the Rio Grande, and
authorized Taylor to fall back to that line if he chose. General
Taylor protested against the depletion of his army, and his subsequent
movement upon Buena Vista would indicate that he did not share the
views of his chief in regard to the unimportance of conquest beyond
the Rio Grande.
Scott had estimated the men and material that would be required to
capture Vera Cruz and to march on the capital of the country, two
hundred and sixty miles in the interior. He was promised all he asked
and seemed to have not only the confidence of the President, but his
sincere good wishes. The promises were all broken. Only about half
the troops were furnished that had been pledged, other war material
was withheld and Scott had scarcely started for Mexico before the
President undertook to supersede him by the appointment of Senator
Thomas H. Benton as lieutenant-general. This being refused by
Congress, the President asked legislative authority to place a junior
over a senior of the same grade, with the view of appointing Benton to
the rank of major-general and then placing him in command of the
army, but Congress failed to accede to this proposition as well, and
Scott remained in command: but every general appointed to serve under
him was politically opposed to the chief, and several were personally
hostile.
General Scott reached Brazos Santiago or Point Isabel, at the
mouth of the Rio Grande, late in December, 1846, and proceeded at
once up the river to Camargo, where he had written General Taylor to
meet him. Taylor, however, had gone to, or towards Tampico, for the
purpose of establishing a post there. He had started on this march
before he was aware of General Scott being in the country. Under
these circumstances Scott had to issue his orders designating the
troops to be withdrawn from Taylor, without the personal consultation
he had expected to hold with his subordinate.
General Taylor's victory at Buena Vista, February 22d, 23d, and
24th, 1847, with an army composed almost entirely of volunteers who
had not been in battle before, and over a vastly superior force
numerically, made his nomination for the Presidency by the Whigs a
foregone conclusion. He was nominated and elected in 1848. I believe
that he sincerely regretted this turn in his fortunes, preferring the
peace afforded by a quiet life free from abuse to the honor of filling
the highest office in the gift of any people, the Presidency of the
United States.
When General Scott assumed command of the army of invasion, I was
in the division of General David Twiggs, in Taylor's command; but
under the new orders my regiment was transferred to the division of
General William Worth, in which I served to the close of the war. The
troops withdrawn from Taylor to form part of the forces to operate
against Vera Cruz, were assembled at the mouth of the Rio Grande
preparatory to embarkation for their destination. I found General
Worth a different man from any I had before served directly under. He
was nervous, impatient and restless on the march, or when important or
responsible duty confronted him. There was not the least reason for
haste on the march, for it was known that it would take weeks to
assemble shipping enough at the point of our embarkation to carry the
army, but General Worth moved his division with a rapidity that would
have been commendable had he been going to the relief of a beleaguered
garrison. The length of the marches was regulated by the distances
between places affording a supply of water for the troops, and these
distances were sometimes long and sometimes short. General Worth on
one occasion at least, after having made the full distance intended
for the day, and after the troops were in camp and preparing their
food, ordered tents struck and made the march that night which had
been intended for the next day. Some commanders can move troops so as
to get the maximum distance out of them without fatigue, while others
can wear them out in a few days without accomplishing so much.
General Worth belonged to this latter class. He enjoyed, however, a
fine reputation for his fighting qualities, and thus attached his
officers and men to him.
The army lay in camp upon the sand-beach in the neighborhood of
the mouth of the Rio Grande for several weeks, awaiting the arrival
of transports to carry it to its new field of operations. The
transports were all sailing vessels. The passage was a tedious one,
and many of the troops were on shipboard over thirty days from the
embarkation at the mouth of the Rio Grande to the time of debarkation
south of Vera Cruz. The trip was a comfortless one for officers and
men. The transports used were built for carrying freight and
possessed but limited accommodations for passengers, and the climate
added to the discomfort of all.
The transports with troops were assembled in the harbor of Anton
Lizardo, some sixteen miles south of Vera Cruz, as they arrived, and
there awaited the remainder of the fleet, bringing artillery,
ammunition and supplies of all kinds from the North. With the fleet
there was a little steam propeller dispatch-boat--the first vessel of
the kind I had ever seen, and probably the first of its kind ever seen
by any one then with the army. At that day ocean steamers were rare,
and what there were were sidewheelers. This little vessel, going
through the fleet so fast, so noiselessly and with its propeller under
water out of view, attracted a great deal of attention. I recollect
that Lieutenant Sidney Smith, of the 4th infantry, by whom I happened
to be standing on the deck of a vessel when this propeller was
passing, exclaimed, "Why, the thing looks as if it was propelled by
the force of circumstances."
Finally on the 7th of March, 1847, the little army of ten or
twelve thousand men, given Scott to invade a country with a
population of seven or eight millions, a mountainous country
affording the greatest possible natural advantages for defence, was
all assembled and ready to commence the perilous task of landing from
vessels lying in the open sea.
The debarkation took place inside of the little island of
Sacrificios, some three miles south of Vera Cruz. The vessels could
not get anywhere near shore, so that everything had to be landed in
lighters or surf-boats; General Scott had provided these before
leaving the North. The breakers were sometimes high, so that the
landing was tedious. The men were got ashore rapidly, because they
could wade when they came to shallow water; but the camp and garrison
equipage, provisions, ammunition and all stores had to be protected
from the salt water, and therefore their landing took several days.
The Mexicans were very kind to us, however, and threw no obstacles
in the way of our landing except an occasional shot from their
nearest fort. During the debarkation one shot took off the head of
Major Albertis. No other, I believe, reached anywhere near the same
distance. On the 9th of March the troops were landed and the
investment of Vera Cruz, from the Gulf of Mexico south of the city to
the Gulf again on the north, was soon and easily effected. The
landing of stores was continued until everything was got ashore.
Vera Cruz, at the time of which I write and up to 1880, was a
walled city. The wall extended from the water's edge south of the
town to the water again on the north. There were fortifications at
intervals along the line and at the angles. In front of the city, and
on an island half a mile out in the Gulf, stands San Juan de Ulloa, an
enclosed fortification of large dimensions and great strength for that
period. Against artillery of the present day the land forts and walls
would prove elements of weakness rather than strength. After the
invading army had established their camps out of range of the fire
from the city, batteries were established, under cover of night, far
to the front of the line where the troops lay. These batteries were
intrenched and the approaches sufficiently protected. If a sortie had
been made at any time by the Mexicans, the men serving the batteries
could have been quickly reinforced without great exposure to the fire
from the enemy's main line. No serious attempt was made to capture
the batteries or to drive our troops away.
The siege continued with brisk firing on our side till the 27th of
March, by which time a considerable breach had been made in the wall
surrounding the city. Upon this General Morales, who was Governor of
both the city and of San Juan de Ulloa, commenced a correspondence
with General Scott looking to the surrender of the town, forts and
garrison. On the 29th Vera Cruz and San Juan de Ulloa were occupied
by Scott's army. About five thousand prisoners and four hundred
pieces of artillery, besides large amounts of small arms and
ammunition, fell into the hands of the victorious force. The
casualties on our side during the siege amounted to sixty-four
officers and men, killed and wounded.
General Scott had less than twelve thousand men at Vera Cruz. He
had been promised by the administration a very much larger force, or
claimed that he had, and he was a man of veracity. Twelve thousand was
a very small army with which to penetrate two hundred and sixty miles
into an enemy's country, and to besiege the capital; a city, at that
time, of largely over one hundred thousand inhabitants. Then, too,
any line of march that could be selected led through mountain passes
easily defended. In fact, there were at that time but two roads from
Vera Cruz to the City of Mexico that could be taken by an army; one by
Jalapa and Perote, the other by Cordova and Orizaba, the two coming
together on the great plain which extends to the City of Mexico after
the range of mountains is passed.
It was very important to get the army away from Vera Cruz as soon
as possible, in order to avoid the yellow fever, or vomito, which
usually visits that city early in the year, and is very fatal to
persons not acclimated; but transportation, which was expected from
the North, was arriving very slowly. It was absolutely necessary to
have enough to supply the army to Jalapa, sixty-five miles in the
interior and above the fevers of the coast. At that point the country
is fertile, and an army of the size of General Scott's could subsist
there for an indefinite period. Not counting the sick, the weak and
the garrisons for the captured city and fort, the moving column was
now less than ten thousand strong. This force was composed of three
divisions, under Generals Twiggs, Patterson, and Worth. The importance
of escaping the vomito was so great that as soon as transportation
enough could be got together to move a division the advance was
commenced. On the 8th of April, Twiggs's division started for Jalapa.
He was followed very soon by Patterson, with his division. General
Worth was to bring up the rear with his command as soon as
transportation enough was assembled to carry six days' rations for his
troops with the necessary ammunition and camp and garrison equipage.
It was the 13th of April before this division left Vera Cruz.
The leading division ran against the enemy at Cerro Gordo, some
fifty miles west, on the road to Jalapa, and went into camp at Plan
del Rio, about three miles from the fortifications. General Patterson
reached Plan del Rio with his division soon after Twiggs arrived. The
two were then secure against an attack from Santa Anna, who commanded
the Mexican forces. At all events they confronted the enemy without
reinforcements and without molestation, until the 18th of April.
General Scott had remained at Vera Cruz to hasten preparations for
the field; but on the 12th, learning the situation at the front, he
hastened on to take personal supervision. He at once commenced his
preparations for the capture of the position held by Santa Anna and
of the troops holding it.
Cerro Gordo is one of the higher spurs of the mountains some
twelve to fifteen miles east of Jalapa, and Santa Anna had selected
this point as the easiest to defend against an invading army. The
road, said to have been built by Cortez, zigzags around the
mountain-side and was defended at every turn by artillery. On either
side were deep chasms or mountain walls. A direct attack along the
road was an impossibility. A flank movement seemed equally
impossible. After the arrival of the commanding-general upon the
scene, reconnoissances were sent out to find, or to make, a road by
which the rear of the enemy's works might be reached without a front
attack. These reconnoissances were made under the supervision of
Captain Robert E. Lee, assisted by Lieutenants P. G. T. Beauregard,
Isaac I. Stevens, Z. B. Tower, G. W. Smith, George B. McClellan, and
J. G. Foster, of the corps of engineers, all officers who attained
rank and fame, on one side or the other, in the great conflict for the
preservation of the unity of the nation. The reconnoissance was
completed, and the labor of cutting out and making roads by the flank
of the enemy was effected by the 17th of the month. This was
accomplished without the knowledge of Santa Anna or his army, and over
ground where he supposed it impossible. On the same day General Scott
issued his order for the attack on the 18th.
The attack was made as ordered, and perhaps there was not a battle
of the Mexican war, or of any other, where orders issued before an
engagement were nearer being a correct report of what afterwards took
place. Under the supervision of the engineers, roadways had been
opened over chasms to the right where the walls were so steep that men
could barely climb them. Animals could not. These had been opened
under cover of night, without attracting the notice of the enemy. The
engineers, who had directed the opening, led the way and the troops
followed. Artillery was let down the steep slopes by hand, the men
engaged attaching a strong rope to the rear axle and letting the guns
down, a piece at a time, while the men at the ropes kept their ground
on top, paying out gradually, while a few at the front directed the
course of the piece. In like manner the guns were drawn by hand up
the opposite slopes. In this way Scott's troops reached their
assigned position in rear of most of the intrenchments of the enemy,
unobserved. The attack was made, the Mexican reserves behind the
works beat a hasty retreat, and those occupying them surrendered. On
the left General Pillow's command made a formidable demonstration,
which doubtless held a part of the enemy in his front and contributed
to the victory. I am not pretending to give full details of all the
battles fought, but of the portion that I saw. There were troops
engaged on both sides at other points in which both sustained losses;
but the battle was won as here narrated.
The surprise of the enemy was complete, the victory overwhelming;
some three thousand prisoners fell into Scott's hands, also a large
amount of ordnance and ordnance stores. The prisoners were paroled,
the artillery parked and the small arms and ammunition destroyed. The
battle of Buena Vista was probably very important to the success of
General Scott at Cerro Gordo and in his entire campaign from Vera Cruz
to the great plains reaching to the City of Mexico. The only army
Santa Anna had to protect his capital and the mountain passes west of
Vera Cruz, was the one he had with him confronting General Taylor. It
is not likely that he would have gone as far north as Monterey to
attack the United States troops when he knew his country was
threatened with invasion further south. When Taylor moved to
Saltillo and then advanced on to Buena Vista, Santa Anna crossed the
desert confronting the invading army, hoping no doubt to crush it and
get back in time to meet General Scott in the mountain passes west of
Vera Cruz. His attack on Taylor was disastrous to the Mexican army,
but, notwithstanding this, he marched his army to Cerro Gordo, a
distance not much short of one thousand miles by the line he had to
travel, in time to intrench himself well before Scott got there. If
he had been successful at Buena Vista his troops would no doubt have
made a more stubborn resistance at Cerro Gordo. Had the battle of
Buena Vista not been fought Santa Anna would have had time to move
leisurely to meet the invader further south and with an army not
demoralized nor depleted by defeat.
After the battle the victorious army moved on to Jalapa, where it
was in a beautiful, productive and healthy country, far above the
fevers of the coast. Jalapa, however, is still in the mountains, and
between there and the great plain the whole line of the road is easy
of defence. It was important, therefore, to get possession of the
great highway between the sea-coast and the capital up to the point
where it leaves the mountains, before the enemy could have time to
re-organize and fortify in our front. Worth's division was selected to
go forward to secure this result. The division marched to Perote on
the great plain, not far from where the road debouches from the
mountains. There is a low, strong fort on the plain in front of the
town, known as the Castle of Perote. This, however, offered no
resistance and fell into our hands, with its armament.
General Scott having now only nine or ten thousand men west of
Vera Cruz, and the time of some four thousand of them being about to
expire, a long delay was the consequence. The troops were in a
healthy climate, and where they could subsist for an indefinite period
even if their line back to Vera Cruz should be cut off. It being
ascertained that the men whose time would expire before the City of
Mexico could possibly fall into the hands of the American army, would
not remain beyond the term for which they had volunteered, the
commanding-general determined to discharge them at once, for a delay
until the expiration of their time would have compelled them to pass
through Vera Cruz during the season of the vomito. This reduced
Scott's force in the field to about five thousand men.
Early in May, Worth, with his division, left Perote and marched on
to Puebla. The roads were wide and the country open except through
one pass in a spur of mountains coming up from the south, through
which the road runs. Notwithstanding this the small column was
divided into two bodies, moving a day apart. Nothing occurred on the
march of special note, except that while lying at the town of
Amozoque--an easy day's march east of Puebla--a body of the enemy's
cavalry, two or three thousand strong, was seen to our right, not more
than a mile away. A battery or two, with two or three infantry
regiments, was sent against them and they soon disappeared. On the
15th of May we entered the city of Puebla.
General Worth was in command at Puebla until the latter end of
May, when General Scott arrived. Here, as well as on the march up,
his restlessness, particularly under responsibilities, showed itself.
During his brief command he had the enemy hovering around near the
city, in vastly superior numbers to his own. The brigade to which I
was attached changed quarters three different times in about a week,
occupying at first quarters near the plaza, in the heart of the city;
then at the western entrance; then at the extreme east. On one
occasion General Worth had the troops in line, under arms, all day,
with three days' cooked rations in their haversacks. He galloped from
one command to another proclaiming the near proximity of Santa Anna
with an army vastly superior to his own. General Scott arrived upon
the scene the latter part of the month, and nothing more was heard of
Santa Anna and his myriads. There were, of course, bodies of mounted
Mexicans hovering around to watch our movements and to pick up
stragglers, or small bodies of troops, if they ventured too far out.
These always withdrew on the approach of any considerable number of
our soldiers. After the arrival of General Scott I was sent, as
quartermaster, with a large train of wagons, back two days' march at
least, to procure forage. We had less than a thousand men as escort,
and never thought of danger. We procured full loads for our entire
train at two plantations, which could easily have furnished as much
more.
There had been great delay in obtaining the authority of Congress
for the raising of the troops asked for by the administration. A bill
was before the National Legislature from early in the session of
1846-7, authorizing the creation of ten additional regiments for the
war to be attached to the regular army, but it was the middle of
February before it became a law. Appointments of commissioned
officers had then to be made; men had to be enlisted, the regiments
equipped and the whole transported to Mexico. It was August before
General Scott received reinforcement sufficient to warrant an advance.
His moving column, not even now more than ten thousand strong, was
in four divisions, commanded by Generals Twiggs, Worth, Pillow and
Quitman. There was also a cavalry corps under General Harney,
composed of detachments of the 1st, 2d, and 3d dragoons. The advance
commenced on the 7th of August with Twiggs's division in front. The
remaining three divisions followed, with an interval of a day between.
The marches were short, to make concentration easier in case of
attack.
I had now been in battle with the two leading commanders
conducting armies in a foreign land. The contrast between the two
was very marked. General Taylor never wore uniform, but dressed
himself entirely for comfort. He moved about the field in which he
was operating to see through his own eyes the situation. Often he
would be without staff officers, and when he was accompanied by them
there was no prescribed order in which they followed. He was very
much given to sit his horse side-ways--with both feet on one
side--particularly on the battlefield. General Scott was the reverse
in all these particulars. He always wore all the uniform prescribed
or allowed by law when he inspected his lines; word would be sent to
all division and brigade commanders in advance, notifying them of the
hour when the commanding general might be expected. This was done so
that all the army might be under arms to salute their chief as he
passed. On these occasions he wore his dress uniform, cocked hat,
aiguillettes, sabre and spurs. His staff proper, besides all officers
constructively on his staff--engineers, inspectors, quartermasters,
etc., that could be spared--followed, also in uniform and in
prescribed order. Orders were prepared with great care and evidently
with the view that they should be a history of what followed.
In their modes of expressing thought, these two generals
contrasted quite as strongly as in their other characteristics.
General Scott was precise in language, cultivated a style peculiarly
his own; was proud of his rhetoric; not averse to speaking of himself,
often in the third person, and he could bestow praise upon the person
he was talking about without the least embarrassment. Taylor was not
a conversationalist, but on paper he could put his meaning so plainly
that there could be no mistaking it. He knew how to express what he
wanted to say in the fewest well-chosen words, but would not sacrifice
meaning to the construction of high-sounding sentences. But with
their opposite characteristics both were great and successful
soldiers; both were true, patriotic and upright in all their dealings.
Both were pleasant to serve under--Taylor was pleasant to serve
with. Scott saw more through the eyes of his staff officers than
through his own. His plans were deliberately prepared, and fully
expressed in orders. Taylor saw for himself, and gave orders to meet
the emergency without reference to how they would read in history.
The route followed by the army from Puebla to the City of Mexico
was over Rio Frio mountain, the road leading over which, at the
highest point, is about eleven thousand feet above tide water. The
pass through this mountain might have been easily defended, but it was
not; and the advanced division reached the summit in three days after
leaving Puebla. The City of Mexico lies west of Rio Frio mountain, on
a plain backed by another mountain six miles farther west, with others
still nearer on the north and south. Between the western base of Rio
Frio and the City of Mexico there are three lakes, Chalco and
Xochimilco on the left and Texcoco on the right, extending to the east
end of the City of Mexico. Chalco and Texcoco are divided by a narrow
strip of land over which the direct road to the city runs. Xochimilco
is also to the left of the road, but at a considerable distance south
of it, and is connected with Lake Chalco by a narrow channel. There
is a high rocky mound, called El Penon, on the right of the road,
springing up from the low flat ground dividing the lakes. This mound
was strengthened by intrenchments at its base and summit, and rendered
a direct attack impracticable.
Scott's army was rapidly concentrated about Ayotla and other
points near the eastern end of Lake Chalco. Reconnoissances were
made up to within gun-shot of El Penon, while engineers were seeking a
route by the south side of Lake Chalco to flank the city, and come
upon it from the south and south-west. A way was found around the
lake, and by the 18th of August troops were in St. Augustin Tlalpam, a
town about eleven miles due south from the plaza of the capital.
Between St. Augustin Tlalpam and the city lie the hacienda of San
Antonio and the village of Churubusco, and south-west of them is
Contreras. All these points, except St. Augustin Tlalpam, were
intrenched and strongly garrisoned. Contreras is situated on the side
of a mountain, near its base, where volcanic rocks are piled in great
confusion, reaching nearly to San Antonio. This made the approach to
the city from the south very difficult.
The brigade to which I was attached--Garland's, of Worth's
division--was sent to confront San Antonio, two or three miles from
St. Augustin Tlalpam, on the road to Churubusco and the City of
Mexico. The ground on which San Antonio stands is completely in the
valley, and the surface of the land is only a little above the level
of the lakes, and, except to the south-west, it was cut up by deep
ditches filled with water. To the south-west is the Pedregal--the
volcanic rock before spoken of--over which cavalry or artillery could
not be passed, and infantry would make but poor progress if confronted
by an enemy. From the position occupied by Garland's brigade,
therefore, no movement could be made against the defences of San
Antonio except to the front, and by a narrow causeway, over perfectly
level ground, every inch of which was commanded by the enemy's
artillery and infantry. If Contreras, some three miles west and
south, should fall into our hands, troops from there could move to the
right flank of all the positions held by the enemy between us and the
city. Under these circumstances General Scott directed the holding of
the front of the enemy without making an attack until further orders.
On the 18th of August, the day of reaching San Augustin Tlalpam,
Garland's brigade secured a position within easy range of the
advanced intrenchments of San Antonio, but where his troops were
protected by an artificial embankment that had been thrown up for
some other purpose than defense. General Scott at once set his
engineers reconnoitring the works about Contreras, and on the 19th
movements were commenced to get troops into positions from which an
assault could be made upon the force occupying that place. The
Pedregal on the north and north-east, and the mountain on the south,
made the passage by either flank of the enemy's defences difficult,
for their work stood exactly between those natural bulwarks; but a
road was completed during the day and night of the 19th, and troops
were got to the north and west of the enemy.
This affair, like that of Cerro Gordo, was an engagement in which
the officers of the engineer corps won special distinction. In fact,
in both cases, tasks which seemed difficult at first sight were made
easier for the troops that had to execute them than they would have
been on an ordinary field. The very strength of each of these
positions was, by the skill of the engineers, converted into a defence
for the assaulting parties while securing their positions for final
attack. All the troops with General Scott in the valley of Mexico,
except a part of the division of General Quitman at San Augustin
Tlalpam and the brigade of Garland (Worth's division) at San Antonio,
were engaged at the battle of Contreras, or were on their way, in
obedience to the orders of their chief, to reinforce those who were
engaged. The assault was made on the morning of the 20th, and in less
than half an hour from the sound of the advance the position was in
our hands, with many prisoners and large quantities of ordnance and
other stores. The brigade commanded by General Riley was from its
position the most conspicuous in the final assault, but all did well,
volunteers and regulars.
From the point occupied by Garland's brigade we could see the
progress made at Contreras and the movement of troops toward the
flank and rear of the enemy opposing us. The Mexicans all the way
back to the city could see the same thing, and their conduct showed
plainly that they did not enjoy the sight. We moved out at once, and
found them gone from our immediate front. Clarke's brigade of Worth's
division now moved west over the point of the Pedregal, and after
having passed to the north sufficiently to clear San Antonio, turned
east and got on the causeway leading to Churubusco and the City of
Mexico. When he approached Churubusco his left, under Colonel
Hoffman, attacked a tete-de-pont at that place and brought on an
engagement. About an hour after, Garland was ordered to advance
directly along the causeway, and got up in time to take part in the
engagement. San Antonio was found evacuated, the evacuation having
probably taken place immediately upon the enemy seeing the stars and
stripes waving over Contreras.
The troops that had been engaged at Contreras, and even then on
their way to that battle-field, were moved by a causeway west of, and
parallel to the one by way of San Antonio and Churubusco. It was
expected by the commanding general that these troops would move north
sufficiently far to flank the enemy out of his position at Churubusco,
before turning east to reach the San Antonio road, but they did not
succeed in this, and Churubusco proved to be about the severest battle
fought in the valley of Mexico. General Scott coming upon the
battle-field about this juncture, ordered two brigades, under
Shields, to move north and turn the right of the enemy. This Shields
did, but not without hard fighting and heavy loss. The enemy finally
gave way, leaving in our hands prisoners, artillery and small arms.
The balance of the causeway held by the enemy, up to the very gates
of the city, fell in like manner. I recollect at this place that some
of the gunners who had stood their ground, were deserters from General
Taylor's army on the Rio Grande.
Both the strategy and tactics displayed by General Scott in these
various engagements of the 20th of August, 1847, were faultless as I
look upon them now, after the lapse of so many years. As before
stated, the work of the engineer officers who made the reconnoissances
and led the different commands to their destinations, was so perfect
that the chief was able to give his orders to his various subordinates
with all the precision he could use on an ordinary march. I mean, up
to the points from which the attack was to commence. After that point
is reached the enemy often induces a change of orders not before
contemplated. The enemy outside the city outnumbered our soldiery
quite three to one, but they had become so demoralized by the
succession of defeats this day, that the City of Mexico could have
been entered without much further bloodshed. In fact, Captain Philip
Kearney--afterwards a general in the war of the rebellion--rode with a
squadron of cavalry to the very gates of the city, and would no doubt
have entered with his little force, only at that point he was badly
wounded, as were several of his officers. He had not heard the call
for a halt.
General Franklin Pierce had joined the army in Mexico, at Puebla,
a short time before the advance upon the capital commenced. He had
consequently not been in any of the engagements of the war up to the
battle of Contreras. By an unfortunate fall of his horse on the
afternoon of the 19th he was painfully injured. The next day, when
his brigade, with the other troops engaged on the same field, was
ordered against the flank and rear of the enemy guarding the different
points of the road from San Augustin Tlalpam to the city, General
Pierce attempted to accompany them. He was not sufficiently recovered
to do so, and fainted. This circumstance gave rise to exceedingly
unfair and unjust criticisms of him when he became a candidate for the
Presidency. Whatever General Pierce's qualifications may have been
for the Presidency, he was a gentleman and a man of courage. I was
not a supporter of him politically, but I knew him more intimately
than I did any other of the volunteer generals.
General Scott abstained from entering the city at this time,
because Mr. Nicholas P. Trist, the commissioner on the part of the
United States to negotiate a treaty of peace with Mexico, was with the
army, and either he or General Scott thought--probably both of
them--that a treaty would be more possible while the Mexican
government was in possession of the capital than if it was scattered
and the capital in the hands of an invader. Be this as it may, we did
not enter at that time. The army took up positions along the slopes of
the mountains south of the city, as far west as Tacubaya.
Negotiations were at once entered into with Santa Anna, who was then
practically THE GOVERNMENT and the immediate commander of all the
troops engaged in defence of the country. A truce was signed which
denied to either party the right to strengthen its position, or to
receive reinforcements during the continuance of the armistices, but
authorized General Scott to draw supplies for his army from the city
in the meantime.
Negotiations were commenced at once and were kept up vigorously
between Mr. Trist and the commissioners appointed on the part of
Mexico, until the 2d of September. At that time Mr. Trist handed in
his ultimatum. Texas was to be given up absolutely by Mexico, and New
Mexico and California ceded to the United States for a stipulated sum
to be afterwards determined. I do not suppose Mr. Trist had any
discretion whatever in regard to boundaries. The war was one of
conquest, in the interest of an institution, and the probabilities are
that private instructions were for the acquisition of territory out of
which new States might be carved. At all events the Mexicans felt so
outraged at the terms proposed that they commenced preparations for
defence, without giving notice of the termination of the armistice.
The terms of the truce had been violated before, when teams had been
sent into the city to bring out supplies for the army. The first
train entering the city was very severely threatened by a mob. This,
however, was apologized for by the authorities and all responsibility
for it denied; and thereafter, to avoid exciting the Mexican people
and soldiery, our teams with their escorts were sent in at night, when
the troops were in barracks and the citizens in bed. The circumstance
was overlooked and negotiations continued. As soon as the news
reached General Scott of the second violation of the armistice, about
the 4th of September, he wrote a vigorous note to President Santa
Anna, calling his attention to it, and, receiving an unsatisfactory
reply, declared the armistice at an end.
General Scott, with Worth's division, was now occupying Tacubaya,
a village some four miles south-west of the City of Mexico, and
extending from the base up the mountain-side for the distance of half
a mile. More than a mile west, and also a little above the plain,
stands Molino del Rey. The mill is a long stone structure, one story
high and several hundred feet in length. At the period of which I
speak General Scott supposed a portion of the mill to be used as a
foundry for the casting of guns. This, however, proved to be a
mistake. It was valuable to the Mexicans because of the quantity of
grain it contained. The building is flat roofed, and a line of
sand-bags over the outer walls rendered the top quite a formidable
defence for infantry. Chapultepec is a mound springing up from the
plain to the height of probably three hundred feet, and almost in a
direct line between Molino del Rey and the western part of the city.
It was fortified both on the top and on the rocky and precipitous
sides.
The City of Mexico is supplied with water by two aqueducts,
resting on strong stone arches. One of these aqueducts draws its
supply of water from a mountain stream coming into it at or near
Molino del Rey, and runs north close to the west base of Chapultepec;
thence along the centre of a wide road, until it reaches the road
running east into the city by the Garita San Cosme; from which point
the aqueduct and road both run east to the city. The second aqueduct
starts from the east base of Chapultepec, where it is fed by a spring,
and runs north-east to the city. This aqueduct, like the other, runs
in the middle of a broad road-way, thus leaving a space on each side.
The arches supporting the aqueduct afforded protection for advancing
troops as well as to those engaged defensively. At points on the San
Cosme road parapets were thrown across, with an embrasure for a
single piece of artillery in each. At the point where both road and
aqueduct turn at right angles from north to east, there was not only
one of these parapets supplied by one gun and infantry supports, but
the houses to the north of the San Cosme road, facing south and
commanding a view of the road back to Chapultepec, were covered with
infantry, protected by parapets made of sandbags. The roads leading
to garitas (the gates) San Cosme and Belen, by which these aqueducts
enter the city, were strongly intrenched. Deep, wide ditches, filled
with water, lined the sides of both roads. Such were the defences of
the City of Mexico in September, 1847, on the routes over which
General Scott entered.
Prior to the Mexican war General Scott had been very partial to
General Worth--indeed he continued so up to the close of
hostilities--but, for some reason, Worth had become estranged from
his chief. Scott evidently took this coldness somewhat to heart. He
did not retaliate, however, but on the contrary showed every
disposition to appease his subordinate. It was understood at the time
that he gave Worth authority to plan and execute the battle of Molino
del Rey without dictation or interference from any one, for the very
purpose of restoring their former relations. The effort failed, and
the two generals remained ever after cold and indifferent towards each
other, if not actually hostile.
The battle of Molino del Rey was fought on the 8th of September.
The night of the 7th, Worth sent for his brigade and regimental
commanders, with their staffs, to come to his quarters to receive
instructions for the morrow. These orders contemplated a movement up
to within striking distance of the Mills before daylight. The
engineers had reconnoitred the ground as well as possible, and had
acquired all the information necessary to base proper orders both for
approach and attack.
By daylight on the morning of the 8th, the troops to be engaged at
Molino were all at the places designated. The ground in front of the
Mills, to the south, was commanded by the artillery from the summit of
Chapultepec as well as by the lighter batteries at hand; but a charge
was made, and soon all was over. Worth's troops entered the Mills by
every door, and the enemy beat a hasty retreat back to Chapultepec.
Had this victory been followed up promptly, no doubt Americans and
Mexicans would have gone over the defences of Chapultepec so near
together that the place would have fallen into our hands without
further loss. The defenders of the works could not have fired upon us
without endangering their own men. This was not done, and five days
later more valuable lives were sacrificed to carry works which had
been so nearly in our possession on the 8th. I do not criticise the
failure to capture Chapultepec at this time. The result that followed
the first assault could not possibly have been foreseen, and to profit
by the unexpected advantage, the commanding general must have been on
the spot and given the necessary instructions at the moment, or the
troops must have kept on without orders. It is always, however, in
order to follow a retreating foe, unless stopped or otherwise
directed. The loss on our side at Molino del Rey was severe for the
numbers engaged. It was especially so among commissioned officers.
I was with the earliest of the troops to enter the Mills. In
passing through to the north side, looking towards Chapultepec, I
happened to notice that there were armed Mexicans still on top of the
building, only a few feet from many of our men. Not seeing any
stairway or ladder reaching to the top of the building, I took a few
soldiers, and had a cart that happened to be standing near brought up,
and, placing the shafts against the wall and chocking the wheels so
that the cart could not back, used the shafts as a sort of ladder
extending to within three or four feet of the top. By this I climbed
to the roof of the building, followed by a few men, but found a
private soldier had preceded me by some other way. There were still
quite a number of Mexicans on the roof, among them a major and five or
six officers of lower grades, who had not succeeded in getting away
before our troops occupied the building. They still had their arms,
while the soldier before mentioned was walking as sentry, guarding the
prisoners he had SURROUNDED, all by himself. I halted the sentinel,
received the swords from the commissioned officers, and proceeded,
with the assistance of the soldiers now with me, to disable the
muskets by striking them against the edge of the wall, and throw them
to the ground below.
Molino del Rey was now captured, and the troops engaged, with the
exception of an appropriate guard over the captured position and
property, were marched back to their quarters in Tacubaya. The
engagement did not last many minutes, but the killed and wounded were
numerous for the number of troops engaged.
During the night of the 11th batteries were established which
could play upon the fortifications of Chapultepec. The bombardment
commenced early on the morning of the 12th, but there was no further
engagement during this day than that of the artillery. General Scott
assigned the capture of Chapultepec to General Pillow, but did not
leave the details to his judgment. Two assaulting columns, two hundred
and fifty men each, composed of volunteers for the occasion, were
formed. They were commanded by Captains McKinzie and Casey
respectively. The assault was successful, but bloody.
In later years, if not at the time, the battles of Molino del Rey
and Chapultepec have seemed to me to have been wholly unnecessary.
When the assaults upon the garitas of San Cosme and Belen were
determined upon, the road running east to the former gate could have
been reached easily, without an engagement, by moving along south of
the Mills until west of them sufficiently far to be out of range,
thence north to the road above mentioned; or, if desirable to keep the
two attacking columns nearer together, the troops could have been
turned east so as to come on the aqueduct road out of range of the
guns from Chapultepec. In like manner, the troops designated to act
against Belen could have kept east of Chapultepec, out of range, and
come on to the aqueduct, also out of range of Chapultepec. Molino del
Rey and Chapultepec would both have been necessarily evacuated if this
course had been pursued, for they would have been turned.
General Quitman, a volunteer from the State of Mississippi, who
stood well with the army both as a soldier and as a man, commanded
the column acting against Belen. General Worth commanded the column
against San Cosme. When Chapultepec fell the advance commenced along
the two aqueduct roads. I was on the road to San Cosme, and witnessed
most that took place on that route. When opposition was encountered
our troops sheltered themselves by keeping under the arches supporting
the aqueduct, advancing an arch at a time. We encountered no serious
obstruction until within gun-shot of the point where the road we were
on intersects that running east to the city, the point where the
aqueduct turns at a right angle. I have described the defences of
this position before. There were but three commissioned officers
besides myself, that I can now call to mind, with the advance when the
above position was reached. One of these officers was a Lieutenant
Semmes, of the Marine Corps. I think Captain Gore, and Lieutenant
Judah, of the 4th infantry, were the others. Our progress was stopped
for the time by the single piece of artillery at the angle of the
roads and the infantry occupying the house-tops back from it.
West of the road from where we were, stood a house occupying the
south-west angle made by the San Cosme road and the road we were
moving upon. A stone wall ran from the house along each of these
roads for a considerable distance and thence back until it joined,
enclosing quite a yard about the house. I watched my opportunity and
skipped across the road and behind the south wall. Proceeding
cautiously to the west corner of the enclosure, I peeped around and
seeing nobody, continued, still cautiously, until the road running
east and west was reached. I then returned to the troops, and called
for volunteers. All that were close to me, or that heard me, about a
dozen, offered their services. Commanding them to carry their arms at
a trail, I watched our opportunity and got them across the road and
under cover of the wall beyond, before the enemy had a shot at us. Our
men under cover of the arches kept a close watch on the intrenchments
that crossed our path and the house-tops beyond, and whenever a head
showed itself above the parapets they would fire at it. Our crossing
was thus made practicable without loss.
When we reached a safe position I instructed my little command
again to carry their arms at a trail, not to fire at the enemy until
they were ordered, and to move very cautiously following me until the
San Cosme road was reached; we would then be on the flank of the men
serving the gun on the road, and with no obstruction between us and
them. When we reached the south-west corner of the enclosure before
described, I saw some United States troops pushing north through a
shallow ditch near by, who had come up since my reconnaissance. This
was the company of Captain Horace Brooks, of the artillery, acting as
infantry. I explained to Brooks briefly what I had discovered and
what I was about to do. He said, as I knew the ground and he did not,
I might go on and he would follow. As soon as we got on the road
leading to the city the troops serving the gun on the parapet
retreated, and those on the house-tops near by followed; our men went
after them in such close pursuit--the troops we had left under the
arches joining--that a second line across the road, about half-way
between the first and the garita, was carried. No reinforcements had
yet come up except Brooks's company, and the position we had taken was
too advanced to be held by so small a force. It was given up, but
retaken later in the day, with some loss.
Worth's command gradually advanced to the front now open to it.
Later in the day in reconnoitring I found a church off to the south
of the road, which looked to me as if the belfry would command the
ground back of the garita San Cosme. I got an officer of the
voltigeurs, with a mountain howitzer and men to work it, to go with
me. The road being in possession of the enemy, we had to take the
field to the south to reach the church. This took us over several
ditches breast deep in water and grown up with water plants. These
ditches, however, were not over eight or ten feet in width. The
howitzer was taken to pieces and carried by the men to its
destination. When I knocked for admission a priest came to the door
who, while extremely polite, declined to admit us. With the little
Spanish then at my command, I explained to him that he might save
property by opening the door, and he certainly would save himself
from becoming a prisoner, for a time at least; and besides, I intended
to go in whether he consented or not. He began to see his duty in the
same light that I did, and opened the door, though he did not look as
if it gave him special pleasure to do so. The gun was carried to the
belfry and put together. We were not more than two or three hundred
yards from San Cosme. The shots from our little gun dropped in upon
the enemy and created great confusion. Why they did not send out a
small party and capture us, I do not know. We had no infantry or
other defences besides our one gun.
The effect of this gun upon the troops about the gate of the city
was so marked that General Worth saw it from his position. (*3) He was
so pleased that he sent a staff officer, Lieutenant Pemberton--later
Lieutenant-General commanding the defences of Vicksburg--to bring me
to him. He expressed his gratification at the services the howitzer
in the church steeple was doing, saying that every shot was effective,
and ordered a captain of voltigeurs to report to me with another
howitzer to be placed along with the one already rendering so much
service. I could not tell the General that there was not room enough
in the steeple for another gun, because he probably would have looked
upon such a statement as a contradiction from a second lieutenant. I
took the captain with me, but did not use his gun.
The night of the 13th of September was spent by the troops under
General Worth in the houses near San Cosme, and in line confronting
the general line of the enemy across to Belen. The troops that I was
with were in the houses north of the road leading into the city, and
were engaged during the night in cutting passage-ways from one house
to another towards the town. During the night Santa Anna, with his
army--except the deserters--left the city. He liberated all the
convicts confined in the town, hoping, no doubt, that they would
inflict upon us some injury before daylight; but several hours after
Santa Anna was out of the way, the city authorities sent a delegation
to General Scott to ask--if not demand--an armistice, respecting
church property, the rights of citizens and the supremacy of the city
government in the management of municipal affairs. General Scott
declined to trammel himself with conditions, but gave assurances that
those who chose to remain within our lines would be protected so long
as they behaved themselves properly.
General Quitman had advanced along his line very successfully on
the 13th, so that at night his command occupied nearly the same
position at Belen that Worth's troops did about San Cosme. After the
interview above related between General Scott and the city council,
orders were issued for the cautious entry of both columns in the
morning. The troops under Worth were to stop at the Alameda, a park
near the west end of the city. Quitman was to go directly to the
Plaza, and take possession of the Palace--a mass of buildings on the
east side in which Congress has its sessions, the national courts are
held, the public offices are all located, the President resides, and
much room is left for museums, receptions, etc. This is the building
generally designated as the "Halls of the Montezumas."
On entering the city the troops were fired upon by the released
convicts, and possibly by deserters and hostile citizens. The
streets were deserted, and the place presented the appearance of a
"city of the dead," except for this firing by unseen persons from
house-tops, windows, and around corners. In this firing the
lieutenant-colonel of my regiment, Garland, was badly wounded,
Lieutenant Sidney Smith, of the 4th infantry, was also wounded
mortally. He died a few days after, and by his death I was promoted
to the grade of first lieutenant.(*4) I had gone into the battle of
Palo Alto in May, 1846, a second lieutenant, and I entered the city of
Mexico sixteen months later with the same rank, after having been in
all the engagements possible for any one man and in a regiment that
lost more officers during the war than it ever had present at any one
engagement. My regiment lost four commissioned officers, all senior
to me, by steamboat explosions during the Mexican war. The Mexicans
were not so discriminating. They sometimes picked off my juniors.
General Scott soon followed the troops into the city, in state. I
wonder that he was not fired upon, but I believe he was not; at all
events he was not hurt. He took quarters at first in the "Halls of
the Montezumas," and from there issued his wise and discreet orders
for the government of a conquered city, and for suppressing the
hostile acts of liberated convicts already spoken of--orders which
challenge the respect of all who study them. Lawlessness was soon
suppressed, and the City of Mexico settled down into a quiet,
law-abiding place. The people began to make their appearance upon the
streets without fear of the invaders. Shortly afterwards the bulk of
the troops were sent from the city to the villages at the foot of the
mountains, four or five miles to the south and south-west.
Whether General Scott approved of the Mexican war and the manner
in which it was brought about, I have no means of knowing. His
orders to troops indicate only a soldierly spirit, with probably a
little regard for the perpetuation of his own fame. On the other
hand, General Taylor's, I think, indicate that he considered the
administration accountable for the war, and felt no responsibility
resting on himself further than for the faithful performance of his
duties. Both generals deserve the commendations of their countrymen
and to live in the grateful memory of this people to the latest
generation.
Earlier in this narrative I have stated that the plain, reached
after passing the mountains east of Perote, extends to the cities of
Puebla and Mexico. The route travelled by the army before reaching
Puebla, goes over a pass in a spur of mountain coming up from the
south. This pass is very susceptible of defence by a smaller against
a larger force. Again, the highest point of the road-bed between Vera
Cruz and the City of Mexico is over Rio Frio mountain, which also
might have been successfully defended by an inferior against a
superior force. But by moving north of the mountains, and about
thirty miles north of Puebla, both of these passes would have been
avoided. The road from Perote to the City of Mexico, by this latter
route, is as level as the prairies in our West. Arriving due north
from Puebla, troops could have been detached to take possession of
that place, and then proceeding west with the rest of the army no
mountain would have been encountered before reaching the City of
Mexico. It is true this road would have brought troops in by
Guadalupe--a town, church and detached spur of mountain about two
miles north of the capital, all bearing the same general name--and at
this point Lake Texcoco comes near to the mountain, which was
fortified both at the base and on the sides: but troops could have
passed north of the mountain and come in only a few miles to the
north-west, and so flanked the position, as they actually did on the
south.
It has always seemed to me that this northern route to the City of
Mexico, would have been the better one to have taken. But my later
experience has taught me two lessons: first, that things are seen
plainer after the events have occurred; second, that the most
confident critics are generally those who know the least about the
matter criticised. I know just enough about the Mexican war to
approve heartily of most of the generalship, but to differ with a
little of it. It is natural that an important city like Puebla should
not have been passed with contempt; it may be natural that the direct
road to it should have been taken; but it could have been passed, its
evacuation insured and possession acquired without danger of
encountering the enemy in intricate mountain defiles. In this same
way the City of Mexico could have been approached without any danger
of opposition, except in the open field.
But General Scott's successes are an answer to all criticism. He
invaded a populous country, penetrating two hundred and sixty miles
into the interior, with a force at no time equal to one-half of that
opposed to him; he was without a base; the enemy was always
intrenched, always on the defensive; yet he won every battle, he
captured the capital, and conquered the government. Credit is due to
the troops engaged, it is true, but the plans and the strategy were
the general's.
I had now made marches and been in battle under both General Scott
and General Taylor. The former divided his force of 10,500 men into
four columns, starting a day apart, in moving from Puebla to the
capital of the nation, when it was known that an army more than twice
as large as his own stood ready to resist his coming. The road was
broad and the country open except in crossing the Rio Frio mountain.
General Taylor pursued the same course in marching toward an enemy.
He moved even in smaller bodies. I never thought at the time to
doubt the infallibility of these two generals in all matters
pertaining to their profession. I supposed they moved in small bodies
because more men could not be passed over a single road on the same
day with their artillery and necessary trains. Later I found the
fallacy of this belief. The rebellion, which followed as a sequence
to the Mexican war, never could have been suppressed if larger bodies
of men could not have been moved at the same time than was the custom
under Scott and Taylor.
The victories in Mexico were, in every instance, over vastly
superior numbers. There were two reasons for this. Both General
Scott and General Taylor had such armies as are not often got
together. At the battles of Palo Alto and Resaca-de-la-Palma, General
Taylor had a small army, but it was composed exclusively of regular
troops, under the best of drill and discipline. Every officer, from
the highest to the lowest, was educated in his profession, not at West
Point necessarily, but in the camp, in garrison, and many of them in
Indian wars. The rank and file were probably inferior, as material out
of which to make an army, to the volunteers that participated in all
the later battles of the war; but they were brave men, and then drill
and discipline brought out all there was in them. A better army, man
for man, probably never faced an enemy than the one commanded by
General Taylor in the earliest two engagements of the Mexican war.
The volunteers who followed were of better material, but without
drill or discipline at the start. They were associated with so many
disciplined men and professionally educated officers, that when they
went into engagements it was with a confidence they would not have
felt otherwise. They became soldiers themselves almost at once. All
these conditions we would enjoy again in case of war.
The Mexican army of that day was hardly an organization. The
private soldier was picked up from the lower class of the inhabitants
when wanted; his consent was not asked; he was poorly clothed, worse
fed, and seldom paid. He was turned adrift when no longer wanted.
The officers of the lower grades were but little superior to the men.
With all this I have seen as brave stands made by some of these men
as I have ever seen made by soldiers. Now Mexico has a standing army
larger than that of the United States. They have a military school
modelled after West Point. Their officers are educated and, no doubt,
generally brave. The Mexican war of 1846-8 would be an impossibility
in this generation.
The Mexicans have shown a patriotism which it would be well if we
would imitate in part, but with more regard to truth. They celebrate
the anniversaries of Chapultepec and Molino del Rey as of very great
victories. The anniversaries are recognized as national holidays. At
these two battles, while the United States troops were victorious, it
was at very great sacrifice of life compared with what the Mexicans
suffered. The Mexicans, as on many other occasions, stood up as well
as any troops ever did. The trouble seemed to be the lack of
experience among the officers, which led them after a certain time to
simply quit, without being particularly whipped, but because they had
fought enough. Their authorities of the present day grow enthusiastic
over their theme when telling of these victories, and speak with
pride of the large sum of money they forced us to pay in the end.
With us, now twenty years after the close of the most stupendous war
ever known, we have writers--who profess devotion to the
nation--engaged in trying to prove that the Union forces were not
victorious; practically, they say, we were slashed around from
Donelson to Vicksburg and to Chattanooga; and in the East from
Gettysburg to Appomattox, when the physical rebellion gave out from
sheer exhaustion. There is no difference in the amount of romance in
the two stories.
I would not have the anniversaries of our victories celebrated,
nor those of our defeats made fast days and spent in humiliation and
prayer; but I would like to see truthful history written. Such history
will do full credit to the courage, endurance and soldierly ability of
the American citizen, no matter what section of the country he hailed
from, or in what ranks he fought. The justice of the cause which in
the end prevailed, will, I doubt not, come to be acknowledged by every
citizen of the land, in time. For the present, and so long as there
are living witnesses of the great war of sections, there will be
people who will not be consoled for the loss of a cause which they
believed to be holy. As time passes, people, even of the South, will
begin to wonder how it was possible that their ancestors ever fought
for or justified institutions which acknowledged the right of property
in man.
After the fall of the capital and the dispersal of the government
of Mexico, it looked very much as if military occupation of the
country for a long time might be necessary. General Scott at once
began the preparation of orders, regulations and laws in view of this
contingency. He contemplated making the country pay all the expenses
of the occupation, without the army becoming a perceptible burden upon
the people. His plan was to levy a direct tax upon the separate
states, and collect, at the ports left open to trade, a duty on all
imports. From the beginning of the war private property had not been
taken, either for the use of the army or of individuals, without full
compensation. This policy was to be pursued. There were not troops
enough in the valley of Mexico to occupy many points, but now that
there was no organized army of the enemy of any size, reinforcements
could be got from the Rio Grande, and there were also new volunteers
arriving from time to time, all by way of Vera Cruz. Military
possession was taken of Cuernavaca, fifty miles south of the City of
Mexico; of Toluca, nearly as far west, and of Pachuca, a mining town
of great importance, some sixty miles to the north-east. Vera Cruz,
Jalapa, Orizaba, and Puebla were already in our possession.
Meanwhile the Mexican government had departed in the person of
Santa Anna, and it looked doubtful for a time whether the United
States commissioner, Mr. Trist, would find anybody to negotiate with.
A temporary government, however, was soon established at Queretaro,
and Trist began negotiations for a conclusion of the war. Before
terms were finally agreed upon he was ordered back to Washington, but
General Scott prevailed upon him to remain, as an arrangement had been
so nearly reached, and the administration must approve his acts if he
succeeded in making such a treaty as had been contemplated in his
instructions. The treaty was finally signed the 2d of February, 1848,
and accepted by the government at Washington. It is that known as the
"Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo," and secured to the United States the
Rio Grande as the boundary of Texas, and the whole territory then
included in New Mexico and Upper California, for the sum of
$15,000,000.
Soon after entering the city of Mexico, the opposition of Generals
Pillow, Worth and Colonel Duncan to General Scott became very marked.
Scott claimed that they had demanded of the President his removal. I
do not know whether this is so or not, but I do know of their
unconcealed hostility to their chief. At last he placed them in
arrest, and preferred charges against them of insubordination and
disrespect. This act brought on a crisis in the career of the general
commanding. He had asserted from the beginning that the
administration was hostile to him; that it had failed in its promises
of men and war material; that the President himself had shown
duplicity if not treachery in the endeavor to procure the appointment
of Benton: and the administration now gave open evidence of its
enmity. About the middle of February orders came convening a court of
inquiry, composed of Brevet Brigadier-General Towson, the
paymaster-general of the army, Brigadier-General Cushing and Colonel
Belknap, to inquire into the conduct of the accused and the accuser,
and shortly afterwards orders were received from Washington, relieving
Scott of the command of the army in the field and assigning
Major-General William O. Butler of Kentucky to the place. This order
also released Pillow, Worth and Duncan from arrest.
If a change was to be made the selection of General Butler was
agreeable to every one concerned, so far as I remember to have heard
expressions on the subject. There were many who regarded the
treatment of General Scott as harsh and unjust. It is quite possible
that the vanity of the General had led him to say and do things that
afforded a plausible pretext to the administration for doing just what
it did and what it had wanted to do from the start. The court tried
the accuser quite as much as the accused. It was adjourned before
completing its labors, to meet in Frederick, Maryland. General Scott
left the country, and never after had more than the nominal command of
the army until early in 1861. He certainly was not sustained in his
efforts to maintain discipline in high places.
The efforts to kill off politically the two successful generals,
made them both candidates for the Presidency. General Taylor was
nominated in 1848, and was elected. Four years later General Scott
received the nomination but was badly beaten, and the party nominating
him died with his defeat.(*5)
The treaty of peace between the two countries was signed by the
commissioners of each side early in February, 1848. It took a
considerable time for it to reach Washington, receive the approval of
the administration, and be finally ratified by the Senate. It was
naturally supposed by the army that there would be no more fighting,
and officers and men were of course anxious to get home, but knowing
there must be delay they contented themselves as best they could.
Every Sunday there was a bull fight for the amusement of those who
would pay their fifty cents. I attended one of them--just one--not
wishing to leave the country without having witnessed the national
sport. The sight to me was sickening. I could not see how human
beings could enjoy the sufferings of beasts, and often of men, as they
seemed to do on these occasions.
At these sports there are usually from four to six bulls
sacrificed. The audience occupies seats around the ring in which the
exhibition is given, each seat but the foremost rising higher than the
one in front, so that every one can get a full view of the sport.
When all is ready a bull is turned into the ring. Three or four men
come in, mounted on the merest skeletons of horses blind or
blind-folded and so weak that they could not make a sudden turn with
their riders without danger of falling down. The men are armed with
spears having a point as sharp as a needle. Other men enter the arena
on foot, armed with red flags and explosives about the size of a
musket cartridge. To each of these explosives is fastened a barbed
needle which serves the purpose of attaching them to the bull by
running the needle into the skin. Before the animal is turned loose
a lot of these explosives are attached to him. The pain from the
pricking of the skin by the needles is exasperating; but when the
explosions of the cartridges commence the animal becomes frantic. As
he makes a lunge towards one horseman, another runs a spear into him.
He turns towards his last tormentor when a man on foot holds out a
red flag; the bull rushes for this and is allowed to take it on his
horns. The flag drops and covers the eyes of the animal so that he is
at a loss what to do; it is jerked from him and the torment is
renewed. When the animal is worked into an uncontrollable frenzy,
the horsemen withdraw, and the matadores--literally murderers--enter,
armed with knives having blades twelve or eighteen inches long, and
sharp. The trick is to dodge an attack from the animal and stab him
to the heart as he passes. If these efforts fail the bull is finally
lassoed, held fast and killed by driving a knife blade into the spinal
column just back of the horns. He is then dragged out by horses or
mules, another is let into the ring, and the same performance is
renewed.
On the occasion when I was present one of the bulls was not turned
aside by the attacks in the rear, the presentations of the red flag,
etc., etc., but kept right on, and placing his horns under the flanks
of a horse threw him and his rider to the ground with great force.
The horse was killed and the rider lay prostrate as if dead. The
bull was then lassoed and killed in the manner above described. Men
came in and carried the dead man off in a litter. When the
slaughtered bull and horse were dragged out, a fresh bull was turned
into the ring. Conspicuous among the spectators was the man who had
been carried out on a litter but a few minutes before. He was only
dead so far as that performance went; but the corpse was so lively
that it could not forego the chance of witnessing the discomfiture of
some of his brethren who might not be so fortunate. There was a
feeling of disgust manifested by the audience to find that he had
come to life again. I confess that I felt sorry to see the cruelty
to the bull and the horse. I did not stay for the conclusion of the
performance; but while I did stay, there was not a bull killed in the
prescribed way.
Bull fights are now prohibited in the Federal District-- embracing
a territory around the City of Mexico, somewhat larger than the
District of Columbia--and they are not an institution in any part of
the country. During one of my recent visits to Mexico, bull fights
were got up in my honor at Puebla and at Pachuca. I was not notified
in advance so as to be able to decline and thus prevent the
performance; but in both cases I civilly declined to attend.
Another amusement of the people of Mexico of that day, and one
which nearly all indulged in, male and female, old and young, priest
and layman, was Monte playing. Regular feast weeks were held every
year at what was then known as St. Augustin Tlalpam, eleven miles out
of town. There were dealers to suit every class and condition of
people. In many of the booths tlackos--the copper coin of the
country, four of them making six and a quarter cents of our
money--were piled up in great quantities, with some silver, to
accommodate the people who could not bet more than a few pennies at a
time. In other booths silver formed the bulk of the capital of the
bank, with a few doubloons to be changed if there should be a run of
luck against the bank. In some there was no coin except gold. Here
the rich were said to bet away their entire estates in a single day.
All this is stopped now.
For myself, I was kept somewhat busy during the winter of 1847-8.
My regiment was stationed in Tacubaya. I was regimental
quartermaster and commissary. General Scott had been unable to get
clothing for the troops from the North. The men were becoming--well,
they needed clothing. Material had to be purchased, such as could be
obtained, and people employed to make it up into "Yankee uniforms." A
quartermaster in the city was designated to attend to this special
duty; but clothing was so much needed that it was seized as fast as
made up. A regiment was glad to get a dozen suits at a time. I had
to look after this matter for the 4th infantry. Then our regimental
fund had run down and some of the musicians in the band had been
without their extra pay for a number of months.
The regimental bands at that day were kept up partly by pay from
the government, and partly by pay from the regimental fund. There was
authority of law for enlisting a certain number of men as musicians.
So many could receive the pay of non-commissioned officers of the
various grades, and the remainder the pay of privates. This would not
secure a band leader, nor good players on certain instruments. In
garrison there are various ways of keeping up a regimental fund
sufficient to give extra pay to musicians, establish libraries and
ten-pin alleys, subscribe to magazines and furnish many extra comforts
to the men. The best device for supplying the fund is to issue bread
to the soldiers instead of flour. The ration used to be eighteen
ounces per day of either flour or bread; and one hundred pounds of
flour will make one hundred and forty pounds of bread. This saving
was purchased by the commissary for the benefit of the fund. In the
emergency the 4th infantry was laboring under, I rented a bakery in
the city, hired bakers--Mexicans--bought fuel and whatever was
necessary, and I also got a contract from the chief commissary of the
army for baking a large amount of hard bread. In two months I made
more money for the fund than my pay amounted to during the entire war.
While stationed at Monterey I had relieved the post fund in the same
way. There, however, was no profit except in the saving of flour by
converting it into bread.
In the spring of 1848 a party of officers obtained leave to visit
Popocatapetl, the highest volcano in America, and to take an escort.
I went with the party, many of whom afterwards occupied conspicuous
positions before the country. Of those who "went south," and attained
high rank, there was Lieutenant Richard Anderson, who commanded a
corps at Spottsylvania; Captain Sibley, a major-general, and, after
the war, for a number of years in the employ of the Khedive of Egypt;
Captain George Crittenden, a rebel general; S. B. Buckner, who
surrendered Fort Donelson; and Mansfield Lovell, who commanded at New
Orleans before that city fell into the hands of the National troops.
Of those who remained on our side there were Captain Andrew Porter,
Lieutenant C. P. Stone and Lieutenant Z. B. Tower. There were quite a
number of other officers, whose names I cannot recollect.
At a little village (Ozumba) near the base of Popocatapetl, where
we purposed to commence the ascent, we procured guides and two pack
mules with forage for our horses. High up on the mountain there was a
deserted house of one room, called the Vaqueria, which had been
occupied years before by men in charge of cattle ranging on the
mountain. The pasturage up there was very fine when we saw it, and
there were still some cattle, descendants of the former domestic herd,
which had now become wild. It was possible to go on horseback as far
as the Vaqueria, though the road was somewhat hazardous in places.
Sometimes it was very narrow with a yawning precipice on one side,
hundreds of feet down to a roaring mountain torrent below, and almost
perpendicular walls on the other side. At one of these places one of
our mules loaded with two sacks of barley, one on each side, the two
about as big as he was, struck his load against the mountain-side and
was precipitated to the bottom. The descent was steep but not
perpendicular. The mule rolled over and over until the bottom was
reached, and we supposed of course the poor animal was dashed to
pieces. What was our surprise, not long after we had gone into
bivouac, to see the lost mule, cargo and owner coming up the ascent.
The load had protected the animal from serious injury; and his owner
had gone after him and found a way back to the path leading up to the
hut where we were to stay.
The night at the Vaqueria was one of the most unpleasant I ever
knew. It was very cold and the rain fell in torrents. A little
higher up the rain ceased and snow began. The wind blew with great
velocity. The log-cabin we were in had lost the roof entirely on one
side, and on the other it was hardly better then a sieve. There was
little or no sleep that night. As soon as it was light the next
morning, we started to make the ascent to the summit. The wind
continued to blow with violence and the weather was still cloudy, but
there was neither rain nor snow. The clouds, however, concealed from
our view the country below us, except at times a momentary glimpse
could be got through a clear space between them. The wind carried the
loose snow around the mountain-sides in such volumes as to make it
almost impossible to stand up against it. We labored on and on, until
it became evident that the top could not be reached before night, if
at all in such a storm, and we concluded to return. The descent was
easy and rapid, though dangerous, until we got below the snow line.
At the cabin we mounted our horses, and by night were at Ozumba.
The fatigues of the day and the loss of sleep the night before
drove us to bed early. Our beds consisted of a place on the
dirt-floor with a blanket under us. Soon all were asleep; but long
before morning first one and then another of our party began to cry
out with excruciating pain in the eyes. Not one escaped it. By
morning the eyes of half the party were so swollen that they were
entirely closed. The others suffered pain equally. The feeling was
about what might be expected from the prick of a sharp needle at a
white heat. We remained in quarters until the afternoon bathing our
eyes in cold water. This relieved us very much, and before night the
pain had entirely left. The swelling, however, continued, and about
half the party still had their eyes entirely closed; but we concluded
to make a start back, those who could see a little leading the horses
of those who could not see at all. We moved back to the village of
Ameca Ameca, some six miles, and stopped again for the night. The
next morning all were entirely well and free from pain. The weather
was clear and Popocatapetl stood out in all its beauty, the top
looking as if not a mile away, and inviting us to return. About half
the party were anxious to try the ascent again, and concluded to do
so. The remainder--I was with the remainder--concluded that we had
got all the pleasure there was to be had out of mountain climbing, and
that we would visit the great caves of Mexico, some ninety miles from
where we then were, on the road to Acapulco.
The party that ascended the mountain the second time succeeded in
reaching the crater at the top, with but little of the labor they
encountered in their first attempt. Three of them-- Anderson, Stone
and Buckner--wrote accounts of their journey, which were published at
the time. I made no notes of this excursion, and have read nothing
about it since, but it seems to me that I can see the whole of it as
vividly as if it were but yesterday. I have been back at Ameca Ameca,
and the village beyond, twice in the last five years. The scene had
not changed materially from my recollection of it.
The party which I was with moved south down the valley to the town
of Cuantla, some forty miles from Ameca Ameca. The latter stands on
the plain at the foot of Popocatapetl, at an elevation of about eight
thousand feet above tide water. The slope down is gradual as the
traveller moves south, but one would not judge that, in going to
Cuantla, descent enough had been made to occasion a material change in
the climate and productions of the soil; but such is the case. In the
morning we left a temperate climate where the cereals and fruits are
those common to the United States, we halted in the evening in a
tropical climate where the orange and banana, the coffee and the
sugar-cane were flourishing. We had been travelling, apparently, on a
plain all day, but in the direction of the flow of water.
Soon after the capture of the City of Mexico an armistice had been
agreed to, designating the limits beyond which troops of the
respective armies were not to go during its continuance. Our party
knew nothing about these limits. As we approached Cuantla bugles
sounded the assembly, and soldiers rushed from the guard-house in the
edge of the town towards us. Our party halted, and I tied a white
pocket handkerchief to a stick and, using it as a flag of truce,
proceeded on to the town. Captains Sibley and Porter followed a few
hundred yards behind. I was detained at the guard-house until a
messenger could be dispatched to the quarters of the commanding
general, who authorized that I should be conducted to him. I had been
with the general but a few minutes when the two officers following
announced themselves. The Mexican general reminded us that it was a
violation of the truce for us to be there. However, as we had no
special authority from our own commanding general, and as we knew
nothing about the terms of the truce, we were permitted to occupy a
vacant house outside the guard for the night, with the promise of a
guide to put us on the road to Cuernavaca the next morning.
Cuernavaca is a town west of Guantla. The country through which
we passed, between these two towns, is tropical in climate and
productions and rich in scenery. At one point, about half-way
between the two places, the road goes over a low pass in the
mountains in which there is a very quaint old town, the inhabitants
of which at that day were nearly all full-blooded Indians. Very few
of them even spoke Spanish. The houses were built of stone and
generally only one story high. The streets were narrow, and had
probably been paved before Cortez visited the country. They had not
been graded, but the paving had been done on the natural surface. We
had with us one vehicle, a cart, which was probably the first wheeled
vehicle that had ever passed through that town.
On a hill overlooking this town stands the tomb of an ancient
king; and it was understood that the inhabitants venerated this tomb
very highly, as well as the memory of the ruler who was supposed to be
buried in it. We ascended the mountain and surveyed the tomb; but it
showed no particular marks of architectural taste, mechanical skill or
advanced civilization. The next day we went into Cuernavaca.
After a day's rest at Cuernavaca our party set out again on the
journey to the great caves of Mexico. We had proceeded but a few
miles when we were stopped, as before, by a guard and notified that
the terms of the existing armistice did not permit us to go further in
that direction. Upon convincing the guard that we were a mere party
of pleasure seekers desirous of visiting the great natural curiosities
of the country which we expected soon to leave, we were conducted to a
large hacienda near by, and directed to remain there until the
commanding general of that department could be communicated with and
his decision obtained as to whether we should be permitted to pursue
our journey. The guard promised to send a messenger at once, and
expected a reply by night. At night there was no response from the
commanding general, but the captain of the guard was sure he would
have a reply by morning. Again in the morning there was no reply.
The second evening the same thing happened, and finally we learned
that the guard had sent no message or messenger to the department
commander. We determined therefore to go on unless stopped by a force
sufficient to compel obedience.
After a few hours' travel we came to a town where a scene similar
to the one at Cuantia occurred. The commanding officer sent a guide
to conduct our party around the village and to put us upon our road
again. This was the last interruption: that night we rested at a
large coffee plantation, some eight miles from the cave we were on the
way to visit. It must have been a Saturday night; the peons had been
paid off, and spent part of the night in gambling away their scanty
week's earnings. Their coin was principally copper, and I do not
believe there was a man among them who had received as much as
twenty-five cents in money. They were as much excited, however, as if
they had been staking thousands. I recollect one poor fellow, who had
lost his last tlacko, pulled off his shirt and, in the most excited
manner, put that up on the turn of a card. Monte was the game
played, the place out of doors, near the window of the room occupied
by the officers of our party.
The next morning we were at the mouth of the cave at an early
hour, provided with guides, candles and rockets. We explored to a
distance of about three miles from the entrance, and found a
succession of chambers of great dimensions and of great beauty when
lit up with our rockets. Stalactites and stalagmites of all sizes
were discovered. Some of the former were many feet in diameter and
extended from ceiling to floor; some of the latter were but a few feet
high from the floor; but the formation is going on constantly, and
many centuries hence these stalagmites will extend to the ceiling and
become complete columns. The stalagmites were all a little concave,
and the cavities were filled with water. The water percolates through
the roof, a drop at a time--often the drops several minutes apart--and
more or less charged with mineral matter. Evaporation goes on
slowly, leaving the mineral behind. This in time makes the immense
columns, many of them thousands of tons in weight, which serve to
support the roofs over the vast chambers. I recollect that at one
point in the cave one of these columns is of such huge proportions
that there is only a narrow passage left on either side of it. Some
of our party became satisfied with their explorations before we had
reached the point to which the guides were accustomed to take
explorers, and started back without guides. Coming to the large
column spoken of, they followed it entirely around, and commenced
retracing their steps into the bowels of the mountain, without being
aware of the fact. When the rest of us had completed our
explorations, we started out with our guides, but had not gone far
before we saw the torches of an approaching party. We could not
conceive who these could be, for all of us had come in together, and
there were none but ourselves at the entrance when we started in. Very
soon we found it was our friends. It took them some time to conceive
how they had got where they were. They were sure they had kept
straight on for the mouth of the cave, and had gone about far enough
to have reached it.
My experience in the Mexican war was of great advantage to me
afterwards. Besides the many practical lessons it taught, the war
brought nearly all the officers of the regular army together so as to
make them personally acquainted. It also brought them in contact with
volunteers, many of whom served in the war of the rebellion
afterwards. Then, in my particular case, I had been at West Point at
about the right time to meet most of the graduates who were of a
suitable age at the breaking out of the rebellion to be trusted with
large commands. Graduating in 1843, I was at the military academy
from one to four years with all cadets who graduated between 1840 and
1846--seven classes. These classes embraced more than fifty officers
who afterwards became generals on one side or the other in the
rebellion, many of them holding high commands. All the older
officers, who became conspicuous in the rebellion, I had also served
with and known in Mexico: Lee, J. E. Johnston, A. S. Johnston,
Holmes, Hebert and a number of others on the Confederate side; McCall,
Mansfield, Phil. Kearney and others on the National side. The
acquaintance thus formed was of immense service to me in the war of
the rebellion--I mean what I learned of the characters of those to
whom I was afterwards opposed. I do not pretend to say that all
movements, or even many of them, were made with special reference to
the characteristics of the commander against whom they were directed.
But my appreciation of my enemies was certainly affected by this
knowledge. The natural disposition of most people is to clothe a
commander of a large army whom they do not know, with almost
superhuman abilities. A large part of the National army, for
instance, and most of the press of the country, clothed General Lee
with just such qualities, but I had known him personally, and knew
that he was mortal; and it was just as well that I felt this.
The treaty of peace was at last ratified, and the evacuation of
Mexico by United States troops was ordered. Early in June the troops
in the City of Mexico began to move out. Many of them, including the
brigade to which I belonged, were assembled at Jalapa, above the
vomito, to await the arrival of transports at Vera Cruz: but with all
this precaution my regiment and others were in camp on the sand beach
in a July sun, for about a week before embarking, while the fever
raged with great virulence in Vera Cruz, not two miles away. I can
call to mind only one person, an officer, who died of the disease. My
regiment was sent to Pascagoula, Mississippi, to spend the summer. As
soon as it was settled in camp I obtained a leave of absence for four
months and proceeded to St. Louis. On the 22d of August, 1848, I was
married to Miss Julia Dent, the lady of whom I have before spoken. We
visited my parents and relations in Ohio, and, at the end of my leave,
proceeded to my post at Sackett's Harbor, New York. In April
following I was ordered to Detroit, Michigan, where two years were
spent with but few important incidents.
The present constitution of the State of Michigan was ratified
during this time. By the terms of one of its provisions, all
citizens of the United States residing within the State at the time
of the ratification became citizens of Michigan also. During my stay
in Detroit there was an election for city officers. Mr. Zachariah
Chandler was the candidate of the Whigs for the office of Mayor, and
was elected, although the city was then reckoned democratic. All the
officers stationed there at the time who offered their votes were
permitted to cast them. I did not offer mine, however, as I did not
wish to consider myself a citizen of Michigan. This was Mr.
Chandler's first entry into politics, a career he followed ever after
with great success, and in which he died enjoying the friendship,
esteem and love of his countrymen.
In the spring of 1851 the garrison at Detroit was transferred to
Sackett's Harbor, and in the following spring the entire 4th infantry
was ordered to the Pacific Coast. It was decided that Mrs. Grant
should visit my parents at first for a few months, and then remain
with her own family at their St. Louis home until an opportunity
offered of sending for her. In the month of April the regiment was
assembled at Governor's Island, New York Harbor, and on the 5th of
July eight companies sailed for Aspinwall. We numbered a little over
seven hundred persons, including the families of officers and
soldiers. Passage was secured for us on the old steamer Ohio,
commanded at the time by Captain Schenck, of the navy. It had not
been determined, until a day or two before starting, that the 4th
infantry should go by the Ohio; consequently, a complement of
passengers had already been secured. The addition of over seven
hundred to this list crowded the steamer most uncomfortably,
especially for the tropics in July.
In eight days Aspinwall was reached. At that time the streets of
the town were eight or ten inches under water, and foot passengers
passed from place to place on raised foot-walks. July is at the height
of the wet season, on the Isthmus. At intervals the rain would pour
down in streams, followed in not many minutes by a blazing, tropical
summer's sun. These alternate changes, from rain to sunshine, were
continuous in the afternoons. I wondered how any person could live
many months in Aspinwall, and wondered still more why any one tried.
In the summer of 1852 the Panama railroad was completed only to
the point where it now crosses the Chagres River. From there
passengers were carried by boats to Gorgona, at which place they took
mules for Panama, some twenty-five miles further. Those who travelled
over the Isthmus in those days will remember that boats on the Chagres
River were propelled by natives not inconveniently burdened with
clothing. These boats carried thirty to forty passengers each. The
crews consisted of six men to a boat, armed with long poles. There
were planks wide enough for a man to walk on conveniently, running
along the sides of each boat from end to end. The men would start
from the bow, place one end of their poles against the river bottom,
brace their shoulders against the other end, and then walk to the
stern as rapidly as they could. In this way from a mile to a mile and
a half an hour could be made, against the current of the river.
I, as regimental quartermaster, had charge of the public property
and had also to look after the transportation. A contract had been
entered into with the steamship company in New York for the
transportation of the regiment to California, including the Isthmus
transit. A certain amount of baggage was allowed per man, and saddle
animals were to be furnished to commissioned officers and to all
disabled persons. The regiment, with the exception of one company
left as guards to the public property--camp and garrison equipage
principally--and the soldiers with families, took boats, propelled as
above described, for Gorgona. From this place they marched to Panama,
and were soon comfortably on the steamer anchored in the bay, some
three or four miles from the town. I, with one company of troops and
all the soldiers with families, all the tents, mess chests and camp
kettles, was sent to Cruces, a town a few miles higher up the Chagres
River than Gorgona. There I found an impecunious American who had
taken the contract to furnish transportation for the regiment at a
stipulated price per hundred pounds for the freight and so much for
each saddle animal. But when we reached Cruces there was not a mule,
either for pack or saddle, in the place. The contractor promised that
the animals should be on hand in the morning. In the morning he said
that they were on the way from some imaginary place, and would arrive
in the course of the day. This went on until I saw that he could not
procure the animals at all at the price he had promised to furnish
them for. The unusual number of passengers that had come over on the
steamer, and the large amount of freight to pack, had created an
unprecedented demand for mules. Some of the passengers paid as high
as forty dollars for the use of a mule to ride twenty-five miles, when
the mule would not have sold for ten dollars in that market at other
times. Meanwhile the cholera had broken out, and men were dying every
hour. To diminish the food for the disease, I permitted the company
detailed with me to proceed to Panama. The captain and the doctors
accompanied the men, and I was left alone with the sick and the
soldiers who had families. The regiment at Panama was also affected
with the disease; but there were better accommodations for the well on
the steamer, and a hospital, for those taken with the disease, on an
old hulk anchored a mile off. There were also hospital tents on shore
on the island of Flamingo, which stands in the bay.
I was about a week at Cruces before transportation began to come
in. About one-third of the people with me died, either at Cruces or
on the way to Panama. There was no agent of the transportation
company at Cruces to consult, or to take the responsibility of
procuring transportation at a price which would secure it. I
therefore myself dismissed the contractor and made a new contract with
a native, at more than double the original price. Thus we finally
reached Panama. The steamer, however, could not proceed until the
cholera abated, and the regiment was detained still longer.
Altogether, on the Isthmus and on the Pacific side, we were delayed
six weeks. About one-seventh of those who left New York harbor with
the 4th infantry on the 5th of July, now lie buried on the Isthmus of
Panama or on Flamingo island in Panama Bay.
One amusing circumstance occurred while we were Iying at anchor in
Panama Bay. In the regiment there was a Lieutenant Slaughter who was
very liable to sea-sickness. It almost made him sick to see the wave
of a table-cloth when the servants were spreading it. Soon after his
graduation, Slaughter was ordered to California and took passage by a
sailing vessel going around Cape Horn. The vessel was seven months
making the voyage, and Slaughter was sick every moment of the time,
never more so than while Iying at anchor after reaching his place of
destination. On landing in California he found orders which had come
by the Isthmus, notifying him of a mistake in his assignment; he
should have been ordered to the northern lakes. He started back by
the Isthmus route and was sick all the way. But when he arrived at
the East he was again ordered to California, this time definitely,
and at this date was making his third trip. He was as sick as ever,
and had been so for more than a month while lying at anchor in the
bay. I remember him well, seated with his elbows on the table in
front of him, his chin between his hands, and looking the picture of
despair. At last he broke out, "I wish I had taken my father's
advice; he wanted me to go into the navy; if I had done so, I should
not have had to go to sea so much." Poor Slaughter! it was his last
sea voyage. He was killed by Indians in Oregon.
By the last of August the cholera had so abated that it was deemed
safe to start. The disease did not break out again on the way to
California, and we reached San Francisco early in September.
San Francisco at that day was a lively place. Gold, or placer
digging as it was called, was at its height. Steamers plied daily
between San Francisco and both Stockton and Sacramento. Passengers and
gold from the southern mines came by the Stockton boat; from the
northern mines by Sacramento. In the evening when these boats
arrived, Long Wharf--there was but one wharf in San Francisco in
1852--was alive with people crowding to meet the miners as they came
down to sell their "dust" and to "have a time." Of these some were
runners for hotels, boarding houses or restaurants; others belonged to
a class of impecunious adventurers, of good manners and good presence,
who were ever on the alert to make the acquaintance of people with
some ready means, in the hope of being asked to take a meal at a
restaurant. Many were young men of good family, good education and
gentlemanly instincts. Their parents had been able to support them
during their minority, and to give them good educations, but not to
maintain them afterwards. From 1849 to 1853 there was a rush of
people to the Pacific coast, of the class described. All thought that
fortunes were to be picked up, without effort, in the gold fields on
the Pacific. Some realized more than their most sanguine
expectations; but for one such there were hundreds disappointed, many
of whom now fill unknown graves; others died wrecks of their former
selves, and many, without a vicious instinct, became criminals and
outcasts. Many of the real scenes in early California life exceed in
strangeness and interest any of the mere products of the brain of the
novelist.
Those early days in California brought out character. It was a
long way off then, and the journey was expensive. The fortunate
could go by Cape Horn or by the Isthmus of Panama; but the mass of
pioneers crossed the plains with their ox-teams. This took an entire
summer. They were very lucky when they got through with a yoke of
worn-out cattle. All other means were exhausted in procuring the
outfit on the Missouri River. The immigrant, on arriving, found
himself a stranger, in a strange land, far from friends. Time
pressed, for the little means that could be realized from the sale of
what was left of the outfit would not support a man long at California
prices. Many became discouraged. Others would take off their coats
and look for a job, no matter what it might be. These succeeded as a
rule. There were many young men who had studied professions before
they went to California, and who had never done a day's manual labor
in their lives, who took in the situation at once and went to work to
make a start at anything they could get to do. Some supplied
carpenters and masons with material--carrying plank, brick, or mortar,
as the case might be; others drove stages, drays, or baggage wagons,
until they could do better. More became discouraged early and spent
their time looking up people who would "treat," or lounging about
restaurants and gambling houses where free lunches were furnished
daily. They were welcomed at these places because they often brought
in miners who proved good customers.
My regiment spent a few weeks at Benicia barracks, and then was
ordered to Fort Vancouver, on the Columbia River, then in Oregon
Territory. During the winter of 1852-3 the territory was divided,
all north of the Columbia River being taken from Oregon to make
Washington Territory.
Prices for all kinds of supplies were so high on the Pacific coast
from 1849 until at least 1853--that it would have been impossible for
officers of the army to exist upon their pay, if it had not been that
authority was given them to purchase from the commissary such supplies
as he kept, at New Orleans wholesale prices. A cook could not be
hired for the pay of a captain. The cook could do better. At
Benicia, in 1852, flour was 25 cents per pound; potatoes were 16
cents; beets, turnips and cabbage, 6 cents; onions, 37 - 1/2 cents;
meat and other articles in proportion. In 1853 at Vancouver
vegetables were a little lower. I with three other officers concluded
that we would raise a crop for ourselves, and by selling the surplus
realize something handsome. I bought a pair of horses that had
crossed the plains that summer and were very poor. They recuperated
rapidly, however, and proved a good team to break up the ground with.
I performed all the labor of breaking up the ground while the other
officers planted the potatoes. Our crop was enormous. Luckily for us
the Columbia River rose to a great height from the melting of the snow
in the mountains in June, and overflowed and killed most of our crop.
This saved digging it up, for everybody on the Pacific coast seemed
to have come to the conclusion at the same time that agriculture would
be profitable. In 1853 more than three-quarters of the potatoes
raised were permitted to rot in the ground, or had to be thrown away.
The only potatoes we sold were to our own mess.
While I was stationed on the Pacific coast we were free from
Indian wars. There were quite a number of remnants of tribes in the
vicinity of Portland in Oregon, and of Fort Vancouver in Washington
Territory. They had generally acquired some of the vices of
civilization, but none of the virtues, except in individual cases.
The Hudson's Bay Company had held the North-west with their trading
posts for many years before the United States was represented on the
Pacific coast. They still retained posts along the Columbia River and
one at Fort Vancouver, when I was there. Their treatment of the
Indians had brought out the better qualities of the savages. Farming
had been undertaken by the company to supply the Indians with bread
and vegetables; they raised some cattle and horses; and they had now
taught the Indians to do the labor of the farm and herd. They always
compensated them for their labor, and always gave them goods of
uniform quality and at uniform price.
Before the advent of the American, the medium of exchange between
the Indian and the white man was pelts. Afterward it was silver coin.
If an Indian received in the sale of a horse a fifty dollar gold
piece, not an infrequent occurrence, the first thing he did was to
exchange it for American half dollars. These he could count. He would
then commence his purchases, paying for each article separately, as he
got it. He would not trust any one to add up the bill and pay it all
at once. At that day fifty dollar gold pieces, not the issue of the
government, were common on the Pacific coast. They were called slugs.
The Indians, along the lower Columbia as far as the Cascades and
on the lower Willamette, died off very fast during the year I spent
in that section; for besides acquiring the vices of the white people
they had acquired also their diseases. The measles and the small-pox
were both amazingly fatal. In their wild state, before the appearance
of the white man among them, the principal complaints they were
subject to were those produced by long involuntary fasting, violent
exercise in pursuit of game, and over-eating. Instinct more than
reason had taught them a remedy for these ills. It was the steam
bath. Something like a bake-oven was built, large enough to admit a
man lying down. Bushes were stuck in the ground in two rows, about six
feet long and some two or three feet apart; other bushes connected the
rows at one end. The tops of the bushes were drawn together to
interlace, and confined in that position; the whole was then
plastered over with wet clay until every opening was filled. Just
inside the open end of the oven the floor was scooped out so as to
make a hole that would hold a bucket or two of water. These ovens were
always built on the banks of a stream, a big spring, or pool of water.
When a patient required a bath, a fire was built near the oven and a
pile of stones put upon it. The cavity at the front was then filled
with water. When the stones were sufficiently heated, the patient
would draw himself into the oven; a blanket would be thrown over the
open end, and hot stones put into the water until the patient could
stand it no longer. He was then withdrawn from his steam bath and
doused into the cold stream near by. This treatment may have answered
with the early ailments of the Indians. With the measles or
small-pox it would kill every time.
During my year on the Columbia River, the small-pox exterminated
one small remnant of a band of Indians entirely, and reduced others
materially. I do not think there was a case of recovery among them,
until the doctor with the Hudson Bay Company took the matter in hand
and established a hospital. Nearly every case he treated recovered.
I never, myself, saw the treatment described in the preceding
paragraph, but have heard it described by persons who have witnessed
it. The decimation among the Indians I knew of personally, and the
hospital, established for their benefit, was a Hudson's Bay building
not a stone's throw from my own quarters.
The death of Colonel Bliss, of the Adjutant General's department,
which occurred July 5th, 1853, promoted me to the captaincy of a
company then stationed at Humboldt Bay, California. The notice
reached me in September of the same year, and I very soon started to
join my new command. There was no way of reaching Humboldt at that
time except to take passage on a San Francisco sailing vessel going
after lumber. Red wood, a species of cedar, which on the Pacific
coast takes the place filled by white pine in the East, then abounded
on the banks of Humboldt Bay. There were extensive saw-mills engaged
in preparing this lumber for the San Francisco market, and sailing
vessels, used in getting it to market, furnished the only means of
communication between Humboldt and the balance of the world.
I was obliged to remain in San Francisco for several days before I
found a vessel. This gave me a good opportunity of comparing the San
Francisco of 1852 with that of 1853. As before stated, there had been
but one wharf in front of the city in 1852--Long Wharf. In 1853 the
town had grown out into the bay beyond what was the end of this wharf
when I first saw it. Streets and houses had been built out on piles
where the year before the largest vessels visiting the port lay at
anchor or tied to the wharf. There was no filling under the streets
or houses. San Francisco presented the same general appearance as the
year before; that is, eating, drinking and gambling houses were
conspicuous for their number and publicity. They were on the first
floor, with doors wide open. At all hours of the day and night in
walking the streets, the eye was regaled, on every block near the
water front, by the sight of players at faro. Often broken places were
found in the street, large enough to let a man down into the water
below. I have but little doubt that many of the people who went to
the Pacific coast in the early days of the gold excitement, and have
never been heard from since, or who were heard from for a time and
then ceased to write, found watery graves beneath the houses or
streets built over San Francisco Bay.
Besides the gambling in cards there was gambling on a larger scale
in city lots. These were sold "On Change," much as stocks are now
sold on Wall Street. Cash, at time of purchase, was always paid by
the broker; but the purchaser had only to put up his margin. He was
charged at the rate of two or three per cent. a month on the
difference, besides commissions. The sand hills, some of them almost
inaccessible to foot-passengers, were surveyed off and mapped into
fifty vara lots--a vara being a Spanish yard. These were sold at
first at very low prices, but were sold and resold for higher prices
until they went up to many thousands of dollars. The brokers did a
fine business, and so did many such purchasers as were sharp enough to
quit purchasing before the final crash came. As the city grew, the
sand hills back of the town furnished material for filling up the bay
under the houses and streets, and still further out. The temporary
houses, first built over the water in the harbor, soon gave way to
more solid structures. The main business part of the city now is on
solid ground, made where vessels of the largest class lay at anchor in
the early days. I was in San Francisco again in 1854. Gambling
houses had disappeared from public view. The city had become staid
and orderly.
My family, all this while, was at the East. It consisted now of a
wife and two children. I saw no chance of supporting them on the
Pacific coast out of my pay as an army officer. I concluded,
therefore, to resign, and in March applied for a leave of absence
until the end of the July following, tendering my resignation to take
effect at the end of that time. I left the Pacific coast very much
attached to it, and with the full expectation of making it my future
home. That expectation and that hope remained uppermost in my mind
until the Lieutenant- Generalcy bill was introduced into Congress in
the winter of 1863-4. The passage of that bill, and my promotion,
blasted my last hope of ever becoming a citizen of the further West.
In the late summer of 1854 I rejoined my family, to find in it a
son whom I had never seen, born while I was on the Isthmus of Panama.
I was now to commence, at the age of thirty-two, a new struggle for
our support. My wife had a farm near St. Louis, to which we went, but
I had no means to stock it. A house had to be built also. I worked
very hard, never losing a day because of bad weather, and accomplished
the object in a moderate way. If nothing else could be done I would
load a cord of wood on a wagon and take it to the city for sale. I
managed to keep along very well until 1858, when I was attacked by
fever and ague. I had suffered very severely and for a long time from
this disease, while a boy in Ohio. It lasted now over a year, and,
while it did not keep me in the house, it did interfere greatly with
the amount of work I was able to perform. In the fall of 1858 I sold
out my stock, crops and farming utensils at auction, and gave up
farming.
In the winter I established a partnership with Harry Boggs, a
cousin of Mrs. Grant, in the real estate agency business. I spent
that winter at St. Louis myself, but did not take my family into town
until the spring. Our business might have become prosperous if I had
been able to wait for it to grow. As it was, there was no more than
one person could attend to, and not enough to support two families.
While a citizen of St. Louis and engaged in the real estate agency
business, I was a candidate for the office of county engineer, an
office of respectability and emolument which would have been very
acceptable to me at that time. The incumbent was appointed by the
county court, which consisted of five members. My opponent had the
advantage of birth over me (he was a citizen by adoption) and carried
off the prize. I now withdrew from the co-partnership with Boggs,
and, in May, 1860, removed to Galena, Illinois, and took a clerkship
in my father's store.
While a citizen of Missouri, my first opportunity for casting a
vote at a Presidential election occurred. I had been in the army
from before attaining my majority and had thought but little about
politics, although I was a Whig by education and a great admirer of
Mr. Clay. But the Whig party had ceased to exist before I had an
opportunity of exercising the privilege of casting a ballot; the
Know-Nothing party had taken its place, but was on the wane; and the
Republican party was in a chaotic state and had not yet received a
name. It had no existence in the Slave States except at points on the
borders next to Free States. In St. Louis City and County, what
afterwards became the Republican party was known as the Free-Soil
Democracy, led by the Honorable Frank P. Blair. Most of my neighbors
had known me as an officer of the army with Whig proclivities. They
had been on the same side, and, on the death of their party, many had
become Know-Nothings, or members of the American party. There was a
lodge near my new home, and I was invited to join it. I accepted the
invitation; was initiated; attended a meeting just one week later, and
never went to another afterwards.
I have no apologies to make for having been one week a member of
the American party; for I still think native-born citizens of the
United States should have as much protection, as many privileges in
their native country, as those who voluntarily select it for a home.
But all secret, oath-bound political parties are dangerous to any
nation, no matter how pure or how patriotic the motives and principles
which first bring them together. No political party can or ought to
exist when one of its corner-stones is opposition to freedom of
thought and to the right to worship God "according to the dictate of
one's own conscience," or according to the creed of any religious
denomination whatever. Nevertheless, if a sect sets up its laws as
binding above the State laws, wherever the two come in conflict this
claim must be resisted and suppressed at whatever cost.
Up to the Mexican war there were a few out and out abolitionists,
men who carried their hostility to slavery into all elections, from
those for a justice of the peace up to the Presidency of the United
States. They were noisy but not numerous. But the great majority of
people at the North, where slavery did not exist, were opposed to the
institution, and looked upon its existence in any part of the country
as unfortunate. They did not hold the States where slavery existed
responsible for it; and believed that protection should be given to
the right of property in slaves until some satisfactory way could be
reached to be rid of the institution. Opposition to slavery was not a
creed of either political party. In some sections more anti-slavery
men belonged to the Democratic party, and in others to the Whigs. But
with the inauguration of the Mexican war, in fact with the annexation
of Texas, "the inevitable conflict" commenced.
As the time for the Presidential election of 1856--the first at
which I had the opportunity of voting--approached, party feeling
began to run high. The Republican party was regarded in the South
and the border States not only as opposed to the extension of slavery,
but as favoring the compulsory abolition of the institution without
compensation to the owners. The most horrible visions seemed to
present themselves to the minds of people who, one would suppose,
ought to have known better. Many educated and, otherwise, sensible
persons appeared to believe that emancipation meant social equality.
Treason to the Government was openly advocated and was not rebuked.
It was evident to my mind that the election of a Republican President
in 1856 meant the secession of all the Slave States, and rebellion.
Under these circumstances I preferred the success of a candidate
whose election would prevent or postpone secession, to seeing the
country plunged into a war the end of which no man could foretell.
With a Democrat elected by the unanimous vote of the Slave States,
there could be no pretext for secession for four years. I very much
hoped that the passions of the people would subside in that time, and
the catastrophe be averted altogether; if it was not, I believed the
country would be better prepared to receive the shock and to resist
it. I therefore voted for James Buchanan for President. Four years
later the Republican party was successful in electing its candidate
to the Presidency. The civilized world has learned the consequence.
Four millions of human beings held as chattels have been liberated;
the ballot has been given to them; the free schools of the country
have been opened to their children. The nation still lives, and the
people are just as free to avoid social intimacy with the blacks as
ever they were, or as they are with white people.
While living in Galena I was nominally only a clerk supporting
myself and family on a stipulated salary. In reality my position was
different. My father had never lived in Galena himself, but had
established my two brothers there, the one next younger than myself in
charge of the business, assisted by the youngest. When I went there
it was my father's intention to give up all connection with the
business himself, and to establish his three sons in it: but the
brother who had really built up the business was sinking with
consumption, and it was not thought best to make any change while he
was in this condition. He lived until September, 1861, when he
succumbed to that insidious disease which always flatters its victims
into the belief that they are growing better up to the close of life.
A more honorable man never transacted business. In September, 1861,
I was engaged in an employment which required all my attention
elsewhere.
During the eleven months that I lived in Galena prior to the first
call for volunteers, I had been strictly attentive to my business, and
had made but few acquaintances other than customers and people engaged
in the same line with myself. When the election took place in
November, 1860, I had not been a resident of Illinois long enough to
gain citizenship and could not, therefore, vote. I was really glad of
this at the time, for my pledges would have compelled me to vote for
Stephen A. Douglas, who had no possible chance of election. The
contest was really between Mr. Breckinridge and Mr. Lincoln; between
minority rule and rule by the majority. I wanted, as between these
candidates, to see Mr. Lincoln elected. Excitement ran high during
the canvass, and torch-light processions enlivened the scene in the
generally quiet streets of Galena many nights during the campaign. I
did not parade with either party, but occasionally met with the "wide
awakes"--Republicans--in their rooms, and superintended their drill.
It was evident, from the time of the Chicago nomination to the close
of the canvass, that the election of the Republican candidate would be
the signal for some of the Southern States to secede. I still had
hopes that the four years which had elapsed since the first nomination
of a Presidential candidate by a party distinctly opposed to slavery
extension, had given time for the extreme pro-slavery sentiment to
cool down; for the Southerners to think well before they took the
awful leap which they had so vehemently threatened. But I was
mistaken.
The Republican candidate was elected, and solid substantial people
of the North-west, and I presume the same order of people throughout
the entire North, felt very serious, but determined, after this event.
It was very much discussed whether the South would carry out its
threat to secede and set up a separate government, the corner-stone of
which should be, protection to the "Divine" institution of slavery.
For there were people who believed in the "divinity" of human
slavery, as there are now people who believe Mormonism and Polygamy to
be ordained by the Most High. We forgive them for entertaining such
notions, but forbid their practice. It was generally believed that
there would be a flurry; that some of the extreme Southern States
would go so far as to pass ordinances of secession. But the common
impression was that this step was so plainly suicidal for the South,
that the movement would not spread over much of the territory and
would not last long.
Doubtless the founders of our government, the majority of them at
least, regarded the confederation of the colonies as an experiment.
Each colony considered itself a separate government; that the
confederation was for mutual protection against a foreign foe, and the
prevention of strife and war among themselves. If there had been a
desire on the part of any single State to withdraw from the compact at
any time while the number of States was limited to the original
thirteen, I do not suppose there would have been any to contest the
right, no matter how much the determination might have been regretted.
The problem changed on the ratification of the Constitution by all
the colonies; it changed still more when amendments were added; and
if the right of any one State to withdraw continued to exist at all
after the ratification of the Constitution, it certainly ceased on the
formation of new States, at least so far as the new States themselves
were concerned. It was never possessed at all by Florida or the
States west of the Mississippi, all of which were purchased by the
treasury of the entire nation. Texas and the territory brought into
the Union in consequence of annexation, were purchased with both blood
and treasure; and Texas, with a domain greater than that of any
European state except Russia, was permitted to retain as state
property all the public lands within its borders. It would have been
ingratitude and injustice of the most flagrant sort for this State to
withdraw from the Union after all that had been spent and done to
introduce her; yet, if separation had actually occurred, Texas must
necessarily have gone with the South, both on account of her
institutions and her geographical position. Secession was illogical as
well as impracticable; it was revolution.
Now, the right of revolution is an inherent one. When people are
oppressed by their government, it is a natural right they enjoy to
relieve themselves of the oppression, if they are strong enough,
either by withdrawal from it, or by overthrowing it and substituting a
government more acceptable. But any people or part of a people who
resort to this remedy, stake their lives, their property, and every
claim for protection given by citizenship--on the issue. Victory, or
the conditions imposed by the conqueror--must be the result.
In the case of the war between the States it would have been the
exact truth if the South had said,--"We do not want to live with you
Northern people any longer; we know our institution of slavery is
obnoxious to you, and, as you are growing numerically stronger than
we, it may at some time in the future be endangered. So long as you
permitted us to control the government, and with the aid of a few
friends at the North to enact laws constituting your section a guard
against the escape of our property, we were willing to live with you.
You have been submissive to our rule heretofore; but it looks now as
if you did not intend to continue so, and we will remain in the Union
no longer." Instead of this the seceding States cried lustily,--"Let
us alone; you have no constitutional power to interfere with us."
Newspapers and people at the North reiterated the cry. Individuals
might ignore the constitution; but the Nation itself must not only
obey it, but must enforce the strictest construction of that
instrument; the construction put upon it by the Southerners
themselves. The fact is the constitution did not apply to any such
contingency as the one existing from 1861 to 1865. Its framers never
dreamed of such a contingency occurring. If they had foreseen it, the
probabilities are they would have sanctioned the right of a State or
States to withdraw rather than that there should be war between
brothers.
The framers were wise in their generation and wanted to do the
very best possible to secure their own liberty and independence, and
that also of their descendants to the latest days. It is preposterous
to suppose that the people of one generation can lay down the best and
only rules of government for all who are to come after them, and under
unforeseen contingencies. At the time of the framing of our
constitution the only physical forces that had been subdued and made
to serve man and do his labor, were the currents in the streams and in
the air we breathe. Rude machinery, propelled by water power, had been
invented; sails to propel ships upon the waters had been set to catch
the passing breeze--but the application of stream to propel vessels
against both wind and current, and machinery to do all manner of work
had not been thought of. The instantaneous transmission of messages
around the world by means of electricity would probably at that day
have been attributed to witchcraft or a league with the Devil.
Immaterial circumstances had changed as greatly as material ones. We
could not and ought not to be rigidly bound by the rules laid down
under circumstances so different for emergencies so utterly
unanticipated. The fathers themselves would have been the first to
declare that their prerogatives were not irrevocable. They would
surely have resisted secession could they have lived to see the shape
it assumed.
I travelled through the Northwest considerably during the winter
of 1860-1. We had customers in all the little towns in south-west
Wisconsin, south-east Minnesota and north-east Iowa. These generally
knew I had been a captain in the regular army and had served through
the Mexican war. Consequently wherever I stopped at night, some of
the people would come to the public-house where I was, and sit till a
late hour discussing the probabilities of the future. My own views at
that time were like those officially expressed by Mr. Seward at a
later day, that "the war would be over in ninety days." I continued
to entertain these views until after the battle of Shiloh. I believe
now that there would have been no more battles at the West after the
capture of Fort Donelson if all the troops in that region had been
under a single commander who would have followed up that victory.
There is little doubt in my mind now that the prevailing sentiment
of the South would have been opposed to secession in 1860 and 1861, if
there had been a fair and calm expression of opinion, unbiased by
threats, and if the ballot of one legal voter had counted for as much
as that of any other. But there was no calm discussion of the
question. Demagogues who were too old to enter the army if there
should be a war, others who entertained so high an opinion of their
own ability that they did not believe they could be spared from the
direction of the affairs of state in such an event, declaimed
vehemently and unceasingly against the North; against its aggressions
upon the South; its interference with Southern rights, etc., etc.
They denounced the Northerners as cowards, poltroons, negro-
worshippers; claimed that one Southern man was equal to five Northern
men in battle; that if the South would stand up for its rights the
North would back down. Mr. Jefferson Davis said in a speech,
delivered at La Grange, Mississippi, before the secession of that
State, that he would agree to drink all the blood spilled south of
Mason and Dixon's line if there should be a war. The young men who
would have the fighting to do in case of war, believed all these
statements, both in regard to the aggressiveness of the North and its
cowardice. They, too, cried out for a separation from such people.
The great bulk of the legal voters of the South were men who owned no
slaves; their homes were generally in the hills and poor country;
their facilities for educating their children, even up to the point of
reading and writing, were very limited; their interest in the contest
was very meagre--what there was, if they had been capable of seeing
it, was with the North; they too needed emancipation. Under the old
regime they were looked down upon by those who controlled all the
affairs in the interest of slave-owners, as poor white trash who were
allowed the ballot so long as they cast it according to direction.
I am aware that this last statement may be disputed and individual
testimony perhaps adduced to show that in ante-bellum days the ballot
was as untrammelled in the south as in any section of the country; but
in the face of any such contradiction I reassert the statement. The
shot-gun was not resorted to. Masked men did not ride over the
country at night intimidating voters; but there was a firm feeling
that a class existed in every State with a sort of divine right to
control public affairs. If they could not get this control by one
means they must by another. The end justified the means. The
coercion, if mild, was complete.
There were two political parties, it is true, in all the States,
both strong in numbers and respectability, but both equally loyal to
the institution which stood paramount in Southern eyes to all other
institutions in state or nation. The slave-owners were the minority,
but governed both parties. Had politics ever divided the
slave-holders and the non-slave-holders, the majority would have been
obliged to yield, or internecine war would have been the consequence.
I do not know that the Southern people were to blame for this
condition of affairs. There was a time when slavery was not
profitable, and the discussion of the merits of the institution was
confined almost exclusively to the territory where it existed. The
States of Virginia and Kentucky came near abolishing slavery by their
own acts, one State defeating the measure by a tie vote and the other
only lacking one. But when the institution became profitable, all
talk of its abolition ceased where it existed; and naturally, as human
nature is constituted, arguments were adduced in its support. The
cotton-gin probably had much to do with the justification of slavery.
The winter of 1860-1 will be remembered by middle-aged people of
to-day as one of great excitement. South Carolina promptly seceded
after the result of the Presidential election was known. Other
Southern States proposed to follow. In some of them the Union
sentiment was so strong that it had to be suppressed by force.
Maryland, Delaware, Kentucky and Missouri, all Slave States, failed
to pass ordinances of secession; but they were all represented in the
so-called congress of the so-called Confederate States. The Governor
and Lieutenant- Governor of Missouri, in 1861, Jackson and Reynolds,
were both supporters of the rebellion and took refuge with the enemy.
The governor soon died, and the lieutenant-governor assumed his
office; issued proclamations as governor of the State; was recognized
as such by the Confederate Government, and continued his pretensions
until the collapse of the rebellion. The South claimed the sovereignty
of States, but claimed the right to coerce into their confederation
such States as they wanted, that is, all the States where slavery
existed. They did not seem to think this course inconsistent. The
fact is, the Southern slave-owners believed that, in some way, the
ownership of slaves conferred a sort of patent of nobility--a right to
govern independent of the interest or wishes of those who did not hold
such property. They convinced themselves, first, of the divine
origin of the institution and, next, that that particular institution
was not safe in the hands of any body of legislators but themselves.
Meanwhile the Administration of President Buchanan looked
helplessly on and proclaimed that the general government had no power
to interfere; that the Nation had no power to save its own life. Mr.
Buchanan had in his cabinet two members at least, who were as
earnest--to use a mild term--in the cause of secession as Mr. Davis or
any Southern statesman. One of them, Floyd, the Secretary of War,
scattered the army so that much of it could be captured when
hostilities should commence, and distributed the cannon and small arms
from Northern arsenals throughout the South so as to be on hand when
treason wanted them. The navy was scattered in like manner. The
President did not prevent his cabinet preparing for war upon their
government, either by destroying its resources or storing them in the
South until a de facto government was established with Jefferson Davis
as its President, and Montgomery, Alabama, as the Capital. The
secessionists had then to leave the cabinet. In their own estimation
they were aliens in the country which had given them birth. Loyal men
were put into their places. Treason in the executive branch of the
government was estopped. But the harm had already been done. The
stable door was locked after the horse had been stolen.
During all of the trying winter of 1860-1, when the Southerners
were so defiant that they would not allow within their borders the
expression of a sentiment hostile to their views, it was a brave man
indeed who could stand up and proclaim his loyalty to the Union. On
the other hand men at the North--prominent men--proclaimed that the
government had no power to coerce the South into submission to the
laws of the land; that if the North undertook to raise armies to go
south, these armies would have to march over the dead bodies of the
speakers. A portion of the press of the North was constantly
proclaiming similar views. When the time arrived for the
President-elect to go to the capital of the Nation to be sworn into
office, it was deemed unsafe for him to travel, not only as a
President-elect, but as any private citizen should be allowed to do.
Instead of going in a special car, receiving the good wishes of his
constituents at all the stations along the road, he was obliged to
stop on the way and to be smuggled into the capital. He disappeared
from public view on his journey, and the next the country knew, his
arrival was announced at the capital. There is little doubt that he
would have been assassinated if he had attempted to travel openly
throughout his journey.
The 4th of March, 1861, came, and Abraham Lincoln was sworn to
maintain the Union against all its enemies. The secession of one
State after another followed, until eleven had gone out. On the 11th
of April Fort Sumter, a National fort in the harbor of Charleston,
South Carolina, was fired upon by the Southerners and a few days after
was captured. The Confederates proclaimed themselves aliens, and
thereby debarred themselves of all right to claim protection under the
Constitution of the United States. We did not admit the fact that
they were aliens, but all the same, they debarred themselves of the
right to expect better treatment than people of any other foreign
state who make war upon an independent nation. Upon the firing on
Sumter President Lincoln issued his first call for troops and soon
after a proclamation convening Congress in extra session. The call
was for 75,000 volunteers for ninety days' service. If the shot fired
at Fort Sumter "was heard around the world," the call of the President
for 75,000 men was heard throughout the Northern States. There was
not a state in the North of a million of inhabitants that would not
have furnished the entire number faster than arms could have been
supplied to them, if it had been necessary.
As soon as the news of the call for volunteers reached Galena,
posters were stuck up calling for a meeting of the citizens at the
court-house in the evening. Business ceased entirely; all was
excitement; for a time there were no party distinctions; all were
Union men, determined to avenge the insult to the national flag. In
the evening the court-house was packed. Although a comparative
stranger I was called upon to preside; the sole reason, possibly, was
that I had been in the army and had seen service. With much
embarrassment and some prompting I made out to announce the object of
the meeting. Speeches were in order, but it is doubtful whether it
would have been safe just then to make other than patriotic ones.
There was probably no one in the house, however, who felt like making
any other. The two principal speeches were by B. B. Howard, the
post-master and a Breckinridge Democrat at the November election the
fall before, and John A. Rawlins, an elector on the Douglas ticket.
E. B. Washburne, with whom I was not acquainted at that time, came in
after the meeting had been organized, and expressed, I understood
afterwards, a little surprise that Galena could not furnish a
presiding officer for such an occasion without taking a stranger. He
came forward and was introduced, and made a speech appealing to the
patriotism of the meeting.
After the speaking was over volunteers were called for to form a
company. The quota of Illinois had been fixed at six regiments; and
it was supposed that one company would be as much as would be accepted
from Galena. The company was raised and the officers and
non-commissioned officers elected before the meeting adjourned. I
declined the captaincy before the balloting, but announced that I
would aid the company in every way I could and would be found in the
service in some position if there should be a war. I never went into
our leather store after that meeting, to put up a package or do other
business.
The ladies of Galena were quite as patriotic as the men. They
could not enlist, but they conceived the idea of sending their first
company to the field uniformed. They came to me to get a description
of the United States uniform for infantry; subscribed and bought the
material; procured tailors to cut out the garments, and the ladies
made them up. In a few days the company was in uniform and ready to
report at the State capital for assignment. The men all turned out
the morning after their enlistment, and I took charge, divided them
into squads and superintended their drill. When they were ready to go
to Springfield I went with them and remained there until they were
assigned to a regiment.
There were so many more volunteers than had been called for that
the question whom to accept was quite embarrassing to the governor,
Richard Yates. The legislature was in session at the time, however,
and came to his relief. A law was enacted authorizing the governor to
accept the services of ten additional regiments, one from each
congressional district, for one month, to be paid by the State, but
pledged to go into the service of the United States if there should be
a further call during their term. Even with this relief the governor
was still very much embarrassed. Before the war was over he was like
the President when he was taken with the varioloid: "at last he had
something he could give to all who wanted it."
In time the Galena company was mustered into the United States
service, forming a part of the 11th Illinois volunteer infantry. My
duties, I thought, had ended at Springfield, and I was prepared to
start home by the evening train, leaving at nine o'clock. Up to that
time I do not think I had been introduced to Governor Yates, or had
ever spoken to him. I knew him by sight, however, because he was
living at the same hotel and I often saw him at table. The evening I
was to quit the capital I left the supper room before the governor and
was standing at the front door when he came out. He spoke to me,
calling me by my old army title "Captain," and said he understood that
I was about leaving the city. I answered that I was. He said he
would be glad if I would remain over-night and call at the Executive
office the next morning. I complied with his request, and was asked
to go into the Adjutant-General's office and render such assistance as
I could, the governor saying that my army experience would be of great
service there. I accepted the proposition.
My old army experience I found indeed of very great service. I
was no clerk, nor had I any capacity to become one. The only place I
ever found in my life to put a paper so as to find it again was either
a side coat-pocket or the hands of a clerk or secretary more careful
than myself. But I had been quartermaster, commissary and adjutant in
the field. The army forms were familiar to me and I could direct how
they should be made out. There was a clerk in the office of the
Adjutant- General who supplied my deficiencies. The ease with which
the State of Illinois settled its accounts with the government at the
close of the war is evidence of the efficiency of Mr. Loomis as an
accountant on a large scale. He remained in the office until that
time.
As I have stated, the legislature authorized the governor to
accept the services of ten additional regiments. I had charge of
mustering these regiments into the State service. They were assembled
at the most convenient railroad centres in their respective
congressional districts. I detailed officers to muster in a portion
of them, but mustered three in the southern part of the State myself.
One of these was to assemble at Belleville, some eighteen miles
south-east of St. Louis. When I got there I found that only one or
two companies had arrived. There was no probability of the regiment
coming together under five days. This gave me a few idle days which I
concluded to spend in St. Louis.
There was a considerable force of State militia at Camp Jackson,
on the outskirts of St. Louis, at the time. There is but little
doubt that it was the design of Governor Claiborn Jackson to have
these troops ready to seize the United States arsenal and the city of
St. Louis. Why they did not do so I do not know. There was but a
small garrison, two companies I think, under Captain N. Lyon at the
arsenal, and but for the timely services of the Hon. F. P. Blair, I
have little doubt that St. Louis would have gone into rebel hands, and
with it the arsenal with all its arms and ammunition.
Blair was a leader among the Union men of St. Louis in 1861. There
was no State government in Missouri at the time that would sanction
the raising of troops or commissioned officers to protect United
States property, but Blair had probably procured some form of
authority from the President to raise troops in Missouri and to muster
them into the service of the United States. At all events, he did
raise a regiment and took command himself as Colonel. With this force
he reported to Captain Lyon and placed himself and regiment under his
orders. It was whispered that Lyon thus reinforced intended to break
up Camp Jackson and capture the militia. I went down to the arsenal
in the morning to see the troops start out. I had known Lyon for two
years at West Point and in the old army afterwards. Blair I knew very
well by sight. I had heard him speak in the canvass of 1858, possibly
several times, but I had never spoken to him. As the troops marched
out of the enclosure around the arsenal, Blair was on his horse
outside forming them into line preparatory to their march. I
introduced myself to him and had a few moments' conversation and
expressed my sympathy with his purpose. This was my first personal
acquaintance with the Honorable--afterwards Major-General F. P. Blair.
Camp Jackson surrendered without a fight and the garrison was marched
down to the arsenal as prisoners of war.
Up to this time the enemies of the government in St. Louis had
been bold and defiant, while Union men were quiet but determined.
The enemies had their head-quarters in a central and public position
on Pine Street, near Fifth--from which the rebel flag was flaunted
boldly. The Union men had a place of meeting somewhere in the city, I
did not know where, and I doubt whether they dared to enrage the
enemies of the government by placing the national flag outside their
head-quarters. As soon as the news of the capture of Camp Jackson
reached the city the condition of affairs was changed. Union men
became rampant, aggressive, and, if you will, intolerant. They
proclaimed their sentiments boldly, and were impatient at anything
like disrespect for the Union. The secessionists became quiet but
were filled with suppressed rage. They had been playing the bully.
The Union men ordered the rebel flag taken down from the building on
Pine Street. The command was given in tones of authority and it was
taken down, never to be raised again in St. Louis.
I witnessed the scene. I had heard of the surrender of the camp
and that the garrison was on its way to the arsenal. I had seen the
troops start out in the morning and had wished them success. I now
determined to go to the arsenal and await their arrival and
congratulate them. I stepped on a car standing at the corner of 4th
and Pine streets, and saw a crowd of people standing quietly in front
of the head-quarters, who were there for the purpose of hauling down
the flag. There were squads of other people at intervals down the
street. They too were quiet but filled with suppressed rage, and
muttered their resentment at the insult to, what they called, "their"
flag. Before the car I was in had started, a dapper little fellow--he
would be called a dude at this day--stepped in. He was in a great
state of excitement and used adjectives freely to express his contempt
for the Union and for those who had just perpetrated such an outrage
upon the rights of a free people. There was only one other passenger
in the car besides myself when this young man entered. He evidently
expected to find nothing but sympathy when he got away from the "mud
sills" engaged in compelling a "free people" to pull down a flag they
adored. He turned to me saying: "Things have come to a ---- pretty
pass when a free people can't choose their own flag. Where I came
from if a man dares to say a word in favor of the Union we hang him to
a limb of the first tree we come to." I replied that "after all we
were not so intolerant in St. Louis as we might be; I had not seen a
single rebel hung yet, nor heard of one; there were plenty of them who
ought to be, however." The young man subsided. He was so crestfallen
that I believe if I had ordered him to leave the car he would have
gone quietly out, saying to himself: "More Yankee oppression."
By nightfall the late defenders of Camp Jackson were all within
the walls of the St. Louis arsenal, prisoners of war. The next day I
left St. Louis for Mattoon, Illinois, where I was to muster in the
regiment from that congressional district. This was the 21st Illinois
infantry, the regiment of which I subsequently became colonel. I
mustered one regiment afterwards, when my services for the State were
about closed.
Brigadier-General John Pope was stationed at Springfield, as
United States mustering officer, all the time I was in the State
service. He was a native of Illinois and well acquainted with most
of the prominent men in the State. I was a carpet-bagger and knew but
few of them. While I was on duty at Springfield the senators,
representatives in Congress, ax-governors and the State legislators
were nearly all at the State capital. The only acquaintance I made
among them was with the governor, whom I was serving, and, by chance,
with Senator S. A. Douglas. The only members of Congress I knew were
Washburne and Philip Foulk. With the former, though he represented my
district and we were citizens of the same town, I only became
acquainted at the meeting when the first company of Galena volunteers
was raised. Foulk I had known in St. Louis when I was a citizen of
that city. I had been three years at West Point with Pope and had
served with him a short time during the Mexican war, under General
Taylor. I saw a good deal of him during my service with the State.
On one occasion he said to me that I ought to go into the United
States service. I told him I intended to do so if there was a war.
He spoke of his acquaintance with the public men of the State, and
said he could get them to recommend me for a position and that he
would do all he could for me. I declined to receive endorsement for
permission to fight for my country.
Going home for a day or two soon after this conversation with
General Pope, I wrote from Galena the following letter to the
Adjutant-General of the Army.
GALENA, ILLINOIS, May 24, 1861.
COL. L. THOMAS Adjt. Gen. U. S. A., Washington, D. C.
SIR:--Having served for fifteen years in the regular army,
including four years at West Point, and feeling it the duty of every
one who has been educated at the Government expense to offer their
services for the support of that Government, I have the honor, very
respectfully, to tender my services, until the close of the war, in
such capacity as may be offered. I would say, in view of my present
age and length of service, I feel myself competent to command a
regiment, if the President, in his judgment, should see fit to intrust
one to me.
Since the first call of the President I have been serving on the
staff of the Governor of this State, rendering such aid as I could in
the organization of our State militia, and am still engaged in that
capacity. A letter addressed to me at Springfield, Illinois, will
reach me.
I am very respectfully, Your obt. svt., U. S. GRANT.
This letter failed to elicit an answer from the Adjutant-General
of the Army. I presume it was hardly read by him, and certainly it
could not have been submitted to higher authority. Subsequent to the
war General Badeau having heard of this letter applied to the War
Department for a copy of it. The letter could not be found and no one
recollected ever having seen it. I took no copy when it was written.
Long after the application of General Badeau, General Townsend, who
had become Adjutant-General of the Army, while packing up papers
preparatory to the removal of his office, found this letter in some
out-of-the-way place. It had not been destroyed, but it had not been
regularly filed away.
I felt some hesitation in suggesting rank as high as the colonelcy
of a regiment, feeling somewhat doubtful whether I would be equal to
the position. But I had seen nearly every colonel who had been
mustered in from the State of Illinois, and some from Indiana, and
felt that if they could command a regiment properly, and with credit,
I could also.
Having but little to do after the muster of the last of the
regiments authorized by the State legislature, I asked and obtained
of the governor leave of absence for a week to visit my parents in
Covington, Kentucky, immediately opposite Cincinnati. General
McClellan had been made a major-general and had his headquarters at
Cincinnati. In reality I wanted to see him. I had known him slightly
at West Point, where we served one year together, and in the Mexican
war. I was in hopes that when he saw me he would offer me a position
on his staff. I called on two successive days at his office but
failed to see him on either occasion, and returned to Springfield.
While I was absent from the State capital on this occasion the
President's second call for troops was issued. This time it was for
300,000 men, for three years or the war. This brought into the United
States service all the regiments then in the State service. These had
elected their officers from highest to lowest and were accepted with
their organizations as they were, except in two instances. A Chicago
regiment, the 19th infantry, had elected a very young man to the
colonelcy. When it came to taking the field the regiment asked to
have another appointed colonel and the one they had previously chosen
made lieutenant-colonel. The 21st regiment of infantry, mustered in
by me at Mattoon, refused to go into the service with the colonel of
their selection in any position. While I was still absent Governor
Yates appointed me colonel of this latter regiment. A few days after
I was in charge of it and in camp on the fair grounds near
Springfield.
My regiment was composed in large part of young men of as good
social position as any in their section of the State. It embraced
the sons of farmers, lawyers, physicians, politicians, merchants,
bankers and ministers, and some men of maturer years who had filled
such positions themselves. There were also men in it who could be led
astray; and the colonel, elected by the votes of the regiment, had
proved to be fully capable of developing all there was in his men of
recklessness. It was said that he even went so far at times as to
take the guard from their posts and go with them to the village near
by and make a night of it. When there came a prospect of battle the
regiment wanted to have some one else to lead them. I found it very
hard work for a few days to bring all the men into anything like
subordination; but the great majority favored discipline, and by the
application of a little regular army punishment all were reduced to as
good discipline as one could ask.
The ten regiments which had volunteered in the State service for
thirty days, it will be remembered, had done so with a pledge to go
into the National service if called upon within that time. When they
volunteered the government had only called for ninety days'
enlistments. Men were called now for three years or the war. They
felt that this change of period released them from the obligation of
re-volunteering. When I was appointed colonel, the 21st regiment was
still in the State service. About the time they were to be mustered
into the United States service, such of them as would go, two members
of Congress from the State, McClernand and Logan, appeared at the
capital and I was introduced to them. I had never seen either of them
before, but I had read a great deal about them, and particularly about
Logan, in the newspapers. Both were democratic members of Congress,
and Logan had been elected from the southern district of the State,
where he had a majority of eighteen thousand over his Republican
competitor. His district had been settled originally by people from
the Southern States, and at the breaking out of secession they
sympathized with the South. At the first outbreak of war some of them
joined the Southern army; many others were preparing to do so; others
rode over the country at night denouncing the Union, and made it as
necessary to guard railroad bridges over which National troops had to
pass in southern Illinois, as it was in Kentucky or any of the border
slave states. Logan's popularity in this district was unbounded. He
knew almost enough of the people in it by their Christian names, to
form an ordinary congressional district. As he went in politics, so
his district was sure to go. The Republican papers had been demanding
that he should announce where he stood on the questions which at that
time engrossed the whole of public thought. Some were very bitter in
their denunciations of his silence. Logan was not a man to be coerced
into an utterance by threats. He did, however, come out in a speech
before the adjournment of the special session of Congress which was
convened by the President soon after his inauguration, and announced
his undying loyalty and devotion to the Union. But I had not happened
to see that speech, so that when I first met Logan my impressions were
those formed from reading denunciations of him. McClernand, on the
other hand, had early taken strong grounds for the maintenance of the
Union and had been praised accordingly by the Republican papers. The
gentlemen who presented these two members of Congress asked me if I
would have any objections to their addressing my regiment. I
hesitated a little before answering. It was but a few days before the
time set for mustering into the United States service such of the men
as were willing to volunteer for three years or the war. I had some
doubt as to the effect a speech from Logan might have; but as he was
with McClernand, whose sentiments on the all-absorbing questions of
the day were well known, I gave my consent. McClernand spoke first;
and Logan followed in a speech which he has hardly equalled since for
force and eloquence. It breathed a loyalty and devotion to the Union
which inspired my men to such a point that they would have volunteered
to remain in the army as long as an enemy of the country continued to
bear arms against it. They entered the United States service almost
to a man.
General Logan went to his part of the State and gave his attention
to raising troops. The very men who at first made it necessary to
guard the roads in southern Illinois became the defenders of the
Union. Logan entered the service himself as colonel of a regiment and
rapidly rose to the rank of major-general. His district, which had
promised at first to give much trouble to the government, filled every
call made upon it for troops, without resorting to the draft. There
was no call made when there were not more volunteers than were asked
for. That congressional district stands credited at the War
Department to-day with furnishing more men for the army than it was
called on to supply.
I remained in Springfield with my regiment until the 3d of July,
when I was ordered to Quincy, Illinois. By that time the regiment
was in a good state of discipline and the officers and men were well
up in the company drill. There was direct railroad communication
between Springfield and Quincy, but I thought it would be good
preparation for the troops to march there. We had no transportation
for our camp and garrison equipage, so wagons were hired for the
occasion and on the 3d of July we started. There was no hurry, but
fair marches were made every day until the Illinois River was crossed.
There I was overtaken by a dispatch saying that the destination of
the regiment had been changed to Ironton, Missouri, and ordering me
to halt where I was and await the arrival of a steamer which had been
dispatched up the Illinois River to take the regiment to St. Louis.
The boat, when it did come, grounded on a sand-bar a few miles below
where we were in camp. We remained there several days waiting to have
the boat get off the bar, but before this occurred news came that an
Illinois regiment was surrounded by rebels at a point on the Hannibal
and St. Joe Railroad some miles west of Palmyra, in Missouri, and I
was ordered to proceed with all dispatch to their relief. We took the
cars and reached Quincy in a few hours.
When I left Galena for the last time to take command of the 21st
regiment I took with me my oldest son, Frederick D. Grant, then a lad
of eleven years of age. On receiving the order to take rail for
Quincy I wrote to Mrs. Grant, to relieve what I supposed would be her
great anxiety for one so young going into danger, that I would send
Fred home from Quincy by river. I received a prompt letter in reply
decidedly disapproving my proposition, and urging that the lad should
be allowed to accompany me. It came too late. Fred was already on
his way up the Mississippi bound for Dubuque, Iowa, from which place
there was a railroad to Galena.
My sensations as we approached what I supposed might be "a field
of battle" were anything but agreeable. I had been in all the
engagements in Mexico that it was possible for one person to be in;
but not in command. If some one else had been colonel and I had been
lieutenant-colonel I do not think I would have felt any trepidation.
Before we were prepared to cross the Mississippi River at Quincy my
anxiety was relieved; for the men of the besieged regiment came
straggling into town. I am inclined to think both sides got
frightened and ran away.
I took my regiment to Palmyra and remained there for a few days,
until relieved by the 19th Illinois infantry. From Palmyra I
proceeded to Salt River, the railroad bridge over which had been
destroyed by the enemy. Colonel John M. Palmer at that time
commanded the 13th Illinois, which was acting as a guard to workmen
who were engaged in rebuilding this bridge. Palmer was my senior and
commanded the two regiments as long as we remained together. The
bridge was finished in about two weeks, and I received orders to move
against Colonel Thomas Harris, who was said to be encamped at the
little town of Florida, some twenty-five miles south of where we then
were.
At the time of which I now write we had no transportation and the
country about Salt River was sparsely settled, so that it took some
days to collect teams and drivers enough to move the camp and garrison
equipage of a regiment nearly a thousand strong, together with a
week's supply of provision and some ammunition. While preparations
for the move were going on I felt quite comfortable; but when we got
on the road and found every house deserted I was anything but easy.
In the twenty- five miles we had to march we did not see a person,
old or young, male or female, except two horsemen who were on a road
that crossed ours. As soon as they saw us they decamped as fast as
their horses could carry them. I kept my men in the ranks and forbade
their entering any of the deserted houses or taking anything from
them. We halted at night on the road and proceeded the next morning
at an early hour. Harris had been encamped in a creek bottom for the
sake of being near water. The hills on either side of the creek extend
to a considerable height, possibly more than a hundred feet. As we
approached the brow of the hill from which it was expected we could
see Harris' camp, and possibly find his men ready formed to meet us,
my heart kept getting higher and higher until it felt to me as though
it was in my throat. I would have given anything then to have been
back in Illinois, but I had not the moral courage to halt and consider
what to do; I kept right on. When we reached a point from which the
valley below was in full view I halted. The place where Harris had
been encamped a few days before was still there and the marks of a
recent encampment were plainly visible, but the troops were gone. My
heart resumed its place. It occurred to me at once that Harris had
been as much afraid of me as I had been of him. This was a view of
the question I had never taken before; but it was one I never forgot
afterwards. From that event to the close of the war, I never
experienced trepidation upon confronting an enemy, though I always
felt more or less anxiety. I never forgot that he had as much reason
to fear my forces as I had his. The lesson was valuable.
Inquiries at the village of Florida divulged the fact that Colonel
Harris, learning of my intended movement, while my transportation was
being collected took time by the forelock and left Florida before I
had started from Salt River. He had increased the distance between us
by forty miles. The next day I started back to my old camp at Salt
River bridge. The citizens living on the line of our march had
returned to their houses after we passed, and finding everything in
good order, nothing carried away, they were at their front doors ready
to greet us now. They had evidently been led to believe that the
National troops carried death and devastation with them wherever they
went.
In a short time after our return to Salt River bridge I was
ordered with my regiment to the town of Mexico. General Pope was
then commanding the district embracing all of the State of Missouri
between the Mississippi and Missouri rivers, with his headquarters in
the village of Mexico. I was assigned to the command of a
sub-district embracing the troops in the immediate neighborhood, some
three regiments of infantry and a section of artillery. There was one
regiment encamped by the side of mine. I assumed command of the whole
and the first night sent the commander of the other regiment the
parole and countersign. Not wishing to be outdone in courtesy, he
immediately sent me the countersign for his regiment for the night.
When he was informed that the countersign sent to him was for use
with his regiment as well as mine, it was difficult to make him
understand that this was not an unwarranted interference of one
colonel over another. No doubt he attributed it for the time to the
presumption of a graduate of West Point over a volunteer pure and
simple. But the question was soon settled and we had no further
trouble.
My arrival in Mexico had been preceded by that of two or three
regiments in which proper discipline had not been maintained, and the
men had been in the habit of visiting houses without invitation and
helping themselves to food and drink, or demanding them from the
occupants. They carried their muskets while out of camp and made
every man they found take the oath of allegiance to the government. I
at once published orders prohibiting the soldiers from going into
private houses unless invited by the inhabitants, and from
appropriating private property to their own or to government uses.
The people were no longer molested or made afraid. I received the
most marked courtesy from the citizens of Mexico as long as I remained
there.
Up to this time my regiment had not been carried in the school of
the soldier beyond the company drill, except that it had received some
training on the march from Springfield to the Illinois River. There
was now a good opportunity of exercising it in the battalion drill.
While I was at West Point the tactics used in the army had been
Scott's and the musket the flint lock. I had never looked at a copy
of tactics from the time of my graduation. My standing in that branch
of studies had been near the foot of the class. In the Mexican war in
the summer of 1846, I had been appointed regimental quartermaster and
commissary and had not been at a battalion drill since. The arms had
been changed since then and Hardee's tactics had been adopted. I got
a copy of tactics and studied one lesson, intending to confine the
exercise of the first day to the commands I had thus learned. By
pursuing this course from day to day I thought I would soon get
through the volume.
We were encamped just outside of town on the common, among
scattering suburban houses with enclosed gardens, and when I got my
regiment in line and rode to the front I soon saw that if I attempted
to follow the lesson I had studied I would have to clear away some of
the houses and garden fences to make room. I perceived at once,
however, that Hardee's tactics--a mere translation from the French
with Hardee's name attached--was nothing more than common sense and
the progress of the age applied to Scott's system. The commands were
abbreviated and the movement expedited. Under the old tactics almost
every change in the order of march was preceded by a "halt," then came
the change, and then the "forward march." With the new tactics all
these changes could be made while in motion. I found no trouble in
giving commands that would take my regiment where I wanted it to go
and carry it around all obstacles. I do not believe that the officers
of the regiment ever discovered that I had never studied the tactics
that I used.
I had not been in Mexico many weeks when, reading a St. Louis
paper, I found the President had asked the Illinois delegation in
Congress to recommend some citizens of the State for the position of
brigadier-general, and that they had unanimously recommended me as
first on a list of seven. I was very much surprised because, as I
have said, my acquaintance with the Congressmen was very limited and I
did not know of anything I had done to inspire such confidence. The
papers of the next day announced that my name, with three others, had
been sent to the Senate, and a few days after our confirmation was
announced.
When appointed brigadier-general I at once thought it proper that
one of my aides should come from the regiment I had been commanding,
and so selected Lieutenant C. B. Lagow. While living in St. Louis, I
had had a desk in the law office of McClellan, Moody and Hillyer.
Difference in views between the members of the firm on the questions
of the day, and general hard times in the border cities, had broken up
this firm. Hillyer was quite a young man, then in his twenties, and
very brilliant. I asked him to accept a place on my staff. I also
wanted to take one man from my new home, Galena. The canvass in the
Presidential campaign the fall before had brought out a young lawyer
by the name of John A. Rawlins, who proved himself one of the ablest
speakers in the State. He was also a candidate for elector on the
Douglas ticket. When Sumter was fired upon and the integrity of the
Union threatened, there was no man more ready to serve his country
than he. I wrote at once asking him to accept the position of
assistant adjutant-general with the rank of captain, on my staff. He
was about entering the service as major of a new regiment then
organizing in the north-western part of the State; but he threw this
up and accepted my offer.
Neither Hillyer nor Lagow proved to have any particular taste or
special qualifications for the duties of the soldier, and the former
resigned during the Vicksburg campaign; the latter I relieved after
the battle of Chattanooga. Rawlins remained with me as long as he
lived, and rose to the rank of brigadier general and chief-of-staff to
the General of the Army--an office created for him--before the war
closed. He was an able man, possessed of great firmness, and could
say "no" so emphatically to a request which he thought should not be
granted that the person he was addressing would understand at once
that there was no use of pressing the matter. General Rawlins was a
very useful officer in other ways than this. I became very much
attached to him.
Shortly after my promotion I was ordered to Ironton, Missouri, to
command a district in that part of the State, and took the 21st
Illinois, my old regiment, with me. Several other regiments were
ordered to the same destination about the same time. Ironton is on
the Iron Mountain railroad, about seventy miles south of St. Louis,
and situated among hills rising almost to the dignity of mountains.
When I reached there, about the 8th of August, Colonel B. Gratz
Brown--afterwards Governor of Missouri and in 1872 Vice-Presidential
candidate--was in command. Some of his troops were ninety days' men
and their time had expired some time before. The men had no clothing
but what they had volunteered in, and much of this was so worn that
it would hardly stay on. General Hardee--the author of the tactics I
did not study--was at Greenville some twenty-five miles further south,
it was said, with five thousand Confederate troops. Under these
circumstances Colonel Brown's command was very much demoralized. A
squadron of cavalry could have ridden into the valley and captured the
entire force. Brown himself was gladder to see me on that occasion
than he ever has been since. I relieved him and sent all his men home
within a day or two, to be mustered out of service.
Within ten days after reading Ironton I was prepared to take the
offensive against the enemy at Greenville. I sent a column east out
of the valley we were in, with orders to swing around to the south and
west and come into the Greenville road ten miles south of Ironton.
Another column marched on the direct road and went into camp at the
point designated for the two columns to meet. I was to ride out the
next morning and take personal command of the movement. My experience
against Harris, in northern Missouri, had inspired me with confidence.
But when the evening train came in, it brought General B. M. Prentiss
with orders to take command of the district. His orders did not
relieve me, but I knew that by law I was senior, and at that time even
the President did not have the authority to assign a junior to
command a senior of the same grade. I therefore gave General
Prentiss the situation of the troops and the general condition of
affairs, and started for St. Louis the same day. The movement against
the rebels at Greenville went no further.
From St. Louis I was ordered to Jefferson City, the capital of the
State, to take command. General Sterling Price, of the Confederate
army, was thought to be threatening the capital, Lexington,
Chillicothe and other comparatively large towns in the central part of
Missouri. I found a good many troops in Jefferson City, but in the
greatest confusion, and no one person knew where they all were.
Colonel Mulligan, a gallant man, was in command, but he had not been
educated as yet to his new profession and did not know how to maintain
discipline. I found that volunteers had obtained permission from the
department commander, or claimed they had, to raise, some of them,
regiments; some battalions; some companies--the officers to be
commissioned according to the number of men they brought into the
service. There were recruiting stations all over town, with notices,
rudely lettered on boards over the doors, announcing the arm of
service and length of time for which recruits at that station would be
received. The law required all volunteers to serve for three years or
the war. But in Jefferson City in August, 1861, they were recruited
for different periods and on different conditions; some were enlisted
for six months, some for a year, some without any condition as to
where they were to serve, others were not to be sent out of the State.
The recruits were principally men from regiments stationed there and
already in the service, bound for three years if the war lasted that
long.
The city was filled with Union fugitives who had been driven by
guerilla bands to take refuge with the National troops. They were in
a deplorable condition and must have starved but for the support the
government gave them. They had generally made their escape with a
team or two, sometimes a yoke of oxen with a mule or a horse in the
lead. A little bedding besides their clothing and some food had been
thrown into the wagon. All else of their worldly goods were abandoned
and appropriated by their former neighbors; for the Union man in
Missouri who staid at home during the rebellion, if he was not
immediately under the protection of the National troops, was at
perpetual war with his neighbors. I stopped the recruiting service,
and disposed the troops about the outskirts of the city so as to guard
all approaches. Order was soon restored.
I had been at Jefferson City but a few days when I was directed
from department headquarters to fit out an expedition to Lexington,
Booneville and Chillicothe, in order to take from the banks in those
cities all the funds they had and send them to St. Louis. The western
army had not yet been supplied with transportation. It became
necessary therefore to press into the service teams belonging to
sympathizers with the rebellion or to hire those of Union men. This
afforded an opportunity of giving employment to such of the refugees
within our lines as had teams suitable for our purposes. They
accepted the service with alacrity. As fast as troops could be got
off they were moved west some twenty miles or more. In seven or eight
days from my assuming command at Jefferson City, I had all the troops,
except a small garrison, at an advanced position and expected to join
them myself the next day.
But my campaigns had not yet begun, for while seated at my office
door, with nothing further to do until it was time to start for the
front, I saw an officer of rank approaching, who proved to be Colonel
Jefferson C. Davis. I had never met him before, but he introduced
himself by handing me an order for him to proceed to Jefferson City
and relieve me of the command. The orders directed that I should
report at department headquarters at St. Louis without delay, to
receive important special instructions. It was about an hour before
the only regular train of the day would start. I therefore turned
over to Colonel Davis my orders, and hurriedly stated to him the
progress that had been made to carry out the department instructions
already described. I had at that time but one staff officer, doing
myself all the detail work usually performed by an adjutant-general.
In an hour after being relieved from the command I was on my way to
St. Louis, leaving my single staff officer(*6) to follow the next day
with our horses and baggage.
The "important special instructions" which I received the next
day, assigned me to the command of the district of south-east
Missouri, embracing all the territory south of St. Louis, in
Missouri, as well as all southern Illinois. At first I was to take
personal command of a combined expedition that had been ordered for
the capture of Colonel Jeff. Thompson, a sort of independent or
partisan commander who was disputing with us the possession of
south-east Missouri. Troops had been ordered to move from Ironton to
Cape Girardeau, sixty or seventy miles to the south-east, on the
Mississippi River; while the forces at Cape Girardeau had been ordered
to move to Jacksonville, ten miles out towards Ironton; and troops at
Cairo and Bird's Point, at the junction of the Ohio and Mississippi
rivers, were to hold themselves in readiness to go down the
Mississippi to Belmont, eighteen miles below, to be moved west from
there when an officer should come to command them. I was the officer
who had been selected for this purpose. Cairo was to become my
headquarters when the expedition terminated.
In pursuance of my orders I established my temporary headquarters
at Cape Girardeau and sent instructions to the commanding officer at
Jackson, to inform me of the approach of General Prentiss from
Ironton. Hired wagons were kept moving night and day to take
additional rations to Jackson, to supply the troops when they started
from there. Neither General Prentiss nor Colonel Marsh, who commanded
at Jackson, knew their destination. I drew up all the instructions
for the contemplated move, and kept them in my pocket until I should
hear of the junction of our troops at Jackson. Two or three days
after my arrival at Cape Girardeau, word came that General Prentiss
was approaching that place (Jackson). I started at once to meet him
there and to give him his orders. As I turned the first corner of a
street after starting, I saw a column of cavalry passing the next
street in front of me. I turned and rode around the block the other
way, so as to meet the head of the column. I found there General
Prentiss himself, with a large escort. He had halted his troops at
Jackson for the night, and had come on himself to Cape Girardeau,
leaving orders for his command to follow him in the morning. I gave
the General his orders--which stopped him at Jackson--but he was very
much aggrieved at being placed under another brigadier-general,
particularly as he believed himself to be the senior. He had been a
brigadier, in command at Cairo, while I was mustering officer at
Springfield without any rank. But we were nominated at the same time
for the United States service, and both our commissions bore date May
17th, 1861. By virtue of my former army rank I was, by law, the
senior. General Prentiss failed to get orders to his troops to remain
at Jackson, and the next morning early they were reported as
approaching Cape Girardeau. I then ordered the General very
peremptorily to countermarch his command and take it back to Jackson.
He obeyed the order, but bade his command adieu when he got them to
Jackson, and went to St. Louis and reported himself. This broke up
the expedition. But little harm was done, as Jeff. Thompson moved
light and had no fixed place for even nominal headquarters. He was as
much at home in Arkansas as he was in Missouri and would keep out of
the way of a superior force. Prentiss was sent to another part of the
State.
General Prentiss made a great mistake on the above occasion, one
that he would not have committed later in the war. When I came to
know him better, I regretted it much. In consequence of this
occurrence he was off duty in the field when the principal campaign
at the West was going on, and his juniors received promotion while he
was where none could be obtained. He would have been next to myself
in rank in the district of south-east Missouri, by virtue of his
services in the Mexican war. He was a brave and very earnest soldier.
No man in the service was more sincere in his devotion to the cause
for which we were battling; none more ready to make sacrifices or risk
life in it.
On the 4th of September I removed my headquarters to Cairo and
found Colonel Richard Oglesby in command of the post. We had never
met, at least not to my knowledge. After my promotion I had ordered
my brigadier-general's uniform from New York, but it had not yet
arrived, so that I was in citizen's dress. The Colonel had his office
full of people, mostly from the neighboring States of Missouri and
Kentucky, making complaints or asking favors. He evidently did not
catch my name when I was presented, for on my taking a piece of paper
from the table where he was seated and writing the order assuming
command of the district of south-east Missouri, Colonel Richard J.
Oglesby to command the post at Bird's Point, and handing it to him, he
put on an expression of surprise that looked a little as if he would
like to have some one identify me. But he surrendered the office
without question.
The day after I assumed command at Cairo a man came to me who said
he was a scout of General Fremont. He reported that he had just come
from Columbus, a point on the Mississippi twenty miles below on the
Kentucky side, and that troops had started from there, or were about
to start, to seize Paducah, at the mouth of the Tennessee. There was
no time for delay; I reported by telegraph to the department commander
the information I had received, and added that I was taking steps to
get off that night to be in advance of the enemy in securing that
important point. There was a large number of steamers Iying at Cairo
and a good many boatmen were staying in the town. It was the work of
only a few hours to get the boats manned, with coal aboard and steam
up. Troops were also designated to go aboard. The distance from
Cairo to Paducah is about forty-five miles. I did not wish to get
there before daylight of the 6th, and directed therefore that the
boats should lie at anchor out in the stream until the time to start.
Not having received an answer to my first dispatch, I again
telegraphed to department headquarters that I should start for Paducah
that night unless I received further orders. Hearing nothing, we
started before midnight and arrived early the following morning,
anticipating the enemy by probably not over six or eight hours. It
proved very fortunate that the expedition against Jeff. Thompson had
been broken up. Had it not been, the enemy would have seized Paducah
and fortified it, to our very great annoyance.
When the National troops entered the town the citizens were taken
by surprise. I never after saw such consternation depicted on the
faces of the people. Men, women and children came out of their doors
looking pale and frightened at the presence of the invader. They were
expecting rebel troops that day. In fact, nearly four thousand men
from Columbus were at that time within ten or fifteen miles of Paducah
on their way to occupy the place. I had but two regiments and one
battery with me, but the enemy did not know this and returned to
Columbus. I stationed my troops at the best points to guard the roads
leading into the city, left gunboats to guard the river fronts and by
noon was ready to start on my return to Cairo. Before leaving,
however, I addressed a short printed proclamation to the citizens of
Paducah assuring them of our peaceful intentions, that we had come
among them to protect them against the enemies of our country, and
that all who chose could continue their usual avocations with
assurance of the protection of the government. This was evidently a
relief to them; but the majority would have much preferred the
presence of the other army. I reinforced Paducah rapidly from the
troops at Cape Girardeau; and a day or two later General C. F. Smith,
a most accomplished soldier, reported at Cairo and was assigned to the
command of the post at the mouth of the Tennessee. In a short time
it was well fortified and a detachment was sent to occupy Smithland,
at the mouth of the Cumberland.
The State government of Kentucky at that time was rebel in
sentiment, but wanted to preserve an armed neutrality between the
North and the South, and the governor really seemed to think the State
had a perfect right to maintain a neutral position. The rebels already
occupied two towns in the State, Columbus and Hickman, on the
Mississippi; and at the very moment the National troops were entering
Paducah from the Ohio front, General Lloyd Tilghman--a
Confederate--with his staff and a small detachment of men, were
getting out in the other direction, while, as I have already said,
nearly four thousand Confederate troops were on Kentucky soil on their
way to take possession of the town. But, in the estimation of the
governor and of those who thought with him, this did not justify the
National authorities in invading the soil of Kentucky. I informed the
legislature of the State of what I was doing, and my action was
approved by the majority of that body. On my return to Cairo I found
authority from department headquarters for me to take Paducah "if I
felt strong enough," but very soon after I was reprimanded from the
same quarters for my correspondence with the legislature and warned
against a repetition of the offence.
Soon after I took command at Cairo, General Fremont entered into
arrangements for the exchange of the prisoners captured at Camp
Jackson in the month of May. I received orders to pass them through
my lines to Columbus as they presented themselves with proper
credentials. Quite a number of these prisoners I had been personally
acquainted with before the war. Such of them as I had so known were
received at my headquarters as old acquaintances, and ordinary routine
business was not disturbed by their presence. On one occasion when
several were present in my office my intention to visit Cape Girardeau
the next day, to inspect the troops at that point, was mentioned.
Something transpired which postponed my trip; but a steamer employed
by the government was passing a point some twenty or more miles above
Cairo, the next day, when a section of rebel artillery with proper
escort brought her to. A major, one of those who had been at my
headquarters the day before, came at once aboard and after some search
made a direct demand for my delivery. It was hard to persuade him
that I was not there. This officer was Major Barrett, of St. Louis.
I had been acquainted with his family before the war.
From the occupation of Paducah up to the early part of November
nothing important occurred with the troops under my command. I was
reinforced from time to time and the men were drilled and disciplined
preparatory for the service which was sure to come. By the 1st of
November I had not fewer than 20,000 men, most of them under good
drill and ready to meet any equal body of men who, like themselves,
had not yet been in an engagement. They were growing impatient at
lying idle so long, almost in hearing of the guns of the enemy they
had volunteered to fight against. I asked on one or two occasions to
be allowed to move against Columbus. It could have been taken soon
after the occupation of Paducah; but before November it was so
strongly fortified that it would have required a large force and a
long siege to capture it.
In the latter part of October General Fremont took the field in
person and moved from Jefferson City against General Sterling Price,
who was then in the State of Missouri with a considerable command.
About the first of November I was directed from department
headquarters to make a demonstration on both sides of the Mississippi
River with the view of detaining the rebels at Columbus within their
lines. Before my troops could be got off, I was notified from the
same quarter that there were some 3,000 of the enemy on the St.
Francis River about fifty miles west, or south-west, from Cairo, and
was ordered to send another force against them. I dispatched Colonel
Oglesby at once with troops sufficient to compete with the reported
number of the enemy. On the 5th word came from the same source that
the rebels were about to detach a large force from Columbus to be
moved by boats down the Mississippi and up the White River, in
Arkansas, in order to reinforce Price, and I was directed to prevent
this movement if possible. I accordingly sent a regiment from Bird's
Point under Colonel W. H. L. Wallace to overtake and reinforce
Oglesby, with orders to march to New Madrid, a point some distance
below Columbus, on the Missouri side. At the same time I directed
General C. F. Smith to move all the troops he could spare from
Paducah directly against Columbus, halting them, however, a few miles
from the town to await further orders from me. Then I gathered up all
the troops at Cairo and Fort Holt, except suitable guards, and moved
them down the river on steamers convoyed by two gunboats, accompanying
them myself. My force consisted of a little over 3,000 men and
embraced five regiments of infantry, two guns and two companies of
cavalry. We dropped down the river on the 6th to within about six
miles of Columbus, debarked a few men on the Kentucky side and
established pickets to connect with the troops from Paducah.
I had no orders which contemplated an attack by the National
troops, nor did I intend anything of the kind when I started out from
Cairo; but after we started I saw that the officers and men were
elated at the prospect of at last having the opportunity of doing what
they had volunteered to do--fight the enemies of their country. I did
not see how I could maintain discipline, or retain the confidence of
my command, if we should return to Cairo without an effort to do
something. Columbus, besides being strongly fortified, contained a
garrison much more numerous than the force I had with me. It would
not do, therefore, to attack that point. About two o'clock on the
morning of the 7th, I learned that the enemy was crossing troops from
Columbus to the west bank to be dispatched, presumably, after Oglesby.
I knew there was a small camp of Confederates at Belmont, immediately
opposite Columbus, and I speedily resolved to push down the river,
land on the Missouri side, capture Belmont, break up the camp and
return. Accordingly, the pickets above Columbus were drawn in at
once, and about daylight the boats moved out from shore. In an hour
we were debarking on the west bank of the Mississippi, just out of
range of the batteries at Columbus.
The ground on the west shore of the river, opposite Columbus, is
low and in places marshy and cut up with sloughs. The soil is rich
and the timber large and heavy. There were some small clearings
between Belmont and the point where we landed, but most of the country
was covered with the native forests. We landed in front of a
cornfield. When the debarkation commenced, I took a regiment down the
river to post it as a guard against surprise. At that time I had no
staff officer who could be trusted with that duty. In the woods, at a
short distance below the clearing, I found a depression, dry at the
time, but which at high water became a slough or bayou. I placed the
men in the hollow, gave them their instructions and ordered them to
remain there until they were properly relieved. These troops, with
the gunboats, were to protect our transports.
Up to this time the enemy had evidently failed to divine our
intentions. From Columbus they could, of course, see our gunboats
and transports loaded with troops. But the force from Paducah was
threatening them from the land side, and it was hardly to be expected
that if Columbus was our object we would separate our troops by a wide
river. They doubtless thought we meant to draw a large force from the
east bank, then embark ourselves, land on the east bank and make a
sudden assault on Columbus before their divided command could be
united.
About eight o'clock we started from the point of debarkation,
marching by the flank. After moving in this way for a mile or a mile
and a half, I halted where there was marshy ground covered with a
heavy growth of timber in our front, and deployed a large part of my
force as skirmishers. By this time the enemy discovered that we were
moving upon Belmont and sent out troops to meet us. Soon after we had
started in line, his skirmishers were encountered and fighting
commenced. This continued, growing fiercer and fiercer, for about
four hours, the enemy being forced back gradually until he was driven
into his camp. Early in this engagement my horse was shot under me,
but I got another from one of my staff and kept well up with the
advance until the river was reached.
The officers and men engaged at Belmont were then under fire for
the first time. Veterans could not have behaved better than they did
up to the moment of reaching the rebel camp. At this point they
became demoralized from their victory and failed to reap its full
reward. The enemy had been followed so closely that when he reached
the clear ground on which his camp was pitched he beat a hasty retreat
over the river bank, which protected him from our shots and from view.
This precipitate retreat at the last moment enabled the National
forces to pick their way without hinderance through the abatis--the
only artificial defence the enemy had. The moment the camp was
reached our men laid down their arms and commenced rummaging the tents
to pick up trophies. Some of the higher officers were little better
than the privates. They galloped about from one cluster of men to
another and at every halt delivered a short eulogy upon the Union
cause and the achievements of the command.
All this time the troops we had been engaged with for four hours,
lay crouched under cover of the river bank, ready to come up and
surrender if summoned to do so; but finding that they were not
pursued, they worked their way up the river and came up on the bank
between us and our transports. I saw at the same time two steamers
coming from the Columbus side towards the west shore, above us,
black--or gray--with soldiers from boiler-deck to roof. Some of my
men were engaged in firing from captured guns at empty steamers down
the river, out of range, cheering at every shot. I tried to get them
to turn their guns upon the loaded steamers above and not so far away.
My efforts were in vain. At last I directed my staff officers to set
fire to the camps. This drew the fire of the enemy's guns located on
the heights of Columbus. They had abstained from firing before,
probably because they were afraid of hitting their own men; or they
may have supposed, until the camp was on fire, that it was still in
the possession of their friends. About this time, too, the men we had
driven over the bank were seen in line up the river between us and our
transports. The alarm "surrounded" was given. The guns of the enemy
and the report of being surrounded, brought officers and men
completely under control. At first some of the officers seemed to
think that to be surrounded was to be placed in a hopeless position,
where there was nothing to do but surrender. But when I announced
that we had cut our way in and could cut our way out just as well, it
seemed a new revelation to officers and soldiers. They formed line
rapidly and we started back to our boats, with the men deployed as
skirmishers as they had been on entering camp. The enemy was soon
encountered, but his resistance this time was feeble. Again the
Confederates sought shelter under the river banks. We could not
stop, however, to pick them up, because the troops we had seen
crossing the river had debarked by this time and were nearer our
transports than we were. It would be prudent to get them behind us;
but we were not again molested on our way to the boats.
From the beginning of the fighting our wounded had been carried to
the houses at the rear, near the place of debarkation. I now set the
troops to bringing their wounded to the boats. After this had gone on
for some little time I rode down the road, without even a staff
officer, to visit the guard I had stationed over the approach to our
transports. I knew the enemy had crossed over from Columbus in
considerable numbers and might be expected to attack us as we were
embarking. This guard would be encountered first and, as they were in
a natural intrenchment, would be able to hold the enemy for a
considerable time. My surprise was great to find there was not a
single man in the trench. Riding back to the boat I found the officer
who had commanded the guard and learned that he had withdrawn his
force when the main body fell back. At first I ordered the guard to
return, but finding that it would take some time to get the men
together and march them back to their position, I countermanded the
order. Then fearing that the enemy we had seen crossing the river
below might be coming upon us unawares, I rode out in the field to our
front, still entirely alone, to observe whether the enemy was passing.
The field was grown up with corn so tall and thick as to cut off the
view of even a person on horseback, except directly along the rows.
Even in that direction, owing to the overhanging blades of corn, the
view was not extensive. I had not gone more than a few hundred yards
when I saw a body of troops marching past me not fifty yards away. I
looked at them for a moment and then turned my horse towards the river
and started back, first in a walk, and when I thought myself
concealed from the view of the enemy, as fast as my horse could carry
me. When at the river bank I still had to ride a few hundred yards to
the point where the nearest transport lay.
The cornfield in front of our transports terminated at the edge of
a dense forest. Before I got back the enemy had entered this forest
and had opened a brisk fire upon the boats. Our men, with the
exception of details that had gone to the front after the wounded,
were now either aboard the transports or very near them. Those who
were not aboard soon got there, and the boats pushed off. I was the
only man of the National army between the rebels and our transports.
The captain of a boat that had just pushed out but had not started,
recognized me and ordered the engineer not to start the engine; he
then had a plank run out for me. My horse seemed to take in the
situation. There was no path down the bank and every one acquainted
with the Mississippi River knows that its banks, in a natural state,
do not vary at any great angle from the perpendicular. My horse put
his fore feet over the bank without hesitation or urging, and with his
hind feet well under him, slid down the bank and trotted aboard the
boat, twelve or fifteen feet away, over a single gang plank. I
dismounted and went at once to the upper deck.
The Mississippi River was low on the 7th of November, 1861, so
that the banks were higher than the heads of men standing on the
upper decks of the steamers. The rebels were some distance back from
the river, so that their fire was high and did us but little harm.
Our smoke-stack was riddled with bullets, but there were only three
men wounded on the boats, two of whom were soldiers. When I first
went on deck I entered the captain's room adjoining the pilot-house,
and threw myself on a sofa. I did not keep that position a moment,
but rose to go out on the deck to observe what was going on. I had
scarcely left when a musket ball entered the room, struck the head of
the sofa, passed through it and lodged in the foot.
When the enemy opened fire on the transports our gunboats returned
it with vigor. They were well out in the stream and some distance
down, so that they had to give but very little elevation to their guns
to clear the banks of the river. Their position very nearly enfiladed
the line of the enemy while he was marching through the cornfield.
The execution was very great, as we could see at the time and as I
afterwards learned more positively. We were very soon out of range
and went peacefully on our way to Cairo, every man feeling that
Belmont was a great victory and that he had contributed his share to
it.
Our loss at Belmont was 485 in killed, wounded and missing. About
125 of our wounded fell into the hands of the enemy. We returned with
175 prisoners and two guns, and spiked four other pieces. The loss of
the enemy, as officially reported, was 642 men, killed, wounded and
missing. We had engaged about 2,500 men, exclusive of the guard left
with the transports. The enemy had about 7,000; but this includes the
troops brought over from Columbus who were not engaged in the first
defence of Belmont.
The two objects for which the battle of Belmont was fought were
fully accomplished. The enemy gave up all idea of detaching troops
from Columbus. His losses were very heavy for that period of the war.
Columbus was beset by people looking for their wounded or dead kin,
to take them home for medical treatment or burial. I learned later,
when I had moved further south, that Belmont had caused more mourning
than almost any other battle up to that time. The National troops
acquired a confidence in themselves at Belmont that did not desert
them through the war.
The day after the battle I met some officers from General Polk's
command, arranged for permission to bury our dead at Belmont and also
commenced negotiations for the exchange of prisoners. When our men
went to bury their dead, before they were allowed to land they were
conducted below the point where the enemy had engaged our transports.
Some of the officers expressed a desire to see the field; but the
request was refused with the statement that we had no dead there.
While on the truce-boat I mentioned to an officer, whom I had
known both at West Point and in the Mexican war, that I was in the
cornfield near their troops when they passed; that I had been on
horseback and had worn a soldier's overcoat at the time. This officer
was on General Polk's staff. He said both he and the general had seen
me and that Polk had said to his men, "There is a Yankee; you may try
your marksmanship on him if you wish," but nobody fired at me.
Belmont was severely criticised in the North as a wholly
unnecessary battle, barren of results, or the possibility of them
from the beginning. If it had not been fought, Colonel Oglesby would
probably have been captured or destroyed with his three thousand men.
Then I should have been culpable indeed.
While at Cairo I had frequent opportunities of meeting the rebel
officers of the Columbus garrison. They seemed to be very fond of
coming up on steamers under flags of truce. On two or three occasions
I went down in like manner. When one of their boats was seen coming
up carrying a white flag, a gun would be fired from the lower battery
at Fort Holt, throwing a shot across the bow as a signal to come no
farther. I would then take a steamer and, with my staff and
occasionally a few other officers, go down to receive the party.
There were several officers among them whom I had known before, both
at West Point and in Mexico. Seeing these officers who had been
educated for the profession of arms, both at school and in actual war,
which is a far more efficient training, impressed me with the great
advantage the South possessed over the North at the beginning of the
rebellion. They had from thirty to forty per cent. of the educated
soldiers of the Nation. They had no standing army and, consequently,
these trained soldiers had to find employment with the troops from
their own States. In this way what there was of military education
and training was distributed throughout their whole army. The whole
loaf was leavened.
The North had a great number of educated and trained soldiers, but
the bulk of them were still in the army and were retained, generally
with their old commands and rank, until the war had lasted many
months. In the Army of the Potomac there was what was known as the
"regular brigade," in which, from the commanding officer down to the
youngest second lieutenant, every one was educated to his profession.
So, too, with many of the batteries; all the officers, generally four
in number to each, were men educated for their profession. Some of
these went into battle at the beginning under division commanders who
were entirely without military training. This state of affairs gave
me an idea which I expressed while at Cairo; that the government
ought to disband the regular army, with the exception of the staff
corps, and notify the disbanded officers that they would receive no
compensation while the war lasted except as volunteers. The register
should be kept up, but the names of all officers who were not in the
volunteer service at the close, should be stricken from it.
On the 9th of November, two days after the battle of Belmont,
Major-General H. W. Halleck superseded General Fremont in command of
the Department of the Missouri. The limits of his command took in
Arkansas and west Kentucky east to the Cumberland River. From the
battle of Belmont until early in February, 1862, the troops under my
command did little except prepare for the long struggle which proved
to be before them.
The enemy at this time occupied a line running from the
Mississippi River at Columbus to Bowling Green and Mill Springs,
Kentucky. Each of these positions was strongly fortified, as were
also points on the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers near the Tennessee
state line. The works on the Tennessee were called Fort Heiman and
Fort Henry, and that on the Cumberland was Fort Donelson. At these
points the two rivers approached within eleven miles of each other.
The lines of rifle pits at each place extended back from the water at
least two miles, so that the garrisons were in reality only seven
miles apart. These positions were of immense importance to the enemy;
and of course correspondingly important for us to possess ourselves
of. With Fort Henry in our hands we had a navigable stream open to us
up to Muscle Shoals, in Alabama. The Memphis and Charleston Railroad
strikes the Tennessee at Eastport, Mississippi, and follows close to
the banks of the river up to the shoals. This road, of vast
importance to the enemy, would cease to be of use to them for through
traffic the moment Fort Henry became ours. Fort Donelson was the gate
to Nashville--a place of great military and political importance--and
to a rich country extending far east in Kentucky. These two points in
our possession the enemy would necessarily be thrown back to the
Memphis and Charleston road, or to the boundary of the cotton states,
and, as before stated, that road would be lost to them for through
communication.
The designation of my command had been changed after Halleck's
arrival, from the District of South-east Missouri to the District of
Cairo, and the small district commanded by General C. F. Smith,
embracing the mouths of the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers, had been
added to my jurisdiction. Early in January, 1862, I was directed by
General McClellan, through my department commander, to make a
reconnoissance in favor of Brigadier-General Don Carlos Buell, who
commanded the Department of the Ohio, with headquarters at Louisville,
and who was confronting General S. B. Buckner with a larger
Confederate force at Bowling Green. It was supposed that Buell was
about to make some move against the enemy, and my demonstration was
intended to prevent the sending of troops from Columbus, Fort Henry
or Donelson to Buckner. I at once ordered General Smith to send a
force up the west bank of the Tennessee to threaten forts Heiman and
Henry; McClernand at the same time with a force of 6,000 men was sent
out into west Kentucky, threatening Columbus with one column and the
Tennessee River with another. I went with McClernand's command. The
weather was very bad; snow and rain fell; the roads, never good in
that section, were intolerable. We were out more than a week
splashing through the mud, snow and rain, the men suffering very much.
The object of the expedition was accomplished. The enemy did not
send reinforcements to Bowling Green, and General George H. Thomas
fought and won the battle of Mill Springs before we returned.
As a result of this expedition General Smith reported that he
thought it practicable to capture Fort Heiman. This fort stood on
high ground, completely commanding Fort Henry on the opposite side of
the river, and its possession by us, with the aid of our gunboats,
would insure the capture of Fort Henry. This report of Smith's
confirmed views I had previously held, that the true line of
operations for us was up the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers. With us
there, the enemy would be compelled to fall back on the east and west
entirely out of the State of Kentucky. On the 6th of January, before
receiving orders for this expedition, I had asked permission of the
general commanding the department to go to see him at St. Louis. My
object was to lay this plan of campaign before him. Now that my
views had been confirmed by so able a general as Smith, I renewed my
request to go to St. Louis on what I deemed important military
business. The leave was granted, but not graciously. I had known
General Halleck but very slightly in the old army, not having met him
either at West Point or during the Mexican war. I was received with so
little cordiality that I perhaps stated the object of my visit with
less clearness than I might have done, and I had not uttered many
sentences before I was cut short as if my plan was preposterous. I
returned to Cairo very much crestfallen.
Flag-officer Foote commanded the little fleet of gunboats then in
the neighborhood of Cairo and, though in another branch of the
service, was subject to the command of General Halleck. He and I
consulted freely upon military matters and he agreed with me perfectly
as to the feasibility of the campaign up the Tennessee.
Notwithstanding the rebuff I had received from my immediate chief, I
therefore, on the 28th of January, renewed the suggestion by telegraph
that "if permitted, I could take and hold Fort Henry on the
Tennessee." This time I was backed by Flag-officer Foote, who sent a
similar dispatch. On the 29th I wrote fully in support of the
proposition. On the 1st of February I received full instructions from
department headquarters to move upon Fort Henry. On the 2d the
expedition started.
In February, 1862, there were quite a good many steamers laid up
at Cairo for want of employment, the Mississippi River being closed
against navigation below that point. There were also many men in the
town whose occupation had been following the river in various
capacities, from captain down to deck hand But there were not enough
of either boats or men to move at one time the 17,000 men I proposed
to take with me up the Tennessee. I loaded the boats with more than
half the force, however, and sent General McClernand in command. I
followed with one of the later boats and found McClernand had stopped,
very properly, nine miles below Fort Henry. Seven gunboats under
Flag-officer Foote had accompanied the advance. The transports we had
with us had to return to Paducah to bring up a division from there,
with General C. F. Smith in command.
Before sending the boats back I wanted to get the troops as near
to the enemy as I could without coming within range of their guns.
There was a stream emptying into the Tennessee on the east side,
apparently at about long range distance below the fort. On account of
the narrow water-shed separating the Tennessee and Cumberland rivers
at that point, the stream must be insignificant at ordinary stages,
but when we were there, in February, it was a torrent. It would
facilitate the investment of Fort Henry materially if the troops could
be landed south of that stream. To test whether this could be done I
boarded the gunboat Essex and requested Captain Wm. Porter commanding
it, to approach the fort to draw its fire. After we had gone some
distance past the mouth of the stream we drew the fire of the fort,
which fell much short of us. In consequence I had made up my mind to
return and bring the troops to the upper side of the creek, when the
enemy opened upon us with a rifled gun that sent shot far beyond us
and beyond the stream. One shot passed very near where Captain Porter
and I were standing, struck the deck near the stern, penetrated and
passed through the cabin and so out into the river. We immediately
turned back, and the troops were debarked below the mouth of the
creek.
When the landing was completed I returned with the transports to
Paducah to hasten up the balance of the troops. I got back on the
5th with the advance the remainder following as rapidly as the
steamers could carry them. At ten o'clock at night, on the 5th, the
whole command was not yet up. Being anxious to commence operations as
soon as possible before the enemy could reinforce heavily, I issued my
orders for an advance at 11 A.M. on the 6th. I felt sure that all the
troops would be up by that time.
Fort Henry occupies a bend in the river which gave the guns in the
water battery a direct fire down the stream. The camp outside the
fort was intrenched, with rifle pits and outworks two miles back on
the road to Donelson and Dover. The garrison of the fort and camp was
about 2,800, with strong reinforcements from Donelson halted some
miles out. There were seventeen heavy guns in the fort. The river
was very high, the banks being overflowed except where the bluffs come
to the water's edge. A portion of the ground on which Fort Henry
stood was two feet deep in water. Below, the water extended into the
woods several hundred yards back from the bank on the east side. On
the west bank Fort Heiman stood on high ground, completely commanding
Fort Henry. The distance from Fort Henry to Donelson is but eleven
miles. The two positions were so important to the enemy, AS HE SAW
HIS INTEREST, that it was natural to suppose that reinforcements would
come from every quarter from which they could be got. Prompt action
on our part was imperative.
The plan was for the troops and gunboats to start at the same
moment. The troops were to invest the garrison and the gunboats to
attack the fort at close quarters. General Smith was to land a
brigade of his division on the west bank during the night of the 5th
and get it in rear of Heiman.
At the hour designated the troops and gunboats started. General
Smith found Fort Heiman had been evacuated before his men arrived.
The gunboats soon engaged the water batteries at very close quarters,
but the troops which were to invest Fort Henry were delayed for want
of roads, as well as by the dense forest and the high water in what
would in dry weather have been unimportant beds of streams. This
delay made no difference in the result. On our first appearance
Tilghman had sent his entire command, with the exception of about one
hundred men left to man the guns in the fort, to the outworks on the
road to Dover and Donelson, so as to have them out of range of the
guns of our navy; and before any attack on the 6th he had ordered them
to retreat on Donelson. He stated in his subsequent report that the
defence was intended solely to give his troops time to make their
escape.
Tilghman was captured with his staff and ninety men, as well as
the armament of the fort, the ammunition and whatever stores were
there. Our cavalry pursued the retreating column towards Donelson and
picked up two guns and a few stragglers; but the enemy had so much the
start, that the pursuing force did not get in sight of any except the
stragglers.
All the gunboats engaged were hit many times. The damage,
however, beyond what could be repaired by a small expenditure of
money, was slight, except to the Essex. A shell penetrated the
boiler of that vessel and exploded it, killing and wounding
forty-eight men, nineteen of whom were soldiers who had been detailed
to act with the navy. On several occasions during the war such
details were made when the complement of men with the navy was
insufficient for the duty before them. After the fall of Fort Henry
Captain Phelps, commanding the iron-clad Carondelet, at my request
ascended the Tennessee River and thoroughly destroyed the bridge of
the Memphis and Ohio Railroad.
I informed the department commander of our success at Fort Henry
and that on the 8th I would take Fort Donelson. But the rain
continued to fall so heavily that the roads became impassable for
artillery and wagon trains. Then, too, it would not have been prudent
to proceed without the gunboats. At least it would have been leaving
behind a valuable part of our available force.
On the 7th, the day after the fall of Fort Henry, I took my staff
and the cavalry--a part of one regiment--and made a reconnoissance to
within about a mile of the outer line of works at Donelson. I had
known General Pillow in Mexico, and judged that with any force, no
matter how small, I could march up to within gunshot of any
intrenchments he was given to hold. I said this to the officers of my
staff at the time. I knew that Floyd was in command, but he was no
soldier, and I judged that he would yield to Pillow's pretensions. I
met, as I expected, no opposition in making the reconnoissance and,
besides learning the topography of the country on the way and around
Fort Donelson, found that there were two roads available for
marching; one leading to the village of Dover, the other to Donelson.
Fort Donelson is two miles north, or down the river, from Dover.
The fort, as it stood in 1861, embraced about one hundred acres of
land. On the east it fronted the Cumberland; to the north it faced
Hickman's creek, a small stream which at that time was deep and wide
because of the back-water from the river; on the south was another
small stream, or rather a ravine, opening into the Cumberland. This
also was filled with back-water from the river. The fort stood on
high ground, some of it as much as a hundred feet above the
Cumberland. Strong protection to the heavy guns in the water
batteries had been obtained by cutting away places for them in the
bluff. To the west there was a line of rifle pits some two miles back
from the river at the farthest point. This line ran generally along
the crest of high ground, but in one place crossed a ravine which
opens into the river between the village and the fort. The ground
inside and outside of this intrenched line was very broken and
generally wooded. The trees outside of the rifle-pits had been cut
down for a considerable way out, and had been felled so that their
tops lay outwards from the intrenchments. The limbs had been trimmed
and pointed, and thus formed an abatis in front of the greater part of
the line. Outside of this intrenched line, and extending about half
the entire length of it, is a ravine running north and south and
opening into Hickman creek at a point north of the fort. The entire
side of this ravine next to the works was one long abatis.
General Halleck commenced his efforts in all quarters to get
reinforcements to forward to me immediately on my departure from
Cairo. General Hunter sent men freely from Kansas, and a large
division under General Nelson, from Buell's army, was also
dispatched. Orders went out from the War Department to consolidate
fragments of companies that were being recruited in the Western States
so as to make full companies, and to consolidate companies into
regiments. General Halleck did not approve or disapprove of my going
to Fort Donelson. He said nothing whatever to me on the subject. He
informed Buell on the 7th that I would march against Fort Donelson the
next day; but on the 10th he directed me to fortify Fort Henry
strongly, particularly to the land side, saying that he forwarded me
intrenching tools for that purpose. I received this dispatch in
front of Fort Donelson.
I was very impatient to get to Fort Donelson because I knew the
importance of the place to the enemy and supposed he would reinforce
it rapidly. I felt that 15,000 men on the 8th would be more effective
than 50,000 a month later. I asked Flag-officer Foote, therefore, to
order his gunboats still about Cairo to proceed up the Cumberland
River and not to wait for those gone to Eastport and Florence; but
the others got back in time and we started on the 12th. I had moved
McClernand out a few miles the night before so as to leave the road as
free as possible.
Just as we were about to start the first reinforcement reached me
on transports. It was a brigade composed of six full regiments
commanded by Colonel Thayer, of Nebraska. As the gunboats were going
around to Donelson by the Tennessee, Ohio and Cumberland rivers, I
directed Thayer to turn about and go under their convoy.
I started from Fort Henry with 15,000 men, including eight
batteries and part of a regiment of cavalry, and, meeting with no
obstruction to detain us, the advance arrived in front of the enemy by
noon. That afternoon and the next day were spent in taking up ground
to make the investment as complete as possible. General Smith had
been directed to leave a portion of his division behind to guard forts
Henry and Heiman. He left General Lew. Wallace with 2,500 men. With
the remainder of his division he occupied our left, extending to
Hickman creek. McClernand was on the right and covered the roads
running south and south-west from Dover. His right extended to the
back-water up the ravine opening into the Cumberland south of the
village. The troops were not intrenched, but the nature of the ground
was such that they were just as well protected from the fire of the
enemy as if rifle-pits had been thrown up. Our line was generally
along the crest of ridges. The artillery was protected by being sunk
in the ground. The men who were not serving the guns were perfectly
covered from fire on taking position a little back from the crest.
The greatest suffering was from want of shelter. It was midwinter
and during the siege we had rain and snow, thawing and freezing
alternately. It would not do to allow camp-fires except far down the
hill out of sight of the enemy, and it would not do to allow many of
the troops to remain there at the same time. In the march over from
Fort Henry numbers of the men had thrown away their blankets and
overcoats. There was therefore much discomfort and absolute
suffering.
During the 12th and 13th, and until the arrival of Wallace and
Thayer on the 14th, the National forces, composed of but 15,000 men,
without intrenchments, confronted an intrenched army of 21,000,
without conflict further than what was brought on by ourselves. Only
one gunboat had arrived. There was a little skirmishing each day,
brought on by the movement of our troops in securing commanding
positions; but there was no actual fighting during this time except
once, on the 13th, in front of McClernand's command. That general had
undertaken to capture a battery of the enemy which was annoying his
men. Without orders or authority he sent three regiments to make the
assault. The battery was in the main line of the enemy, which was
defended by his whole army present. Of course the assault was a
failure, and of course the loss on our side was great for the number
of men engaged. In this assault Colonel William Morrison fell badly
wounded. Up to this time the surgeons with the army had no
difficulty in finding room in the houses near our line for all the
sick and wounded; but now hospitals were overcrowded. Owing, however,
to the energy and skill of the surgeons the suffering was not so great
as it might have been. The hospital arrangements at Fort Donelson
were as complete as it was possible to make them, considering the
inclemency of the weather and the lack of tents, in a sparsely settled
country where the houses were generally of but one or two rooms.
On the return of Captain Walke to Fort Henry on the 10th, I had
requested him to take the vessels that had accompanied him on his
expedition up the Tennessee, and get possession of the Cumberland as
far up towards Donelson as possible. He started without delay,
taking, however, only his own gunboat, the Carondelet, towed by the
steamer Alps. Captain Walke arrived a few miles below Donelson on the
12th, a little after noon. About the time the advance of troops
reached a point within gunshot of the fort on the land side, he
engaged the water batteries at long range. On the 13th I informed him
of my arrival the day before and of the establishment of most of our
batteries, requesting him at the same time to attack again that day so
that I might take advantage of any diversion. The attack was made and
many shots fell within the fort, creating some consternation, as we
now know. The investment on the land side was made as complete as the
number of troops engaged would admit of.
During the night of the 13th Flag-officer Foote arrived with the
iron-clads St. Louis, Louisville and Pittsburg and the wooden
gunboats Tyler and Conestoga, convoying Thayer's brigade. On the
morning of the 14th Thayer was landed. Wallace, whom I had ordered
over from Fort Henry, also arrived about the same time. Up to this
time he had been commanding a brigade belonging to the division of
General C. F. Smith. These troops were now restored to the division
they belonged to, and General Lew. Wallace was assigned to the command
of a division composed of the brigade of Colonel Thayer and other
reinforcements that arrived the same day. This new division was
assigned to the centre, giving the two flanking divisions an
opportunity to close up and form a stronger line.
The plan was for the troops to hold the enemy within his lines,
while the gunboats should attack the water batteries at close
quarters and silence his guns if possible. Some of the gunboats were
to run the batteries, get above the fort and above the village of
Dover. I had ordered a reconnoissance made with the view of getting
troops to the river above Dover in case they should be needed there.
That position attained by the gunboats it would have been but a
question of time--and a very short time, too--when the garrison would
have been compelled to surrender.
By three in the afternoon of the 14th Flag-officer Foote was
ready, and advanced upon the water batteries with his entire fleet.
After coming in range of the batteries of the enemy the advance was
slow, but a constant fire was delivered from every gun that could be
brought to bear upon the fort. I occupied a position on shore from
which I could see the advancing navy. The leading boat got within a
very short distance of the water battery, not further off I think than
two hundred yards, and I soon saw one and then another of them
dropping down the river, visibly disabled. Then the whole fleet
followed and the engagement closed for the day. The gunboat which
Flag-officer Foote was on, besides having been hit about sixty times,
several of the shots passing through near the waterline, had a shot
enter the pilot-house which killed the pilot, carried away the wheel
and wounded the flag-officer himself. The tiller-ropes of another
vessel were carried away and she, too, dropped helplessly back. Two
others had their pilot-houses so injured that they scarcely formed a
protection to the men at the wheel.
The enemy had evidently been much demoralized by the assault, but
they were jubilant when they saw the disabled vessels dropping down
the river entirely out of the control of the men on board. Of course
I only witnessed the falling back of our gunboats and felt sad enough
at the time over the repulse. Subsequent reports, now published, show
that the enemy telegraphed a great victory to Richmond. The sun went
down on the night of the 14th of February, 1862, leaving the army
confronting Fort Donelson anything but comforted over the prospects.
The weather had turned intensely cold; the men were without tents and
could not keep up fires where most of them had to stay, and, as
previously stated, many had thrown away their overcoats and blankets.
Two of the strongest of our gunboats had been disabled, presumably
beyond the possibility of rendering any present assistance. I retired
this night not knowing but that I would have to intrench my position,
and bring up tents for the men or build huts under the cover of the
hills.
On the morning of the 15th, before it was yet broad day, a
messenger from Flag-officer Foote handed me a note, expressing a
desire to see me on the flag-ship and saying that he had been injured
the day before so much that he could not come himself to me. I at
once made my preparations for starting. I directed my
adjutant-general to notify each of the division commanders of my
absence and instruct them to do nothing to bring on an engagement
until they received further orders, but to hold their positions.
From the heavy rains that had fallen for days and weeks preceding and
from the constant use of the roads between the troops and the landing
four to seven miles below, these roads had become cut up so as to be
hardly passable. The intense cold of the night of the 14th-15th had
frozen the ground solid. This made travel on horseback even slower
than through the mud; but I went as fast as the roads would allow.
When I reached the fleet I found the flag-ship was anchored out in
the stream. A small boat, however, awaited my arrival and I was soon
on board with the flag-officer. He explained to me in short the
condition in which he was left by the engagement of the evening
before, and suggested that I should intrench while he returned to
Mound City with his disabled boats, expressing at the time the belief
that he could have the necessary repairs made and be back in ten days.
I saw the absolute necessity of his gunboats going into hospital and
did not know but I should be forced to the alternative of going
through a siege. But the enemy relieved me from this necessity.
When I left the National line to visit Flag-officer Foote I had no
idea that there would be any engagement on land unless I brought it on
myself. The conditions for battle were much more favorable to us than
they had been for the first two days of the investment. From the 12th
to the 14th we had but 15,000 men of all arms and no gunboats. Now we
had been reinforced by a fleet of six naval vessels, a large division
of troops under General L. Wallace and 2,500 men brought over from
Fort Henry belonging to the division of C. F. Smith. The enemy,
however, had taken the initiative. Just as I landed I met Captain
Hillyer of my staff, white with fear, not for his personal safety, but
for the safety of the National troops. He said the enemy had come out
of his lines in full force and attacked and scattered McClernand's
division, which was in full retreat. The roads, as I have said, were
unfit for making fast time, but I got to my command as soon as
possible. The attack had been made on the National right. I was some
four or five miles north of our left. The line was about three miles
long. In reaching the point where the disaster had occurred I had to
pass the divisions of Smith and Wallace. I saw no sign of excitement
on the portion of the line held by Smith; Wallace was nearer the scene
of conflict and had taken part in it. He had, at an opportune time,
sent Thayer's brigade to the support of McClernand and thereby
contributed to hold the enemy within his lines.
I saw everything favorable for us along the line of our left and
centre. When I came to the right appearances were different. The
enemy had come out in full force to cut his way out and make his
escape. McClernand's division had to bear the brunt of the attack
from this combined force. His men had stood up gallantly until the
ammunition in their cartridge-boxes gave out. There was abundance of
ammunition near by lying on the ground in boxes, but at that stage of
the war it was not all of our commanders of regiments, brigades, or
even divisions, who had been educated up to the point of seeing that
their men were constantly supplied with ammunition during an
engagement. When the men found themselves without ammunition they
could not stand up against troops who seemed to have plenty of it.
The division broke and a portion fled, but most of the men, as they
were not pursued, only fell back out of range of the fire of the
enemy. It must have been about this time that Thayer pushed his
brigade in between the enemy and those of our troops that were without
ammunition. At all events the enemy fell back within his
intrenchments and was there when I got on the field.
I saw the men standing in knots talking in the most excited
manner. No officer seemed to be giving any directions. The soldiers
had their muskets, but no ammunition, while there were tons of it
close at hand. I heard some of the men say that the enemy had come
out with knapsacks, and haversacks filled with rations. They seemed
to think this indicated a determination on his part to stay out and
fight just as long as the provisions held out. I turned to Colonel J.
D. Webster, of my staff, who was with me, and said: "Some of our men
are pretty badly demoralized, but the enemy must be more so, for he
has attempted to force his way out, but has fallen back: the one who
attacks first now will be victorious and the enemy will have to be in
a hurry if he gets ahead of me." I determined to make the assault at
once on our left. It was clear to my mind that the enemy had started
to march out with his entire force, except a few pickets, and if our
attack could be made on the left before the enemy could redistribute
his forces along the line, we would find but little opposition except
from the intervening abatis. I directed Colonel Webster to ride with
me and call out to the men as we passed: "Fill your cartridge-boxes,
quick, and get into line; the enemy is trying to escape and he must
not be permitted to do so." This acted like a charm. The men only
wanted some one to give them a command. We rode rapidly to Smith's
quarters, when I explained the situation to him and directed him to
charge the enemy's works in his front with his whole division, saying
at the same time that he would find nothing but a very thin line to
contend with. The general was off in an incredibly short time, going
in advance himself to keep his men from firing while they were working
their way through the abatis intervening between them and the enemy.
The outer line of rifle-pits was passed, and the night of the 15th
General Smith, with much of his division, bivouacked within the lines
of the enemy. There was now no doubt but that the Confederates must
surrender or be captured the next day.
There seems from subsequent accounts to have been much
consternation, particularly among the officers of high rank, in Dover
during the night of the 15th. General Floyd, the commanding officer,
who was a man of talent enough for any civil position, was no soldier
and, possibly, did not possess the elements of one. He was further
unfitted for command, for the reason that his conscience must have
troubled him and made him afraid. As Secretary of War he had taken a
solemn oath to maintain the Constitution of the United States and to
uphold the same against all its enemies. He had betrayed that trust.
As Secretary of War he was reported through the northern press to
have scattered the little army the country had so that the most of it
could be picked up in detail when secession occurred. About a year
before leaving the Cabinet he had removed arms from northern to
southern arsenals. He continued in the Cabinet of President Buchanan
until about the 1st of January, 1861, while he was working vigilantly
for the establishment of a confederacy made out of United States
territory. Well may he have been afraid to fall into the hands of
National troops. He would no doubt have been tried for
misappropriating public property, if not for treason, had he been
captured. General Pillow, next in command, was conceited, and prided
himself much on his services in the Mexican war. He telegraphed to
General Johnston, at Nashville, after our men were within the rebel
rifle-pits, and almost on the eve of his making his escape, that the
Southern troops had had great success all day. Johnston forwarded the
dispatch to Richmond. While the authorities at the capital were
reading it Floyd and Pillow were fugitives.
A council of war was held by the enemy at which all agreed that it
would be impossible to hold out longer. General Buckner, who was
third in rank in the garrison but much the most capable soldier, seems
to have regarded it a duty to hold the fort until the general
commanding the department, A. S. Johnston, should get back to his
headquarters at Nashville. Buckner's report shows, however, that he
considered Donelson lost and that any attempt to hold the place longer
would be at the sacrifice of the command. Being assured that Johnston
was already in Nashville, Buckner too agreed that surrender was the
proper thing. Floyd turned over the command to Pillow, who declined
it. It then devolved upon Buckner, who accepted the responsibility of
the position. Floyd and Pillow took possession of all the river
transports at Dover and before morning both were on their way to
Nashville, with the brigade formerly commanded by Floyd and some
other troops, in all about 3,000. Some marched up the east bank of
the Cumberland; others went on the steamers. During the night Forrest
also, with his cavalry and some other troops about a thousand in all,
made their way out, passing between our right and the river. They had
to ford or swim over the back-water in the little creek just south of
Dover.
Before daylight General Smith brought to me the following letter
from General Buckner:
HEADQUARTERS, FORT DONELSON, February 16, 1862.
SIR:--In consideration of all the circumstances governing the
present situation of affairs at this station, I propose to the
Commanding Officer of the Federal forces the appointment of
Commissioners to agree upon terms of capitulation of the forces and
fort under my command, and in that view suggest an armistice until 12
o'clock to-day.
I am, sir, very respectfully, Your ob't se'v't, S. B. BUCKNER,
Brig. Gen. C. S. A.
To Brigadier-General U. S. Grant, Com'ding U. S. Forces, Near
Fort Donelson.
To this I responded as follows:
HEADQUARTERS ARMY IN THE FIELD, Camp near Donelson, February 16,
1862.
General S. B. BUCKNER, Confederate Army.
SIR:--Yours of this date, proposing armistice and appointment of
Commissioners to settle terms of capitulation, is just received. No
terms except an unconditional and immediate surrender can be accepted.
I propose to move immediately upon your works.
I am, sir, very respectfully, Your ob't se'v't, U. S. GRANT,
Brig. Gen.
To this I received the following reply:
HEADQUARTERS, DOVER, TENNESSEE, February 16, 1862.
To Brig. Gen'I U. S. GRANT, U. S. Army.
SIR:--The distribution of the forces under my command, incident to
an unexpected change of commanders, and the overwhelming force under
your command, compel me, notwithstanding the brilliant success of the
Confederate arms yesterday, to accept the ungenerous and unchivalrous
terms which you propose.
I am, sir, Your very ob't se'v't, S. B. BUCKNER, Brig. Gen. C.
S. A.
General Buckner, as soon as he had dispatched the first of the
above letters, sent word to his different commanders on the line of
rifle-pits, notifying them that he had made a proposition looking to
the surrender of the garrison, and directing them to notify National
troops in their front so that all fighting might be prevented. White
flags were stuck at intervals along the line of rifle-pits, but none
over the fort. As soon as the last letter from Buckner was received I
mounted my horse and rode to Dover. General Wallace, I found, had
preceded me an hour or more. I presume that, seeing white flags
exposed in his front, he rode up to see what they meant and, not being
fired upon or halted, he kept on until he found himself at the
headquarters of General Buckner.
I had been at West Point three years with Buckner and afterwards
served with him in the army, so that we were quite well acquainted.
In the course of our conversation, which was very friendly, he said
to me that if he had been in command I would not have got up to
Donelson as easily as I did. I told him that if he had been in
command I should not have tried in the way I did: I had invested
their lines with a smaller force than they had to defend them, and at
the same time had sent a brigade full 5,000 strong, around by water; I
had relied very much upon their commander to allow me to come safely
up to the outside of their works. I asked General Buckner about what
force he had to surrender. He replied that he could not tell with any
degree of accuracy; that all the sick and weak had been sent to
Nashville while we were about Fort Henry; that Floyd and Pillow had
left during the night, taking many men with them; and that Forrest,
and probably others, had also escaped during the preceding night:
the number of casualties he could not tell; but he said I would not
find fewer than 12,000, nor more than 15,000.
He asked permission to send parties outside of the lines to bury
his dead, who had fallen on the 15th when they tried to get out. I
gave directions that his permit to pass our limits should be
recognized. I have no reason to believe that this privilege was
abused, but it familiarized our guards so much with the sight of
Confederates passing to and fro that I have no doubt many got beyond
our pickets unobserved and went on. The most of the men who went in
that way no doubt thought they had had war enough, and left with the
intention of remaining out of the army. Some came to me and asked
permission to go, saying that they were tired of the war and would not
be caught in the ranks again, and I bade them go.
The actual number of Confederates at Fort Donelson can never be
given with entire accuracy. The largest number admitted by any
writer on the Southern side, is by Colonel Preston Johnston. He
gives the number at 17,000. But this must be an underestimate. The
commissary general of prisoners reported having issued rations to
14,623 Fort Donelson prisoners at Cairo, as they passed that point.
General Pillow reported the killed and wounded at 2,000; but he had
less opportunity of knowing the actual numbers than the officers of
McClernand's division, for most of the killed and wounded fell outside
their works, in front of that division, and were buried or cared for
by Buckner after the surrender and when Pillow was a fugitive. It is
known that Floyd and Pillow escaped during the night of the 15th,
taking with them not less than 3,000 men. Forrest escaped with about
1,000 and others were leaving singly and in squads all night. It is
probable that the Confederate force at Donelson, on the 15th of
February, 1862, was 21,000 in round numbers.
On the day Fort Donelson fell I had 27,000 men to confront the
Confederate lines and guard the road four or five miles to the left,
over which all our supplies had to be drawn on wagons. During the
16th, after the surrender, additional reinforcements arrived.
During the siege General Sherman had been sent to Smithland, at
the mouth of the Cumberland River, to forward reinforcements and
supplies to me. At that time he was my senior in rank and there was
no authority of law to assign a junior to command a senior of the same
grade. But every boat that came up with supplies or reinforcements
brought a note of encouragement from Sherman, asking me to call upon
him for any assistance he could render and saying that if he could be
of service at the front I might send for him and he would waive rank.
The news of the fall of Fort Donelson caused great delight all
over the North. At the South, particularly in Richmond, the effect
was correspondingly depressing. I was promptly promoted to the grade
of Major-General of Volunteers, and confirmed by the Senate. All
three of my division commanders were promoted to the same grade and
the colonels who commanded brigades were made brigadier-generals in
the volunteer service. My chief, who was in St. Louis, telegraphed
his congratulations to General Hunter in Kansas for the services he
had rendered in securing the fall of Fort Donelson by sending
reinforcements so rapidly. To Washington he telegraphed that the
victory was due to General C. F. Smith; "promote him," he said, "and
the whole country will applaud." On the 19th there was published at
St. Louis a formal order thanking Flag-officer Foote and myself, and
the forces under our command, for the victories on the Tennessee and
the Cumberland. I received no other recognition whatever from General
Halleck. But General Cullum, his chief of staff, who was at Cairo,
wrote me a warm congratulatory letter on his own behalf. I approved
of General Smith's promotion highly, as I did all the promotions that
were made.
My opinion was and still is that immediately after the fall of
Fort Donelson the way was opened to the National forces all over the
South-west without much resistance. If one general who would have
taken the responsibility had been in command of all the troops west of
the Alleghanies, he could have marched to Chattanooga, Corinth,
Memphis and Vicksburg with the troops we then had, and as volunteering
was going on rapidly over the North there would soon have been force
enough at all these centres to operate offensively against any body of
the enemy that might be found near them. Rapid movements and the
acquisition of rebellious territory would have promoted volunteering,
so that reinforcements could have been had as fast as transportation
could have been obtained to carry them to their destination. On the
other hand there were tens of thousands of strong able-bodied young
men still at their homes in the South-western States, who had not gone
into the Confederate army in February, 1862, and who had no particular
desire to go. If our lines had been extended to protect their homes,
many of them never would have gone. Providence ruled differently.
Time was given the enemy to collect armies and fortify his new
positions; and twice afterwards he came near forcing his north-western
front up to the Ohio River.
I promptly informed the department commander of our success at
Fort Donelson and that the way was open now to Clarksville and
Nashville; and that unless I received orders to the contrary I should
take Clarksville on the 21st and Nashville about the 1st of March.
Both these places are on the Cumberland River above Fort Donelson.
As I heard nothing from headquarters on the subject, General C. F.
Smith was sent to Clarksville at the time designated and found the
place evacuated. The capture of forts Henry and Donelson had broken
the line the enemy had taken from Columbus to Bowling Green, and it
was known that he was falling back from the eastern point of this line
and that Buell was following, or at least advancing. I should have
sent troops to Nashville at the time I sent to Clarksville, but my
transportation was limited and there were many prisoners to be
forwarded north.
None of the reinforcements from Buell's army arrived until the
24th of February. Then General Nelson came up, with orders to report
to me with two brigades, he having sent one brigade to Cairo. I knew
General Buell was advancing on Nashville from the north, and I was
advised by scouts that the rebels were leaving that place, and trying
to get out all the supplies they could. Nashville was, at that time,
one of the best provisioned posts in the South. I had no use for
reinforcements now, and thinking Buell would like to have his troops
again, I ordered Nelson to proceed to Nashville without debarking at
Fort Donelson. I sent a gunboat also as a convoy. The Cumberland
River was very high at the time; the railroad bridge at Nashville had
been burned, and all river craft had been destroyed, or would be
before the enemy left. Nashville is on the west bank of the
Cumberland, and Buell was approaching from the east. I thought the
steamers carrying Nelson's division would be useful in ferrying the
balance of Buell's forces across. I ordered Nelson to put himself in
communication with Buell as soon as possible, and if he found him more
than two days off from Nashville to return below the city and await
orders. Buell, however, had already arrived in person at Edgefield,
opposite Nashville, and Mitchell's division of his command reached
there the same day. Nelson immediately took possession of the city.
After Nelson had gone and before I had learned of Buell's arrival,
I sent word to department headquarters that I should go to Nashville
myself on the 28th if I received no orders to the contrary. Hearing
nothing, I went as I had informed my superior officer I would do. On
arriving at Clarksville I saw a fleet of steamers at the shore--the
same that had taken Nelson's division--and troops going aboard. I
landed and called on the commanding officer, General C. F. Smith. As
soon as he saw me he showed an order he had just received from Buell
in these words:
NASHVILLE, February 25, 1862.
GENERAL C. F. SMITH, Commanding U. S. Forces, Clarksville.
GENERAL:--The landing of a portion of our troops, contrary to my
intentions, on the south side of the river has compelled me to hold
this side at every hazard. If the enemy should assume the offensive,
and I am assured by reliable persons that in view of my position such
is his intention, my force present is altogether inadequate,
consisting of only 15,000 men. I have to request you, therefore, to
come forward with all the available force under your command. So
important do I consider the occasion that I think it necessary to give
this communication all the force of orders, and I send four boats, the
Diana, Woodford, John Rain, and Autocrat, to bring you up. In five or
six days my force will probably be sufficient to relieve you.
Very respectfully, your ob't srv't, D. C. BUELL,
Brigadier-General Comd'g.
P. S.--The steamers will leave here at 12 o'clock to-night.
General Smith said this order was nonsense. But I told him it was
better to obey it. The General replied, "of course I must obey," and
said his men were embarking as fast as they could. I went on up to
Nashville and inspected the position taken by Nelson's troops. I did
not see Buell during the day, and wrote him a note saying that I had
been in Nashville since early morning and had hoped to meet him. On
my return to the boat we met. His troops were still east of the
river, and the steamers that had carried Nelson's division up were
mostly at Clarksville to bring Smith's division. I said to General
Buell my information was that the enemy was retreating as fast as
possible. General Buell said there was fighting going on then only
ten or twelve miles away. I said: "Quite probably; Nashville
contained valuable stores of arms, ammunition and provisions, and the
enemy is probably trying to carry away all he can. The fighting is
doubtless with the rear-guard who are trying to protect the trains
they are getting away with." Buell spoke very positively of the
danger Nashville was in of an attack from the enemy. I said, in the
absence of positive information, I believed my information was
correct. He responded that he "knew." "Well," I said, "I do not
know; but as I came by Clarksville General Smith's troops were
embarking to join you."
Smith's troops were returned the same day. The enemy were trying
to get away from Nashville and not to return to it.
At this time General Albert Sidney Johnston commanded all the
Confederate troops west of the Alleghany Mountains, with the
exception of those in the extreme south. On the National side the
forces confronting him were divided into, at first three, then four
separate departments. Johnston had greatly the advantage in having
supreme command over all troops that could possibly be brought to bear
upon one point, while the forces similarly situated on the National
side, divided into independent commands, could not be brought into
harmonious action except by orders from Washington.
At the beginning of 1862 Johnston's troops east of the Mississippi
occupied a line extending from Columbus, on his left, to Mill Springs,
on his right. As we have seen, Columbus, both banks of the Tennessee
River, the west bank of the Cumberland and Bowling Green, all were
strongly fortified. Mill Springs was intrenched. The National troops
occupied no territory south of the Ohio, except three small garrisons
along its bank and a force thrown out from Louisville to confront that
at Bowling Green. Johnston's strength was no doubt numerically
inferior to that of the National troops; but this was compensated for
by the advantage of being sole commander of all the Confederate forces
at the West, and of operating in a country where his friends would
take care of his rear without any detail of soldiers. But when
General George H. Thomas moved upon the enemy at Mill Springs and
totally routed him, inflicting a loss of some 300 killed and wounded,
and forts Henry and Heiman fell into the hands of the National forces,
with their armaments and about 100 prisoners, those losses seemed to
dishearten the Confederate commander so much that he immediately
commenced a retreat from Bowling Green on Nashville. He reached this
latter place on the 14th of February, while Donelson was still
besieged. Buell followed with a portion of the Army of the Ohio, but
he had to march and did not reach the east bank of the Cumberland
opposite Nashville until the 24th of the month, and then with only one
division of his army.
The bridge at Nashville had been destroyed and all boats removed
or disabled, so that a small garrison could have held the place
against any National troops that could have been brought against it
within ten days after the arrival of the force from Bowling Green.
Johnston seemed to lie quietly at Nashville to await the result at
Fort Donelson, on which he had staked the possession of most of the
territory embraced in the States of Kentucky and Tennessee. It is
true, the two generals senior in rank at Fort Donelson were sending
him encouraging dispatches, even claiming great Confederate victories
up to the night of the 16th when they must have been preparing for
their individual escape. Johnston made a fatal mistake in intrusting
so important a command to Floyd, who he must have known was no soldier
even if he possessed the elements of one. Pillow's presence as second
was also a mistake. If these officers had been forced upon him and
designated for that particular command, then he should have left
Nashville with a small garrison under a trusty officer, and with the
remainder of his force gone to Donelson himself. If he had been
captured the result could not have been worse than it was.
Johnston's heart failed him upon the first advance of National
troops. He wrote to Richmond on the 8th of February, "I think the
gunboats of the enemy will probably take Fort Donelson without the
necessity of employing their land force in cooperation." After the
fall of that place he abandoned Nashville and Chattanooga without an
effort to save either, and fell back into northern Mississippi, where,
six weeks later, he was destined to end his career.
From the time of leaving Cairo I was singularly unfortunate in not
receiving dispatches from General Halleck. The order of the 10th of
February directing me to fortify Fort Henry strongly, particularly to
the land side, and saying that intrenching tools had been sent for
that purpose, reached me after Donelson was invested. I received
nothing direct which indicated that the department commander knew we
were in possession of Donelson. I was reporting regularly to the
chief of staff, who had been sent to Cairo, soon after the troops left
there, to receive all reports from the front and to telegraph the
substance to the St. Louis headquarters. Cairo was at the southern
end of the telegraph wire. Another line was started at once from
Cairo to Paducah and Smithland, at the mouths of the Tennessee and
Cumberland respectively. My dispatches were all sent to Cairo by
boat, but many of those addressed to me were sent to the operator at
the end of the advancing wire and he failed to forward them. This
operator afterwards proved to be a rebel; he deserted his post after a
short time and went south taking his dispatches with him. A telegram
from General McClellan to me of February 16th, the day of the
surrender, directing me to report in full the situation, was not
received at my headquarters until the 3d of March.
On the 2d of March I received orders dated March 1st to move my
command back to Fort Henry, leaving only a small garrison at
Donelson. From Fort Henry expeditions were to be sent against
Eastport, Mississippi, and Paris, Tennessee. We started from
Donelson on the 4th, and the same day I was back on the Tennessee
River. On March 4th I also received the following dispatch from
General Halleck:
MAJ.-GEN. U. S. GRANT, Fort Henry:
You will place Maj.-Gen. C. F. Smith in command of expedition, and
remain yourself at Fort Henry. Why do you not obey my orders to
report strength and positions of your command?
H. W. HALLECK, Major-General.
I was surprised. This was the first intimation I had received
that General Halleck had called for information as to the strength of
my command. On the 6th he wrote to me again. "Your going to
Nashville without authority, and when your presence with your troops
was of the utmost importance, was a matter of very serious complaint
at Washington, so much so that I was advised to arrest you on your
return." This was the first I knew of his objecting to my going to
Nashville. That place was not beyond the limits of my command, which,
it had been expressly declared in orders, were "not defined."
Nashville is west of the Cumberland River, and I had sent troops that
had reported to me for duty to occupy the place. I turned over the
command as directed and then replied to General Halleck courteously,
but asked to be relieved from further duty under him.
Later I learned that General Halleck had been calling lustily for
more troops, promising that he would do something important if he
could only be sufficiently reinforced. McClellan asked him what force
he then had. Halleck telegraphed me to supply the information so far
as my command was concerned, but I received none of his dispatches.
At last Halleck reported to Washington that he had repeatedly ordered
me to give the strength of my force, but could get nothing out of me;
that I had gone to Nashville, beyond the limits of my command, without
his authority, and that my army was more demoralized by victory than
the army at Bull Run had been by defeat. General McClellan, on this
information, ordered that I should be relieved from duty and that an
investigation should be made into any charges against me. He even
authorized my arrest. Thus in less than two weeks after the victory
at Donelson, the two leading generals in the army were in
correspondence as to what disposition should be made of me, and in
less than three weeks I was virtually in arrest and without a command.
On the 13th of March I was restored to command, and on the 17th
Halleck sent me a copy of an order from the War Department which
stated that accounts of my misbehavior had reached Washington and
directed him to investigate and report the facts. He forwarded also
a copy of a detailed dispatch from himself to Washington entirely
exonerating me; but he did not inform me that it was his own reports
that had created all the trouble. On the contrary, he wrote to me,
"Instead of relieving you, I wish you, as soon as your new army is in
the field, to assume immediate command, and lead it to new victories."
In consequence I felt very grateful to him, and supposed it was his
interposition that had set me right with the government. I never knew
the truth until General Badeau unearthed the facts in his researches
for his history of my campaigns.
General Halleck unquestionably deemed General C. F. Smith a much
fitter officer for the command of all the forces in the military
district than I was, and, to render him available for such command,
desired his promotion to antedate mine and those of the other division
commanders. It is probable that the general opinion was that Smith's
long services in the army and distinguished deeds rendered him the
more proper person for such command. Indeed I was rather inclined to
this opinion myself at that time, and would have served as faithfully
under Smith as he had done under me. But this did not justify the
dispatches which General Halleck sent to Washington, or his subsequent
concealment of them from me when pretending to explain the action of
my superiors.
On receipt of the order restoring me to command I proceeded to
Savannah on the Tennessee, to which point my troops had advanced.
General Smith was delighted to see me and was unhesitating in his
denunciation of the treatment I had received. He was on a sick bed at
the time, from which he never came away alive. His death was a severe
loss to our western army. His personal courage was unquestioned, his
judgment and professional acquirements were unsurpassed, and he had
the confidence of those he commanded as well as of those over him.
When I reassumed command on the 17th of March I found the army
divided, about half being on the east bank of the Tennessee at
Savannah, while one division was at Crump's landing on the west bank
about four miles higher up, and the remainder at Pittsburg landing,
five miles above Crump's. The enemy was in force at Corinth, the
junction of the two most important railroads in the Mississippi
valley--one connecting Memphis and the Mississippi River with the
East, and the other leading south to all the cotton states. Still
another railroad connects Corinth with Jackson, in west Tennessee. If
we obtained possession of Corinth the enemy would have no railroad for
the transportation of armies or supplies until that running east from
Vicksburg was reached. It was the great strategic position at the
West between the Tennessee and the Mississippi rivers and between
Nashville and Vicksburg.
I at once put all the troops at Savannah in motion for Pittsburg
landing, knowing that the enemy was fortifying at Corinth and
collecting an army there under Johnston. It was my expectation to
march against that army as soon as Buell, who had been ordered to
reinforce me with the Army of the Ohio, should arrive; and the west
bank of the river was the place to start from. Pittsburg is only
about twenty miles from Corinth, and Hamburg landing, four miles
further up the river, is a mile or two nearer. I had not been in
command long before I selected Hamburg as the place to put the Army of
the Ohio when it arrived. The roads from Pittsburg and Hamburg to
Corinth converge some eight miles out. This disposition of the troops
would have given additional roads to march over when the advance
commenced, within supporting distance of each other.
Before I arrived at Savannah, Sherman, who had joined the Army of
the Tennessee and been placed in command of a division, had made an
expedition on steamers convoyed by gunboats to the neighborhood of
Eastport, thirty miles south, for the purpose of destroying the
railroad east of Corinth. The rains had been so heavy for some time
before that the low-lands had become impassable swamps. Sherman
debarked his troops and started out to accomplish the object of the
expedition; but the river was rising so rapidly that the back-water up
the small tributaries threatened to cut off the possibility of getting
back to the boats, and the expedition had to return without reaching
the railroad. The guns had to be hauled by hand through the water to
get back to the boats.
On the 17th of March the army on the Tennessee River consisted of
five divisions, commanded respectively by Generals C. F. Smith,
McClernand, L. Wallace, Hurlbut and Sherman. General W. H. L. Wallace
was temporarily in command of Smith's division, General Smith, as I
have said, being confined to his bed. Reinforcements were arriving
daily and as they came up they were organized, first into brigades,
then into a division, and the command given to General Prentiss, who
had been ordered to report to me. General Buell was on his way from
Nashville with 40,000 veterans. On the 19th of March he was at
Columbia, Tennessee, eighty-five miles from Pittsburg. When all
reinforcements should have arrived I expected to take the initiative
by marching on Corinth, and had no expectation of needing
fortifications, though this subject was taken into consideration.
McPherson, my only military engineer, was directed to lay out a line
to intrench. He did so, but reported that it would have to be made in
rear of the line of encampment as it then ran. The new line, while it
would be nearer the river, was yet too far away from the Tennessee, or
even from the creeks, to be easily supplied with water, and in case of
attack these creeks would be in the hands of the enemy. The fact is,
I regarded the campaign we were engaged in as an offensive one and
had no idea that the enemy would leave strong intrenchments to take
the initiative when he knew he would be attacked where he was if he
remained. This view, however, did not prevent every precaution being
taken and every effort made to keep advised of all movements of the
enemy.
Johnston's cavalry meanwhile had been well out towards our front,
and occasional encounters occurred between it and our outposts. On
the 1st of April this cavalry became bold and approached our lines,
showing that an advance of some kind was contemplated. On the 2d
Johnston left Corinth in force to attack my army. On the 4th his
cavalry dashed down and captured a small picket guard of six or seven
men, stationed some five miles out from Pittsburg on the Corinth road.
Colonel Buckland sent relief to the guard at once and soon followed
in person with an entire regiment, and General Sherman followed
Buckland taking the remainder of a brigade. The pursuit was kept up
for some three miles beyond the point where the picket guard had been
captured, and after nightfall Sherman returned to camp and reported to
me by letter what had occurred.
At this time a large body of the enemy was hovering to the west of
us, along the line of the Mobile and Ohio railroad. My apprehension
was much greater for the safety of Crump's landing than it was for
Pittsburg. I had no apprehension that the enemy could really capture
either place. But I feared it was possible that he might make a rapid
dash upon Crump's and destroy our transports and stores, most of which
were kept at that point, and then retreat before Wallace could be
reinforced. Lew. Wallace's position I regarded as so well chosen that
he was not removed.
At this time I generally spent the day at Pittsburg and returned
to Savannah in the evening. I was intending to remove my
headquarters to Pittsburg, but Buell was expected daily and would
come in at Savannah. I remained at this point, therefore, a few days
longer than I otherwise should have done, in order to meet him on his
arrival. The skirmishing in our front, however, had been so
continuous from about the 3d of April that I did not leave Pittsburg
each night until an hour when I felt there would be no further danger
before the morning.
On Friday the 4th, the day of Buckland's advance, I was very much
injured by my horse falling with me, and on me, while I was trying to
get to the front where firing had been heard. The night was one of
impenetrable darkness, with rain pouring down in torrents; nothing was
visible to the eye except as revealed by the frequent flashes of
lightning. Under these circumstances I had to trust to the horse,
without guidance, to keep the road. I had not gone far, however, when
I met General W. H. L. Wallace and Colonel (afterwards General)
McPherson coming from the direction of the front. They said all was
quiet so far as the enemy was concerned. On the way back to the boat
my horse's feet slipped from under him, and he fell with my leg under
his body. The extreme softness of the ground, from the excessive
rains of the few preceding days, no doubt saved me from a severe
injury and protracted lameness. As it was, my ankle was very much
injured, so much so that my boot had to be cut off. For two or three
days after I was unable to walk except with crutches.
On the 5th General Nelson, with a division of Buell's army,
arrived at Savannah and I ordered him to move up the east bank of the
river, to be in a position where he could be ferried over to Crump's
landing or Pittsburg as occasion required. I had learned that General
Buell himself would be at Savannah the next day, and desired to meet
me on his arrival. Affairs at Pittsburg landing had been such for
several days that I did not want to be away during the day. I
determined, therefore, to take a very early breakfast and ride out to
meet Buell, and thus save time. He had arrived on the evening of the
5th, but had not advised me of the fact and I was not aware of it
until some time after. While I was at breakfast, however, heavy
firing was heard in the direction of Pittsburg landing, and I hastened
there, sending a hurried note to Buell informing him of the reason why
I could not meet him at Savannah. On the way up the river I directed
the dispatch-boat to run in close to Crump's landing, so that I could
communicate with General Lew. Wallace. I found him waiting on a boat
apparently expecting to see me, and I directed him to get his troops
in line ready to execute any orders he might receive. He replied that
his troops were already under arms and prepared to move.
Up to that time I had felt by no means certain that Crump's
landing might not be the point of attack. On reaching the front,
however, about eight A.M., I found that the attack on Pittsburg was
unmistakable, and that nothing more than a small guard, to protect our
transports and stores, was needed at Crump's. Captain Baxter, a
quartermaster on my staff, was accordingly directed to go back and
order General Wallace to march immediately to Pittsburg by the road
nearest the river. Captain Baxter made a memorandum of this order.
About one P.M., not hearing from Wallace and being much in need of
reinforcements, I sent two more of my staff, Colonel McPherson and
Captain Rowley, to bring him up with his division. They reported
finding him marching towards Purdy, Bethel, or some point west from
the river, and farther from Pittsburg by several miles than when he
started. The road from his first position to Pittsburg landing was
direct and near the river. Between the two points a bridge had been
built across Snake Creek by our troops, at which Wallace's command had
assisted, expressly to enable the troops at the two places to support
each other in case of need. Wallace did not arrive in time to take
part in the first day's fight. General Wallace has since claimed that
the order delivered to him by Captain Baxter was simply to join the
right of the army, and that the road over which he marched would have
taken him to the road from Pittsburg to Purdy where it crosses Owl
Creek on the right of Sherman; but this is not where I had ordered him
nor where I wanted him to go.
I never could see and do not now see why any order was necessary
further than to direct him to come to Pittsburg landing, without
specifying by what route. His was one of three veteran divisions
that had been in battle, and its absence was severely felt. Later in
the war General Wallace would not have made the mistake that he
committed on the 6th of April, 1862. I presume his idea was that by
taking the route he did he would be able to come around on the flank
or rear of the enemy, and thus perform an act of heroism that would
redound to the credit of his command, as well as to the benefit of his
country.
Some two or three miles from Pittsburg landing was a log
meeting-house called Shiloh. It stood on the ridge which divides the
waters of Snake and Lick creeks, the former emptying into the
Tennessee just north of Pittsburg landing, and the latter south. This
point was the key to our position and was held by Sherman. His
division was at that time wholly raw, no part of it ever having been
in an engagement; but I thought this deficiency was more than made up
by the superiority of the commander. McClernand was on Sherman's
left, with troops that had been engaged at forts Henry and Donelson
and were therefore veterans so far as western troops had become such
at that stage of the war. Next to McClernand came Prentiss with a raw
division, and on the extreme left, Stuart with one brigade of
Sherman's division. Hurlbut was in rear of Prentiss, massed, and in
reserve at the time of the onset. The division of General C. F. Smith
was on the right, also in reserve. General Smith was still sick in
bed at Savannah, but within hearing of our guns. His services would
no doubt have been of inestimable value had his health permitted his
presence. The command of his division devolved upon Brigadier-General
W. H. L. Wallace, a most estimable and able officer; a veteran too,
for he had served a year in the Mexican war and had been with his
command at Henry and Donelson. Wallace was mortally wounded in the
first day's engagement, and with the change of commanders thus
necessarily effected in the heat of battle the efficiency of his
division was much weakened.
The position of our troops made a continuous line from Lick Creek
on the left to Owl Creek, a branch of Snake Creek, on the right,
facing nearly south and possibly a little west. The water in all
these streams was very high at the time and contributed to protect our
flanks. The enemy was compelled, therefore, to attack directly in
front. This he did with great vigor, inflicting heavy losses on the
National side, but suffering much heavier on his own.
The Confederate assaults were made with such a disregard of losses
on their own side that our line of tents soon fell into their hands.
The ground on which the battle was fought was undulating, heavily
timbered with scattered clearings, the woods giving some protection to
the troops on both sides. There was also considerable underbrush. A
number of attempts were made by the enemy to turn our right flank,
where Sherman was posted, but every effort was repulsed with heavy
loss. But the front attack was kept up so vigorously that, to prevent
the success of these attempts to get on our flanks, the National
troops were compelled, several times, to take positions to the rear
nearer Pittsburg landing. When the firing ceased at night the
National line was all of a mile in rear of the position it had
occupied in the morning.
In one of the backward moves, on the 6th, the division commanded
by General Prentiss did not fall back with the others. This left his
flanks exposed and enabled the enemy to capture him with about 2,200
of his officers and men. General Badeau gives four o'clock of the 6th
as about the time this capture took place. He may be right as to the
time, but my recollection is that the hour was later. General
Prentiss himself gave the hour as half-past five. I was with him, as
I was with each of the division commanders that day, several times,
and my recollection is that the last time I was with him was about
half-past four, when his division was standing up firmly and the
General was as cool as if expecting victory. But no matter whether it
was four or later, the story that he and his command were surprised
and captured in their camps is without any foundation whatever. If
it had been true, as currently reported at the time and yet believed
by thousands of people, that Prentiss and his division had been
captured in their beds, there would not have been an all-day struggle,
with the loss of thousands killed and wounded on the Confederate side.
With the single exception of a few minutes after the capture of
Prentiss, a continuous and unbroken line was maintained all day from
Snake Creek or its tributaries on the right to Lick Creek or the
Tennessee on the left above Pittsburg.
There was no hour during the day when there was not heavy firing
and generally hard fighting at some point on the line, but seldom at
all points at the same time. It was a case of Southern dash against
Northern pluck and endurance. Three of the five divisions engaged on
Sunday were entirely raw, and many of the men had only received their
arms on the way from their States to the field. Many of them had
arrived but a day or two before and were hardly able to load their
muskets according to the manual. Their officers were equally ignorant
of their duties. Under these circumstances it is not astonishing that
many of the regiments broke at the first fire. In two cases, as I now
remember, colonels led their regiments from the field on first
hearing the whistle of the enemy's bullets. In these cases the
colonels were constitutional cowards, unfit for any military
position; but not so the officers and men led out of danger by them.
Better troops never went upon a battle-field than many of these,
officers and men, afterwards proved themselves to be, who fled panic
stricken at the first whistle of bullets and shell at Shiloh.
During the whole of Sunday I was continuously engaged in passing
from one part of the field to another, giving directions to division
commanders. In thus moving along the line, however, I never deemed it
important to stay long with Sherman. Although his troops were then
under fire for the first time, their commander, by his constant
presence with them, inspired a confidence in officers and men that
enabled them to render services on that bloody battle-field worthy of
the best of veterans. McClernand was next to Sherman, and the hardest
fighting was in front of these two divisions. McClernand told me on
that day, the 6th, that he profited much by having so able a commander
supporting him. A casualty to Sherman that would have taken him from
the field that day would have been a sad one for the troops engaged at
Shiloh. And how near we came to this! On the 6th Sherman was shot
twice, once in the hand, once in the shoulder, the ball cutting his
coat and making a slight wound, and a third ball passed through his
hat. In addition to this he had several horses shot during the day.
The nature of this battle was such that cavalry could not be used
in front; I therefore formed ours into line in rear, to stop
stragglers--of whom there were many. When there would be enough of
them to make a show, and after they had recovered from their fright,
they would be sent to reinforce some part of the line which needed
support, without regard to their companies, regiments or brigades.
On one occasion during the day I rode back as far as the river and
met General Buell, who had just arrived; I do not remember the hour,
but at that time there probably were as many as four or five thousand
stragglers lying under cover of the river bluff, panic-stricken, most
of whom would have been shot where they lay, without resistance,
before they would have taken muskets and marched to the front to
protect themselves. This meeting between General Buell and myself was
on the dispatch-boat used to run between the landing and Savannah. It
was brief, and related specially to his getting his troops over the
river. As we left the boat together, Buell's attention was attracted
by the men lying under cover of the river bank. I saw him berating
them and trying to shame them into joining their regiments. He even
threatened them with shells from the gunboats near by. But it was all
to no effect. Most of these men afterward proved themselves as
gallant as any of those who saved the battle from which they had
deserted. I have no doubt that this sight impressed General Buell
with the idea that a line of retreat would be a good thing just then.
If he had come in by the front instead of through the stragglers in
the rear, he would have thought and felt differently. Could he have
come through the Confederate rear, he would have witnessed there a
scene similar to that at our own. The distant rear of an army
engaged in battle is not the best place from which to judge correctly
what is going on in front. Later in the war, while occupying the
country between the Tennessee and the Mississippi, I learned that the
panic in the Confederate lines had not differed much from that within
our own. Some of the country people estimated the stragglers from
Johnston's army as high as 20,000. Of course this was an
exaggeration.
The situation at the close of Sunday was as follows: along the
top of the bluff just south of the log-house which stood at Pittsburg
landing, Colonel J. D. Webster, of my staff, had arranged twenty or
more pieces of artillery facing south or up the river. This line of
artillery was on the crest of a hill overlooking a deep ravine opening
into the Tennessee. Hurlbut with his division intact was on the right
of this artillery, extending west and possibly a little north.
McClernand came next in the general line, looking more to the west.
His division was complete in its organization and ready for any
duty. Sherman came next, his right extending to Snake Creek. His
command, like the other two, was complete in its organization and
ready, like its chief, for any service it might be called upon to
render. All three divisions were, as a matter of course, more or less
shattered and depleted in numbers from the terrible battle of the day.
The division of W. H. L. Wallace, as much from the disorder arising
from changes of division and brigade commanders, under heavy fire, as
from any other cause, had lost its organization and did not occupy a
place in the line as a division. Prentiss' command was gone as a
division, many of its members having been killed, wounded or captured,
but it had rendered valiant services before its final dispersal, and
had contributed a good share to the defence of Shiloh.
The right of my line rested near the bank of Snake Creek, a short
distance above the bridge which had been built by the troops for the
purpose of connecting Crump's landing and Pittsburg landing. Sherman
had posted some troops in a log-house and out-buildings which
overlooked both the bridge over which Wallace was expected and the
creek above that point. In this last position Sherman was frequently
attacked before night, but held the point until he voluntarily
abandoned it to advance in order to make room for Lew. Wallace, who
came up after dark.
There was, as I have said, a deep ravine in front of our left. The
Tennessee River was very high and there was water to a considerable
depth in the ravine. Here the enemy made a last desperate effort to
turn our flank, but was repelled. The gunboats Tyler and Lexington,
Gwin and Shirk commanding, with the artillery under Webster, aided the
army and effectually checked their further progress. Before any of
Buell's troops had reached the west bank of the Tennessee, firing had
almost entirely ceased; anything like an attempt on the part of the
enemy to advance had absolutely ceased. There was some artillery
firing from an unseen enemy, some of his shells passing beyond us; but
I do not remember that there was the whistle of a single musket-ball
heard. As his troops arrived in the dusk General Buell marched
several of his regiments part way down the face of the hill where they
fired briskly for some minutes, but I do not think a single man
engaged in this firing received an injury. The attack had spent its
force.
General Lew. Wallace, with 5,000 effective men, arrived after
firing had ceased for the day, and was placed on the right. Thus
night came, Wallace came, and the advance of Nelson's division came;
but none--unless night--in time to be of material service to the
gallant men who saved Shiloh on that first day against large odds.
Buell's loss on the 6th of April was two men killed and one wounded,
all members of the 36th Indiana infantry. The Army of the Tennessee
lost on that day at least 7,000 men. The presence of two or three
regiments of Buell's army on the west bank before firing ceased had
not the slightest effect in preventing the capture of Pittsburg
landing.
So confident was I before firing had ceased on the 6th that the
next day would bring victory to our arms if we could only take the
initiative, that I visited each division commander in person before
any reinforcements had reached the field. I directed them to throw
out heavy lines of skirmishers in the morning as soon as they could
see, and push them forward until they found the enemy, following with
their entire divisions in supporting distance, and to engage the enemy
as soon as found. To Sherman I told the story of the assault at Fort
Donelson, and said that the same tactics would win at Shiloh. Victory
was assured when Wallace arrived, even if there had been no other
support. I was glad, however, to see the reinforcements of Buell and
credit them with doing all there was for them to do.
During the night of the 6th the remainder of Nelson's division,
Buell's army crossed the river and were ready to advance in the
morning, forming the left wing. Two other divisions, Crittenden's
and McCook's, came up the river from Savannah in the transports and
were on the west bank early on the 7th. Buell commanded them in
person. My command was thus nearly doubled in numbers and efficiency.
During the night rain fell in torrents and our troops were exposed
to the storm without shelter. I made my headquarters under a tree a
few hundred yards back from the river bank. My ankle was so much
swollen from the fall of my horse the Friday night preceding, and the
bruise was so painful, that I could get no rest.
The drenching rain would have precluded the possibility of sleep
without this additional cause. Some time after midnight, growing
restive under the storm and the continuous pain, I moved back to the
log-house under the bank. This had been taken as a hospital, and all
night wounded men were being brought in, their wounds dressed, a leg
or an arm amputated as the case might require, and everything being
done to save life or alleviate suffering. The sight was more
unendurable than encountering the enemy's fire, and I returned to my
tree in the rain.
The advance on the morning of the 7th developed the enemy in the
camps occupied by our troops before the battle began, more than a
mile back from the most advanced position of the Confederates on the
day before. It is known now that they had not yet learned of the
arrival of Buell's command. Possibly they fell back so far to get the
shelter of our tents during the rain, and also to get away from the
shells that were dropped upon them by the gunboats every fifteen
minutes during the night.
The position of the Union troops on the morning of the 7th was as
follows: General Lew. Wallace on the right; Sherman on his left; then
McClernand and then Hurlbut. Nelson, of Buell's army, was on our
extreme left, next to the river.
Crittenden was next in line after Nelson and on his right, McCook
followed and formed the extreme right of Buell's command. My old
command thus formed the right wing, while the troops directly under
Buell constituted the left wing of the army. These relative positions
were retained during the entire day, or until the enemy was driven
from the field.
In a very short time the battle became general all along the line.
This day everything was favorable to the Union side. We had now
become the attacking party. The enemy was driven back all day, as we
had been the day before, until finally he beat a precipitate retreat.
The last point held by him was near the road leading from the landing
to Corinth, on the left of Sherman and right of McClernand. About
three o'clock, being near that point and seeing that the enemy was
giving way everywhere else, I gathered up a couple of regiments, or
parts of regiments, from troops near by, formed them in line of battle
and marched them forward, going in front myself to prevent premature
or long-range firing. At this point there was a clearing between us
and the enemy favorable for charging, although exposed. I knew the
enemy were ready to break and only wanted a little encouragement from
us to go quickly and join their friends who had started earlier.
After marching to within musket-range I stopped and let the troops
pass. The command, CHARGE, was given, and was executed with loud
cheers and with a run; when the last of the enemy broke. (*7)
During this second day of the battle I had been moving from right
to left and back, to see for myself the progress made. In the early
part of the afternoon, while riding with Colonel McPherson and Major
Hawkins, then my chief commissary, we got beyond the left of our
troops. We were moving along the northern edge of a clearing, very
leisurely, toward the river above the landing. There did not appear
to be an enemy to our right, until suddenly a battery with musketry
opened upon us from the edge of the woods on the other side of the
clearing. The shells and balls whistled about our ears very fast for
about a minute. I do not think it took us longer than that to get out
of range and out of sight. In the sudden start we made, Major
Hawkins lost his hat. He did not stop to pick it up. When we
arrived at a perfectly safe position we halted to take an account of
damages. McPherson's horse was panting as if ready to drop. On
examination it was found that a ball had struck him forward of the
flank just back of the saddle, and had gone entirely through. In a
few minutes the poor beast dropped dead; he had given no sign of
injury until we came to a stop. A ball had struck the metal scabbard
of my sword, just below the hilt, and broken it nearly off; before the
battle was over it had broken off entirely. There were three of us:
one had lost a horse, killed; one a hat and one a sword-scabbard.
All were thankful that it was no worse.
After the rain of the night before and the frequent and heavy
rains for some days previous, the roads were almost impassable. The
enemy carrying his artillery and supply trains over them in his
retreat, made them still worse for troops following. I wanted to
pursue, but had not the heart to order the men who had fought
desperately for two days, lying in the mud and rain whenever not
fighting, and I did (*8) not feel disposed to positively order Buell,
or any part of his command, to pursue. Although the senior in rank at
the time I had been so only a few weeks. Buell was, and had been for
some time past, a department commander, while I commanded only a
district. I did not meet Buell in person until too late to get
troops ready and pursue with effect; but had I seen him at the moment
of the last charge I should have at least requested him to follow.
I rode forward several miles the day after the battle, and found
that the enemy had dropped much, if not all, of their provisions,
some ammunition and the extra wheels of their caissons, lightening
their loads to enable them to get off their guns. About five miles out
we found their field hospital abandoned. An immediate pursuit must
have resulted in the capture of a considerable number of prisoners and
probably some guns.
Shiloh was the severest battle fought at the West during the war,
and but few in the East equalled it for hard, determined fighting. I
saw an open field, in our possession on the second day, over which the
Confederates had made repeated charges the day before, so covered with
dead that it would have been possible to walk across the clearing, in
any direction, stepping on dead bodies, without a foot touching the
ground. On our side National and Confederate troops were mingled
together in about equal proportions; but on the remainder of the field
nearly all were Confederates. On one part, which had evidently not
been ploughed for several years, probably because the land was poor,
bushes had grown up, some to the height of eight or ten feet. There
was not one of these left standing unpierced by bullets. The smaller
ones were all cut down.
Contrary to all my experience up to that time, and to the
experience of the army I was then commanding, we were on the
defensive. We were without intrenchments or defensive advantages of
any sort, and more than half the army engaged the first day was
without experience or even drill as soldiers. The officers with them,
except the division commanders and possibly two or three of the
brigade commanders, were equally inexperienced in war. The result was
a Union victory that gave the men who achieved it great confidence in
themselves ever after.
The enemy fought bravely, but they had started out to defeat and
destroy an army and capture a position. They failed in both, with
very heavy loss in killed and wounded, and must have gone back
discouraged and convinced that the "Yankee" was not an enemy to be
despised.
After the battle I gave verbal instructions to division commanders
to let the regiments send out parties to bury their own dead, and to
detail parties, under commissioned officers from each division, to
bury the Confederate dead in their respective fronts and to report the
numbers so buried. The latter part of these instructions was not
carried out by all; but they were by those sent from Sherman's
division, and by some of the parties sent out by McClernand. The
heaviest loss sustained by the enemy was in front of these two
divisions.
The criticism has often been made that the Union troops should
have been intrenched at Shiloh. Up to that time the pick and spade
had been but little resorted to at the West. I had, however, taken
this subject under consideration soon after re-assuming command in the
field, and, as already stated, my only military engineer reported
unfavorably. Besides this, the troops with me, officers and men,
needed discipline and drill more than they did experience with the
pick, shovel and axe. Reinforcements were arriving almost daily,
composed of troops that had been hastily thrown together into
companies and regiments--fragments of incomplete organizations, the
men and officers strangers to each other. Under all these
circumstances I concluded that drill and discipline were worth more to
our men than fortifications.
General Buell was a brave, intelligent officer, with as much
professional pride and ambition of a commendable sort as I ever knew.
I had been two years at West Point with him, and had served with him
afterwards, in garrison and in the Mexican war, several years more.
He was not given in early life or in mature years to forming intimate
acquaintances. He was studious by habit, and commanded the confidence
and respect of all who knew him. He was a strict disciplinarian, and
perhaps did not distinguish sufficiently between the volunteer who
"enlisted for the war" and the soldier who serves in time of peace.
One system embraced men who risked life for a principle, and often
men of social standing, competence, or wealth and independence of
character. The other includes, as a rule, only men who could not do
as well in any other occupation. General Buell became an object of
harsh criticism later, some going so far as to challenge his loyalty.
No one who knew him ever believed him capable of a dishonorable act,
and nothing could be more dishonorable than to accept high rank and
command in war and then betray the trust. When I came into command of
the army in 1864, I requested the Secretary of War to restore General
Buell to duty.
After the war, during the summer of 1865, I travelled considerably
through the North, and was everywhere met by large numbers of people.
Every one had his opinion about the manner in which the war had been
conducted: who among the generals had failed, how, and why.
Correspondents of the press were ever on hand to hear every word
dropped, and were not always disposed to report correctly what did not
confirm their preconceived notions, either about the conduct of the
war or the individuals concerned in it. The opportunity frequently
occurred for me to defend General Buell against what I believed to be
most unjust charges. On one occasion a correspondent put in my mouth
the very charge I had so often refuted--of disloyalty. This brought
from General Buell a very severe retort, which I saw in the New York
World some time before I received the letter itself. I could very
well understand his grievance at seeing untrue and disgraceful charges
apparently sustained by an officer who, at the time, was at the head
of the army. I replied to him, but not through the press. I kept no
copy of my letter, nor did I ever see it in print; neither did I
receive an answer.
General Albert Sidney Johnston, who commanded the Confederate
forces at the beginning of the battle, was disabled by a wound on the
afternoon of the first day. This wound, as I understood afterwards,
was not necessarily fatal, or even dangerous. But he was a man who
would not abandon what he deemed an important trust in the face of
danger and consequently continued in the saddle, commanding, until so
exhausted by the loss of blood that he had to be taken from his horse,
and soon after died. The news was not long in reaching our side and I
suppose was quite an encouragement to the National soldiers.
I had known Johnston slightly in the Mexican war and later as an
officer in the regular army. He was a man of high character and
ability. His contemporaries at West Point, and officers generally
who came to know him personally later and who remained on our side,
expected him to prove the most formidable man to meet that the
Confederacy would produce.
I once wrote that nothing occurred in his brief command of an army
to prove or disprove the high estimate that had been placed upon his
military ability; but after studying the orders and dispatches of
Johnston I am compelled to materially modify my views of that
officer's qualifications as a soldier. My judgment now is that he was
vacillating and undecided in his actions.
All the disasters in Kentucky and Tennessee were so discouraging
to the authorities in Richmond that Jefferson Davis wrote an
unofficial letter to Johnston expressing his own anxiety and that of
the public, and saying that he had made such defence as was dictated
by long friendship, but that in the absence of a report he needed
facts. The letter was not a reprimand in direct terms, but it was
evidently as much felt as though it had been one. General Johnston
raised another army as rapidly as he could, and fortified or strongly
intrenched at Corinth. He knew the National troops were preparing to
attack him in his chosen position. But he had evidently become so
disturbed at the results of his operations that he resolved to strike
out in an offensive campaign which would restore all that was lost,
and if successful accomplish still more. We have the authority of his
son and biographer for saying that his plan was to attack the forces
at Shiloh and crush them; then to cross the Tennessee and destroy the
army of Buell, and push the war across the Ohio River. The design was
a bold one; but we have the same authority for saying that in the
execution Johnston showed vacillation and indecision. He left Corinth
on the 2d of April and was not ready to attack until the 6th. The
distance his army had to march was less than twenty miles.
Beauregard, his second in command, was opposed to the attack for two
reasons: first, he thought, if let alone the National troops would
attack the Confederates in their intrenchments; second, we were in
ground of our own choosing and would necessarily be intrenched.
Johnston not only listened to the objection of Beauregard to an
attack, but held a council of war on the subject on the morning of the
5th. On the evening of the same day he was in consultation with some
of his generals on the same subject, and still again on the morning of
the 6th. During this last consultation, and before a decision had
been reached, the battle began by the National troops opening fire on
the enemy. This seemed to settle the question as to whether there was
to be any battle of Shiloh. It also seems to me to settle the
question as to whether there was a surprise.
I do not question the personal courage of General Johnston, or his
ability. But he did not win the distinction predicted for him by many
of his friends. He did prove that as a general he was over-estimated.
General Beauregard was next in rank to Johnston and succeeded to
the command, which he retained to the close of the battle and during
the subsequent retreat on Corinth, as well as in the siege of that
place. His tactics have been severely criticised by Confederate
writers, but I do not believe his fallen chief could have done any
better under the circumstances. Some of these critics claim that
Shiloh was won when Johnston fell, and that if he had not fallen the
army under me would have been annihilated or captured. IFS defeated
the Confederates at Shiloh. There is little doubt that we would have
been disgracefully beaten IF all the shells and bullets fired by us
had passed harmlessly over the enemy and IF all of theirs had taken
effect. Commanding generals are liable to be killed during
engagements; and the fact that when he was shot Johnston was leading a
brigade to induce it to make a charge which had been repeatedly
ordered, is evidence that there was neither the universal
demoralization on our side nor the unbounded confidence on theirs
which has been claimed. There was, in fact, no hour during the day
when I doubted the eventual defeat of the enemy, although I was
disappointed that reinforcements so near at hand did not arrive at an
earlier hour.
The description of the battle of Shiloh given by Colonel Wm.
Preston Johnston is very graphic and well told. The reader will
imagine that he can see each blow struck, a demoralized and broken
mob of Union soldiers, each blow sending the enemy more demoralized
than ever towards the Tennessee River, which was a little more than
two miles away at the beginning of the onset. If the reader does not
stop to inquire why, with such Confederate success for more than
twelve hours of hard fighting, the National troops were not all
killed, captured or driven into the river, he will regard the pen
picture as perfect. But I witnessed the fight from the National side
from eight o'clock in the morning until night closed the contest. I
see but little in the description that I can recognize. The
Confederate troops fought well and deserve commendation enough for
their bravery and endurance on the 6th of April, without detracting
from their antagonists or claiming anything more than their just dues.
The reports of the enemy show that their condition at the end of
the first day was deplorable; their losses in killed and wounded had
been very heavy, and their stragglers had been quite as numerous as on
the National side, with the difference that those of the enemy left
the field entirely and were not brought back to their respective
commands for many days. On the Union side but few of the stragglers
fell back further than the landing on the river, and many of these
were in line for duty on the second day. The admissions of the
highest Confederate officers engaged at Shiloh make the claim of a
victory for them absurd. The victory was not to either party until
the battle was over. It was then a Union victory, in which the Armies
of the Tennessee and the Ohio both participated. But the Army of the
Tennessee fought the entire rebel army on the 6th and held it at bay
until near night; and night alone closed the conflict and not the
three regiments of Nelson's division.
The Confederates fought with courage at Shiloh, but the particular
skill claimed I could not and still cannot see; though there is
nothing to criticise except the claims put forward for it since. But
the Confederate claimants for superiority in strategy, superiority in
generalship and superiority in dash and prowess are not so unjust to
the Union troops engaged at Shiloh as are many Northern writers. The
troops on both sides were American, and united they need not fear any
foreign foe. It is possible that the Southern man started in with a
little more dash than his Northern brother; but he was correspondingly
less enduring.
The endeavor of the enemy on the first day was simply to hurl
their men against ours--first at one point, then at another,
sometimes at several points at once. This they did with daring and
energy, until at night the rebel troops were worn out. Our effort
during the same time was to be prepared to resist assaults wherever
made. The object of the Confederates on the second day was to get
away with as much of their army and material as possible. Ours then
was to drive them from our front, and to capture or destroy as great a
part as possible of their men and material. We were successful in
driving them back, but not so successful in captures as if farther
pursuit could have been made. As it was, we captured or recaptured on
the second day about as much artillery as we lost on the first; and,
leaving out the one great capture of Prentiss, we took more prisoners
on Monday than the enemy gained from us on Sunday. On the 6th Sherman
lost seven pieces of artillery, McClernand six, Prentiss eight, and
Hurlbut two batteries. On the 7th Sherman captured seven guns,
McClernand three and the Army of the Ohio twenty.
At Shiloh the effective strength of the Union forces on the
morning of the 6th was 33,000 men. Lew. Wallace brought 5,000 more
after nightfall. Beauregard reported the enemy's strength at 40,955.
According to the custom of enumeration in the South, this number
probably excluded every man enlisted as musician or detailed as guard
or nurse, and all commissioned officers-- everybody who did not carry
a musket or serve a cannon. With us everybody in the field receiving
pay from the government is counted. Excluding the troops who fled,
panic-stricken, before they had fired a shot, there was not a time
during the 6th when we had more than 25,000 men in line. On the 7th
Buell brought 20,000 more. Of his remaining two divisions, Thomas's
did not reach the field during the engagement; Wood's arrived before
firing had ceased, but not in time to be of much service.
Our loss in the two days' fight was 1,754 killed, 8,408 wounded
and 2,885 missing. Of these, 2,103 were in the Army of the Ohio.
Beauregard reported a total loss of 10,699, of whom 1,728 were
killed, 8,012 wounded and 957 missing. This estimate must be
incorrect. We buried, by actual count, more of the enemy's dead in
front of the divisions of McClernand and Sherman alone than here
reported, and 4,000 was the estimate of the burial parties of the
whole field. Beauregard reports the Confederate force on the 6th at
over 40,000, and their total loss during the two days at 10,699; and
at the same time declares that he could put only 20,000 men in battle
on the morning of the 7th.
The navy gave a hearty support to the army at Shiloh, as indeed it
always did both before and subsequently when I was in command. The
nature of the ground was such, however, that on this occasion it could
do nothing in aid of the troops until sundown on the first day. The
country was broken and heavily timbered, cutting off all view of the
battle from the river, so that friends would be as much in danger from
fire from the gunboats as the foe. But about sundown, when the
National troops were back in their last position, the right of the
enemy was near the river and exposed to the fire of the two gun-boats,
which was delivered with vigor and effect. After nightfall, when
firing had entirely ceased on land, the commander of the fleet
informed himself, approximately, of the position of our troops and
suggested the idea of dropping a shell within the lines of the enemy
every fifteen minutes during the night. This was done with effect, as
is proved by the Confederate reports.
Up to the battle of Shiloh I, as well as thousands of other
citizens, believed that the rebellion against the Government would
collapse suddenly and soon, if a decisive victory could be gained over
any of its armies. Donelson and Henry were such victories. An army
of more than 21,000 men was captured or destroyed. Bowling Green,
Columbus and Hickman, Kentucky, fell in consequence, and Clarksville
and Nashville, Tennessee, the last two with an immense amount of
stores, also fell into our hands. The Tennessee and Cumberland
rivers, from their mouths to the head of navigation, were secured.
But when Confederate armies were collected which not only attempted
to hold a line farther south, from Memphis to Chattanooga, Knoxville
and on to the Atlantic, but assumed the offensive and made such a
gallant effort to regain what had been lost, then, indeed, I gave up
all idea of saving the Union except by complete conquest. Up to that
time it had been the policy of our army, certainly of that portion
commanded by me, to protect the property of the citizens whose
territory was invaded, without regard to their sentiments, whether
Union or Secession. After this, however, I regarded it as humane to
both sides to protect the persons of those found at their homes, but
to consume everything that could be used to support or supply armies.
Protection was still continued over such supplies as were within
lines held by us and which we expected to continue to hold; but such
supplies within the reach of Confederate armies I regarded as much
contraband as arms or ordnance stores. Their destruction was
accomplished without bloodshed and tended to the same result as the
destruction of armies. I continued this policy to the close of the
war. Promiscuous pillaging, however, was discouraged and punished.
Instructions were always given to take provisions and forage under
the direction of commissioned officers who should give receipts to
owners, if at home, and turn the property over to officers of the
quartermaster or commissary departments to be issued as if furnished
from our Northern depots. But much was destroyed without receipts to
owners, when it could not be brought within our lines and would
otherwise have gone to the support of secession and rebellion.
This policy I believe exercised a material influence in hastening
the end.
The battle of Shiloh, or Pittsburg landing, has been perhaps less
understood, or, to state the case more accurately, more persistently
misunderstood, than any other engagement between National and
Confederate troops during the entire rebellion. Correct reports of the
battle have been published, notably by Sherman, Badeau and, in a
speech before a meeting of veterans, by General Prentiss; but all of
these appeared long subsequent to the close of the rebellion and after
public opinion had been most erroneously formed.
I myself made no report to General Halleck, further than was
contained in a letter, written immediately after the battle informing
him that an engagement had been fought and announcing the result. A
few days afterwards General Halleck moved his headquarters to
Pittsburg landing and assumed command of the troops in the field.
Although next to him in rank, and nominally in command of my old
district and army, I was ignored as much as if I had been at the most
distant point of territory within my jurisdiction; and although I was
in command of all the troops engaged at Shiloh I was not permitted to
see one of the reports of General Buell or his subordinates in that
battle, until they were published by the War Department long after the
event. For this reason I never made a full official report of this
engagement.
General Halleck arrived at Pittsburg landing on the 11th of April
and immediately assumed command in the field. On the 21st General
Pope arrived with an army 30,000 strong, fresh from the capture of
Island Number Ten in the Mississippi River. He went into camp at
Hamburg landing five miles above Pittsburg. Halleck had now three
armies: the Army of the Ohio, Buell commanding; the Army of the
Mississippi, Pope commanding; and the Army of the Tennessee. His
orders divided the combined force into the right wing, reserve, centre
and left wing. Major-General George H. Thomas, who had been in Buell's
army, was transferred with his division to the Army of the Tennessee
and given command of the right wing, composed of all of that army
except McClernand's and Lew. Wallace's divisions. McClernand was
assigned to the command of the reserve, composed of his own and Lew.
Wallace's divisions. Buell commanded the centre, the Army of the
Ohio; and Pope the left wing, the Army of the Mississippi. I was
named second in command of the whole, and was also supposed to be in
command of the right wing and reserve.
Orders were given to all the commanders engaged at Shiloh to send
in their reports without delay to department headquarters. Those from
officers of the Army of the Tennessee were sent through me; but from
the Army of the Ohio they were sent by General Buell without passing
through my hands. General Halleck ordered me, verbally, to send in my
report, but I positively declined on the ground that he had received
the reports of a part of the army engaged at Shiloh without their
coming through me. He admitted that my refusal was justifiable under
the circumstances, but explained that he had wanted to get the reports
off before moving the command, and as fast as a report had come to him
he had forwarded it to Washington.
Preparations were at once made upon the arrival of the new
commander for an advance on Corinth. Owl Creek, on our right, was
bridged, and expeditions were sent to the north-west and west to
ascertain if our position was being threatened from those quarters;
the roads towards Corinth were corduroyed and new ones made; lateral
roads were also constructed, so that in case of necessity troops
marching by different routes could reinforce each other. All
commanders were cautioned against bringing on an engagement and
informed in so many words that it would be better to retreat than to
fight. By the 30th of April all preparations were complete; the
country west to the Mobile and Ohio railroad had been reconnoitred, as
well as the road to Corinth as far as Monterey twelve miles from
Pittsburg. Everywhere small bodies of the enemy had been encountered,
but they were observers and not in force to fight battles.
Corinth, Mississippi, lies in a south-westerly direction from
Pittsburg landing and about nineteen miles away as the bird would
fly, but probably twenty-two by the nearest wagon-road. It is about
four miles south of the line dividing the States of Tennessee and
Mississippi, and at the junction of the Mississippi and Chattanooga
railroad with the Mobile and Ohio road which runs from Columbus to
Mobile. From Pittsburg to Corinth the land is rolling, but at no
point reaching an elevation that makes high hills to pass over. In
1862 the greater part of the country was covered with forest with
intervening clearings and houses. Underbrush was dense in the low
grounds along the creeks and ravines, but generally not so thick on
the high land as to prevent men passing through with ease. There are
two small creeks running from north of the town and connecting some
four miles south, where they form Bridge Creek which empties into the
Tuscumbia River. Corinth is on the ridge between these streams and is
a naturally strong defensive position. The creeks are insignificant
in volume of water, but the stream to the east widens out in front of
the town into a swamp impassable in the presence of an enemy. On the
crest of the west bank of this stream the enemy was strongly
intrenched.
Corinth was a valuable strategic point for the enemy to hold, and
consequently a valuable one for us to possess ourselves of. We ought
to have seized it immediately after the fall of Donelson and
Nashville, when it could have been taken without a battle, but failing
then it should have been taken, without delay on the concentration of
troops at Pittsburg landing after the battle of Shiloh. In fact the
arrival of Pope should not have been awaited. There was no time from
the battle of Shiloh up to the evacuation of Corinth when the enemy
would not have left if pushed. The demoralization among the
Confederates from their defeats at Henry and Donelson; their long
marches from Bowling Green, Columbus, and Nashville, and their failure
at Shiloh; in fact from having been driven out of Kentucky and
Tennessee, was so great that a stand for the time would have been
impossible. Beauregard made strenuous efforts to reinforce himself
and partially succeeded. He appealed to the people of the South-west
for new regiments, and received a few. A. S. Johnston had made
efforts to reinforce in the same quarter, before the battle of Shiloh,
but in a different way. He had negroes sent out to him to take the
place of teamsters, company cooks and laborers in every capacity, so
as to put all his white men into the ranks. The people, while willing
to send their sons to the field, were not willing to part with their
negroes. It is only fair to state that they probably wanted their
blacks to raise supplies for the army and for the families left at
home.
Beauregard, however, was reinforced by Van Dorn immediately after
Shiloh with 17,000 men. Interior points, less exposed, were also
depleted to add to the strength at Corinth. With these reinforcements
and the new regiments, Beauregard had, during the month of May, 1862,
a large force on paper, but probably not much over 50,000 effective
men. We estimated his strength at 70,000. Our own was, in round
numbers, 120,000. The defensible nature of the ground at Corinth, and
the fortifications, made 50,000 then enough to maintain their
position against double that number for an indefinite time but for
the demoralization spoken of.
On the 30th of April the grand army commenced its advance from
Shiloh upon Corinth. The movement was a siege from the start to the
close. The National troops were always behind intrenchments, except
of course the small reconnoitring parties sent to the front to clear
the way for an advance. Even the commanders of these parties were
cautioned, "not to bring on an engagement." "It is better to retreat
than to fight." The enemy were constantly watching our advance, but
as they were simply observers there were but few engagements that even
threatened to become battles. All the engagements fought ought to
have served to encourage the enemy. Roads were again made in our
front, and again corduroyed; a line was intrenched, and the troops
were advanced to the new position. Cross roads were constructed to
these new positions to enable the troops to concentrate in case of
attack. The National armies were thoroughly intrenched all the way
from the Tennessee River to Corinth.
For myself I was little more than an observer. Orders were sent
direct to the right wing or reserve, ignoring me, and advances were
made from one line of intrenchments to another without notifying me.
My position was so embarrassing in fact that I made several
applications during the siege to be relieved.
General Halleck kept his headquarters generally, if not all the
time, with the right wing. Pope being on the extreme left did not
see so much of his chief, and consequently got loose as it were at
times. On the 3d of May he was at Seven Mile Creek with the main body
of his command, but threw forward a division to Farmington, within
four miles of Corinth. His troops had quite a little engagement at
Farmington on that day, but carried the place with considerable loss
to the enemy. There would then have been no difficulty in advancing
the centre and right so as to form a new line well up to the enemy,
but Pope was ordered back to conform with the general line. On the
8th of May he moved again, taking his whole force to Farmington, and
pushed out two divisions close to the rebel line. Again he was
ordered back. By the 4th of May the centre and right wing reached
Monterey, twelve miles out. Their advance was slow from there, for
they intrenched with every forward movement. The left wing moved up
again on the 25th of May and intrenched itself close to the enemy.
The creek with the marsh before described, separated the two lines.
Skirmishers thirty feet apart could have maintained either line at
this point.
Our centre and right were, at this time, extended so that the
right of the right wing was probably five miles from Corinth and four
from the works in their front. The creek, which was a formidable
obstacle for either side to pass on our left, became a very slight
obstacle on our right. Here the enemy occupied two positions. One of
them, as much as two miles out from his main line, was on a commanding
elevation and defended by an intrenched battery with infantry
supports. A heavy wood intervened between this work and the National
forces. In rear to the south there was a clearing extending a mile or
more, and south of this clearing a log-house which had been loop-holed
and was occupied by infantry. Sherman's division carried these two
positions with some loss to himself, but with probably greater to the
enemy, on the 28th of May, and on that day the investment of Corinth
was complete, or as complete as it was ever made. Thomas' right now
rested west of the Mobile and Ohio railroad. Pope's left commanded the
Memphis and Charleston railroad east of Corinth.
Some days before I had suggested to the commanding general that I
thought if he would move the Army of the Mississippi at night, by the
rear of the centre and right, ready to advance at daylight, Pope would
find no natural obstacle in his front and, I believed, no serious
artificial one. The ground, or works, occupied by our left could be
held by a thin picket line, owing to the stream and swamp in front.
To the right the troops would have a dry ridge to march over. I was
silenced so quickly that I felt that possibly I had suggested an
unmilitary movement.
Later, probably on the 28th of May, General Logan, whose command
was then on the Mobile and Ohio railroad, said to me that the enemy
had been evacuating for several days and that if allowed he could go
into Corinth with his brigade. Trains of cars were heard coming in
and going out of Corinth constantly. Some of the men who had been
engaged in various capacities on railroads before the war claimed that
they could tell, by putting their ears to the rail, not only which way
the trains were moving but which trains were loaded and which were
empty. They said loaded trains had been going out for several days
and empty ones coming in. Subsequent events proved the correctness of
their judgment. Beauregard published his orders for the evacuation of
Corinth on the 26th of May and fixed the 29th for the departure of
his troops, and on the 30th of May General Halleck had his whole army
drawn up prepared for battle and announced in orders that there was
every indication that our left was to be attacked that morning.
Corinth had already been evacuated and the National troops marched on
and took possession without opposition. Everything had been destroyed
or carried away. The Confederate commander had instructed his
soldiers to cheer on the arrival of every train to create the
impression among the Yankees that reinforcements were arriving. There
was not a sick or wounded man left by the Confederates, nor stores of
any kind. Some ammunition had been blown up--not removed--but the
trophies of war were a few Quaker guns, logs of about the diameter of
ordinary cannon, mounted on wheels of wagons and pointed in the most
threatening manner towards us.
The possession of Corinth by the National troops was of strategic
importance, but the victory was barren in every other particular. It
was nearly bloodless. It is a question whether the MORALE of the
Confederate troops engaged at Corinth was not improved by the immunity
with which they were permitted to remove all public property and then
withdraw themselves. On our side I know officers and men of the Army
of the Tennessee--and I presume the same is true of those of the other
commands--were disappointed at the result. They could not see how the
mere occupation of places was to close the war while large and
effective rebel armies existed. They believed that a well- directed
attack would at least have partially destroyed the army defending
Corinth. For myself I am satisfied that Corinth could have been
captured in a two days' campaign commenced promptly on the arrival of
reinforcements after the battle of Shiloh.
General Halleck at once commenced erecting fortifications around
Corinth on a scale to indicate that this one point must be held if it
took the whole National army to do it. All commanding points two or
three miles to the south, south-east and south-west were strongly
fortified. It was expected in case of necessity to connect these
forts by rifle-pits. They were laid out on a scale that would have
required 100,000 men to fully man them. It was probably thought that
a final battle of the war would be fought at that point. These
fortifications were never used. Immediately after the occupation of
Corinth by the National troops, General Pope was sent in pursuit of
the retreating garrison and General Buell soon followed. Buell was
the senior of the two generals and commanded the entire column. The
pursuit was kept up for some thirty miles, but did not result in the
capture of any material of war or prisoners, unless a few stragglers
who had fallen behind and were willing captives. On the 10th of June
the pursuing column was all back at Corinth. The Army of the
Tennessee was not engaged in any of these movements.
The Confederates were now driven out of West Tennessee, and on the
6th of June, after a well-contested naval battle, the National forces
took possession of Memphis and held the Mississippi river from its
source to that point. The railroad from Columbus to Corinth was at
once put in good condition and held by us. We had garrisons at
Donelson, Clarksville and Nashville, on the Cumberland River, and held
the Tennessee River from its mouth to Eastport. New Orleans and Baton
Rouge had fallen into the possession of the National forces, so that
now the Confederates at the west were narrowed down for all
communication with Richmond to the single line of road running east
from Vicksburg. To dispossess them of this, therefore, became a
matter of the first importance. The possession of the Mississippi by
us from Memphis to Baton Rouge was also a most important object. It
would be equal to the amputation of a limb in its weakening effects
upon the enemy.
After the capture of Corinth a movable force of 80,000 men,
besides enough to hold all the territory acquired, could have been
set in motion for the accomplishment of any great campaign for the
suppression of the rebellion. In addition to this fresh troops were
being raised to swell the effective force. But the work of depletion
commenced. Buell with the Army of the Ohio was sent east, following
the line of the Memphis and Charleston railroad. This he was ordered
to repair as he advanced--only to have it destroyed by small guerilla
bands or other troops as soon as he was out of the way. If he had
been sent directly to Chattanooga as rapidly as he could march,
leaving two or three divisions along the line of the railroad from
Nashville forward, he could have arrived with but little fighting, and
would have saved much of the loss of life which was afterwards
incurred in gaining Chattanooga. Bragg would then not have had time
to raise an army to contest the possession of middle and east
Tennessee and Kentucky; the battles of Stone River and Chickamauga
would not necessarily have been fought; Burnside would not have been
besieged in Knoxville without the power of helping himself or
escaping; the battle of Chattanooga would not have been fought. These
are the negative advantages, if the term negative is applicable, which
would probably have resulted from prompt movements after Corinth fell
into the possession of the National forces. The positive results
might have been: a bloodless advance to Atlanta, to Vicksburg, or to
any other desired point south of Corinth in the interior of
Mississippi.
My position at Corinth, with a nominal command and yet no command,
became so unbearable that I asked permission of Halleck to remove my
headquarters to Memphis. I had repeatedly asked, between the fall of
Donelson and the evacuation of Corinth, to be relieved from duty under
Halleck; but all my applications were refused until the occupation of
the town. I then obtained permission to leave the department, but
General Sherman happened to call on me as I was about starting and
urged me so strongly not to think of going, that I concluded to
remain. My application to be permitted to remove my headquarters to
Memphis was, however, approved, and on the 21st of June I started for
that point with my staff and a cavalry escort of only a part of one
company. There was a detachment of two or three companies going some
twenty-five miles west to be stationed as a guard to the railroad. I
went under cover of this escort to the end of their march, and the
next morning proceeded to La Grange with no convoy but the few cavalry
men I had with me.
From La Grange to Memphis the distance is forty-seven miles. There
were no troops stationed between these two points, except a small
force guarding a working party which was engaged in repairing the
railroad. Not knowing where this party would be found I halted at La
Grange. General Hurlbut was in command there at the time and had his
headquarters tents pitched on the lawn of a very commodious country
house. The proprietor was at home and, learning of my arrival, he
invited General Hurlbut and me to dine with him. I accepted the
invitation and spent a very pleasant afternoon with my host, who was a
thorough Southern gentleman fully convinced of the justice of
secession. After dinner, seated in the capacious porch, he
entertained me with a recital of the services he was rendering the
cause. He was too old to be in the ranks himself--he must have been
quite seventy then--but his means enabled him to be useful in other
ways. In ordinary times the homestead where he was now living
produced the bread and meat to supply the slaves on his main
plantation, in the low-lands of Mississippi. Now he raised food and
forage on both places, and thought he would have that year a surplus
sufficient to feed three hundred families of poor men who had gone
into the war and left their families dependent upon the "patriotism"
of those better off. The crops around me looked fine, and I had at
the moment an idea that about the time they were ready to be gathered
the "Yankee" troops would be in the neighborhood and harvest them for
the benefit of those engaged in the suppression of the rebellion
instead of its support. I felt, however, the greatest respect for the
candor of my host and for his zeal in a cause he thoroughly believed
in, though our views were as wide apart as it is possible to conceive.
The 23d of June, 1862, on the road from La Grange to Memphis was
very warm, even for that latitude and season. With my staff and
small escort I started at an early hour, and before noon we arrived
within twenty miles of Memphis. At this point I saw a very
comfortable-looking white-haired gentleman seated at the front of his
house, a little distance from the road. I let my staff and escort
ride ahead while I halted and, for an excuse, asked for a glass of
water. I was invited at once to dismount and come in. I found my
host very genial and communicative, and staid longer than I had
intended, until the lady of the house announced dinner and asked me to
join them. The host, however, was not pressing, so that I declined
the invitation and, mounting my horse, rode on.
About a mile west from where I had been stopping a road comes up
from the southeast, joining that from La Grange to Memphis. A mile
west of this junction I found my staff and escort halted and enjoying
the shade of forest trees on the lawn of a house located several
hundred feet back from the road, their horses hitched to the fence
along the line of the road. I, too, stopped and we remained there
until the cool of the afternoon, and then rode into Memphis.
The gentleman with whom I had stopped twenty miles from Memphis
was a Mr. De Loche, a man loyal to the Union. He had not pressed me
to tarry longer with him because in the early part of my visit a
neighbor, a Dr. Smith, had called and, on being presented to me,
backed off the porch as if something had hit him. Mr. De Loche knew
that the rebel General Jackson was in that neighborhood with a
detachment of cavalry. His neighbor was as earnest in the southern
cause as was Mr. De Loche in that of the Union. The exact location of
Jackson was entirely unknown to Mr. De Loche; but he was sure that his
neighbor would know it and would give information of my presence, and
this made my stay unpleasant to him after the call of Dr. Smith.
I have stated that a detachment of troops was engaged in guarding
workmen who were repairing the railroad east of Memphis. On the day I
entered Memphis, Jackson captured a small herd of beef cattle which
had been sent east for the troops so engaged. The drovers were not
enlisted men and he released them. A day or two after one of these
drovers came to my headquarters and, relating the circumstances of his
capture, said Jackson was very much disappointed that he had not
captured me; that he was six or seven miles south of the Memphis and
Charleston railroad when he learned that I was stopping at the house
of Mr. De Loche, and had ridden with his command to the junction of
the road he was on with that from La Grange and Memphis, where he
learned that I had passed three-quarters of an hour before. He
thought it would be useless to pursue with jaded horses a well-mounted
party with so much of a start. Had he gone three-quarters of a mile
farther he would have found me with my party quietly resting under the
shade of trees and without even arms in our hands with which to defend
ourselves.
General Jackson of course did not communicate his disappointment
at not capturing me to a prisoner, a young drover; but from the talk
among the soldiers the facts related were learned. A day or two later
Mr. De Loche called on me in Memphis to apologize for his apparent
incivility in not insisting on my staying for dinner. He said that
his wife accused him of marked discourtesy, but that, after the call
of his neighbor, he had felt restless until I got away. I never met
General Jackson before the war, nor during it, but have met him since
at his very comfortable summer home at Manitou Springs, Colorado. I
reminded him of the above incident, and this drew from him the
response that he was thankful now he had not captured me. I
certainly was very thankful too.
My occupation of Memphis as district headquarters did not last
long. The period, however, was marked by a few incidents which were
novel to me. Up to that time I had not occupied any place in the
South where the citizens were at home in any great numbers. Dover was
within the fortifications at Fort Donelson, and, as far as I remember,
every citizen was gone. There were no people living at Pittsburg
landing, and but very few at Corinth. Memphis, however, was a
populous city, and there were many of the citizens remaining there who
were not only thoroughly impressed with the justice of their cause,
but who thought that even the "Yankee soldiery" must entertain the
same views if they could only be induced to make an honest
confession. It took hours of my time every day to listen to
complaints and requests. The latter were generally reasonable, and
if so they were granted; but the complaints were not always, or even
often, well founded. Two instances will mark the general character.
First: the officer who commanded at Memphis immediately after the
city fell into the hands of the National troops had ordered one of the
churches of the city to be opened to the soldiers. Army chaplains
were authorized to occupy the pulpit. Second: at the beginning of
the war the Confederate Congress had passed a law confiscating all
property of "alien enemies" at the South, including the debts of
Southerners to Northern men. In consequence of this law, when Memphis
was occupied the provost-marshal had forcibly collected all the
evidences he could obtain of such debts.
Almost the first complaints made to me were these two outrages.
The gentleman who made the complaints informed me first of his own
high standing as a lawyer, a citizen and a Christian. He was a deacon
in the church which had been defiled by the occupation of Union
troops, and by a Union chaplain